13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Crystal Lake

Georgio's Chicago Pizzeria & Pub Pizza • $$
75 E Woodstock St, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Chicago Style Thin Crust Pepperoni Sausage Pizza
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza Slice
Deep Dish Pepperoni Pizza
Chicago Deep Dish Pizza
Parmesan Truffle Fries
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Papa Georgio Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Boneless Wings
Dough Nuggets

“Have ordered three times via Door Dash the past few weeks and every time food has been great!! Staying in Crystal Lakes on business with great food is a plus. Went inside to pick up an order also and the atmosphere is super cool. Will be a repeat customer always when in the area.“

4.5 Superb101 Reviews

2
Jude's

Jude's Cocktail Bar • $$
19 N Williams St, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Caramel Coconut Shrimp
Chicken Tikka Masala
Vegan Street Tacos
Filet Medallions
Ahi Tuna Tacos
Patatas Bravas
Falafel Plate
Small Plates
Avocado
Pho GA

“Jude's has quickly become one of my favorite restaurants in downtown Crystal Lake. I love the variety of internationally inspired options and the size of the plates is perfect. I brought a very large group of ladies there for Black Friday, everyone has particular tastes and was able to find something they liked. They have a very trendy area in the back with a huge couch/bench for larger parties which was so comfortable. To top it off, the staff are always kind and accommodating during our visits!“

4.5 Superb90 Reviews
That's Amore Pizza Pizza • $
105 N Main St, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

New York Style Thin Crust Sausage
Cheese Pizza and Garlic Knots
Windy City Special
Mozzarella Sticks
Wow Pizza Slices
Buffalo Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Dino's Special
Sausage Pizza
Onion Rings

“We’ve ordered from here many times, they had a new delivery driver come and missed out on our appetizer, when I called they were kind and offered to adjust the mistake. They provided a dessert as an extra too. I appreciate the customer service and would definitely recommend. Bbq chicken pizza is delicious!“

4.8 Superb28 Reviews
El Molino Pizzeria & Bakery Pizza Takeaway • $
1024 McHenry Ave, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Sausage Pizza Slice

“Pizza crust is freshly baked and you can absolutely tell this was made in a bakery. Best in the area. Also...crispiest chicken wings I’ve ever had and don’t even get me started on that tres leches cake...SO. DECADENT! Ordered here for my birthday and wasn’t disappointed!! Friendliest owners, too. Can’t wait to go back! #supportlocal“

5 Superb20 Reviews
Lucky Lulu's Deli • $
2520 IL-176 #1, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Pot Roast Sliders
Meatball Sliders
Flatbread Pizza
Sandwiches
Meatball

“Celebrated my fiancé 30th birthday there and it was the best. Kenny made sure we had everything set days before the party, showed up to the party to help out and make sure everything was great. He would keep up with checking in every so often which was nice to have the owner involved and actually care how it was all going. The bartenders were super awesome and made sure to check on everyone who was in the golf simulator on drinks and food. Overall I’m so thrilled we did his party there. Would 100% recommend lulu’s to anyone who is looking for a nice, clean, laidback vibe and overall fun. Thank you guys for being so awesome!“

4.6 Superb24 Reviews
Nancy's Pizza Pizza • $$
1295 N Randall Rd, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Create Your Own Original Thin Crust Pizza
Super Thin Crust a Lot a Meat Pizza
Super Thin Crust Uncle Tony's Pizza
Original Stuffed a Lot a Meat Pizza
Super Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Boneless Chicken Wings
Rustic Crust Pizza
Mozzarella Sticks
Garbage Salad

“This is a takeout only restaurant. Food is excellent. I ordered a small meal ahead for 2 people and was treated very well. Bill was professional and had helpful suggestions. For amazing deep dish,pasta, or cannolis I highly recommend you try this place.“

4.3 Superb41 Reviews
Chuck E. Cheese Pizza • $$
4725 Northwest Hwy, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Add a Topping to Your Large Pizza for
Pepperoni Pizza and French Fries Side
A Topping to Your Large Pizza for 2
Medium Build Your Own
Large Cheese Pizza
Medium Pizza

“I am always very impressed with how clean, organized and maintained this location is!!! Thank you for giving us a very nice place to allow our children to have fun and be safe! Management should definitely applaud their employees for keeping this place top notch!“

