9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Mchenry

“Great Fox river supper club with a bar next to their dock. We ate this evening and Rachael was our server. What a great server that added to our delicious food! We highly recommend Kiefs and ask for Rachael as your server. You won't be disappointed!“

“Tonight we held a work meeting and ordered 2 family trays, everyone was working so hard when I picked up my order, even a little early, and they were all so friendly, helpful and this food was delicious! Thank you for doing such a great job for us!!“

“definitely! pizza amazing! employees enjoy their job and customers can see that. high quality of food. portion sizes are huge, Delicious and worth it. our team loves to go above and beyond for each customer, catering to every customer. will not disappoint 😁“

“Great atmosphere and amazing food - including not only the pizza, but their pasta dishes and appetizers. It’s our go to restaurant when we want pizza/pasta, or to enjoy live entertainment.“

“We came here got a beefs a burger and fries. The fries were old and super salty. & the burger was very plain and dry. Usually I don’t complain about the food because I been coming here for years but it just wasn’t good at all this time.“

“We have been here twice in the last month and I can't believe I'm just discovering what a great place this is. The food we've had has all been delicious. The staff has been very friendly as well. Prices are average. Would recommend for sure.“

“Good food,service fairly good- a bit slow then got noisy as place filled up. Loved the chic parm sandwich & onion rings and Italian stallion app.5/13/26- had the onion rings again-so good and Mag Mile pizza on hand tossed crust-good w/plenty left for a take home box. We thought it was half-price large pizza special &so did our server. She told us of the error but gave us the special price anyway- so nice!
9/10/26- went for bkfst-mountain omelet had very little bacon & needed more cheese also,love the buddyz potatoes! Server had trouble remembering things we asked for.“

“Great people great service“

“I used to live across the street from this location and ordered monthly (during football season more often) but moved to Stonewater in Wonder Lake and unfortunately no Dominoes will deliver to this subdivision (Only Papa will deliver and that place blows). Unfortunate because theres a lot of homes including mine that want Dominoes. Can you guys fix that?? You used to be able to do pin point in the neighborhood but that stopped. Anyway....the team at this store is awesome and so are the delivery drivers. Always pleasant and food is always good and on the rare occasion there was an issue it was always handled quickly and fairly. We do pick up now but would love get back on that delivery train. Keep up the good work there guys!“