4.1 Good61 Reviews
Nick's Pizza & Pub Pizza • $$
856 Pyott Rd, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Double Decker Cheese Pizza
Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Award-Winning Pizza
Nick's Special
Mexican Pizza
Garlic Bread
Beer Nuggets
Italian Beef
Bruschetta

“Love eating at this place! Great food for either dining in or carry out. On Tuesdays the dining area is closed and they just have a drive-through "buy one get one free" pizza deal which we participate on a regular basis. The workers are very friendly and food is always good. Also they have peanuts you can eat and toss the shells on the floor which pairs well with the Northwoods, rustic themed atmosphere.“

3.9 Good129 Reviews
Pinemoor Pizza Pizza • $
11 Crystal Lake Plaza, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Sausage and Mushroom Pizza
Large Pepperoni Pizza
12 in Garbage Pizza

“I don’t make a ton of reviews but I had to review Pinemoor because this place knows thin crust pie better than anyone in a 25 mile radius, I’m convinced. I’ve tried just about every other pizza spot in Crystal Lake and none of them have even a contender spot in the race against Pinemoor. The crust alone is a perfectly imperfect canvas, and the sauce is exactly what any true pie lover would want the artist to paint it with. Next time I’m getting extra sauce on top! 6/5 stars all day. I found my new favorite local pie joint, and it’s Pinemoor.“

4.2 Good29 Reviews
Mug's Pizza & Ribs Pizza •
230 W Virginia St #600, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Philly Cheese Steak
Deep Dish Pizza
Steak Fries
Side Salad
Mug

“I have been ordering from here for dinner where I work. We all aty work enjoy the pizza & appetizer. I ordered a Chicken Ceasar salad, a small BLT pizza & an Italian Beef with giardiniera with a side of adjustable. Well my coworker told me she only received 1 small Ceasar dressing for the salad (2 or 3 for the salad would have it nicely covered), Italian Beef was a fully disappointment. I would NEVER recommend that at all. The menu for the Italian Beef is NOT true at all. The menu says "NOW WITH MORE MEAT", well I received more giardiniera then meat. When I called she told me that it was 6ozs. of meat that all beefs get. I can tell you as a former line cook that packaged Italian Beef that what I received was NOT 6ozs since I packaged 7ozs of Italian Beef. I DO NOT recommend the Italian Beef at all. I was excited to get the be since all I heard was good things but when I received it and looked at the sandwich it was giardiniera with very little Italian Beef and I received 2 large containers of auju. I was really DISAPPOINTED on the sandwich and the answer that they gave me. If your menu says "NOW WITH MORE MEAT" 6ozs is not enough. It was a GIARDINIERA sandwich with Italian beef... Other pizza I will not order anything else. VERY DISAPPOINTED.... Pictures will be posted...“

3.9 Good57 Reviews
Rosati's Pizza Pizza • $$
40 W Terra Cotta Ave #3540, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Garlic Bread
Pizza

“Had ordered a pizza for myself and a few coworkers. Asked to have it cut pie style but the employee cut it square style.It was a timed work lunch so I didn't have time to wait and have it remade as they suggested. In return they gave me 50% off the pizza and a 2 liter of Pepsi for the inconvenience.As I explained it was not the end of the world. The staff was very apologetic and I left a very satisfied customer.Oh and as a bonus....the pizza was devoured by all!“

3.6 Good33 Reviews
Tommy's Red Hots Pizza • $
363 W Virginia St, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

The Tommy Burger with Fries & 24 Oz Drink
Hot Dog with Sport Peppers and Fries
Chicken Gyros & Fries w Large Pop
Chicken Gyros with Fries & Drink
Breaded Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Gyros Sandwich
Double Cheeseburger
Greek Gyros Salad
Italian Beef
12 Veggie Sub

“Always fast and fresh. But the last two times we went, our beefs are never dipped when we ask for it. Thats a bummer. But they are always good at getting the orders together correctly, like we get all things but the minute errors happen. Food still tastes good though.“

3.5 Good51 Reviews
Rookies Sports Bar & Grill (Crystal Lake) American • $$
72 N Williams St, Crystal Lake

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Mac and Cheese
Turkey Club

“Great sports bar with lots of Chicago sports memorabilia, great service from a lot of friendly staff, but the food only hits halfway home. The pizza comes in two kinds of cooked; either halfway done or really overcooked and still undercooked under its shell. But the wings? They're an amazing different story. Better than Buffalo Wild Wings to me.“

3.5 Good73 Reviews
Loading...
map Map