13 Best Pizza Restaurants in Niles

“I've driven by the place for a year and kept thinking I should drop in. Finally stopped for a slice last month, and went back to try their smash burger just recently.

Love the place. They have excellent food and a kicky little interior, but I loved chatting with the owner as he made my food. One of the owners, at least. Anyway, curious to try their other offerings, and happy to meet a local small business owner and find them to be just good people. To me, that has more impact than the menu. But the menu is worth the trip, all the same!

I know the owner reads these reviews, so I say thank you for your excellent efforts. It's not a small thing to feed strangers food made with care and love, and it matters to some of us when we see it. Nothing but the best to you, my friend.“

“Absolutely delicious! I would totally recommend. 🫶🏻“

“We had a great time at Old City Pizzeria & Sports Bar! Everything we ordered was fresh and really delicious. The pizza was excellent, the appetizers were great, and the portions were very generous. The atmosphere is comfortable and welcoming, and the service was friendly and attentive. We really enjoyed our evening here. Thank you guys for the great food and hospitality! We’ll definitely be back. Highly recommend! 🍕👏“

“My first time here and will not be my last. One of the best beef shawarma pizzas I’ve had. The people are great and the service is excellent.“

“Fantastic experience. Food was delicious. We will definitely be coming back.“

“Happy 2026! This is my first video review, and I’m starting strong with Vince’s Pizza in Niles, IL. Hands down, this is the best pizza spot I’ve had in the Chicagoland area. In my opinion, it’s as good as, if not better than, Pantaleone’s in Denver, Colorado. The quality of the pizza is outstanding. It easily surpasses every slice I tried at Pizza Fest Chicago 2025. Vince uses incredibly fresh ingredients, and it shows in every bite. The crust is exceptional, honestly on par with some of the best pizza spots in NYC. Service is top-notch. Vince himself is the owner, chef, cashier, and server, which adds a personal touch you don’t find often. He’s friendly, welcoming, and happy to offer recommendations based on what you like. It’s no surprise he’s been a multiple-year Pizza Wars winner. On top of that, the pricing is unbeatable for the size and quality, easily better value than places like Rosati’s, Viccino’s Pizza Company, and Giordano’s. The ambiance feels like stepping into an old-school neighborhood pizza shop. It’s nostalgic, warm, and refreshing, something that’s becoming harder and harder to find. Final recommendation: Try the pizza by the slice (it’s massive basically a quarter of a pie), the Vince’s Special, or the Meat Lovers. You’ll leave more than satisfied and definitely wanting to come back. Highly recommend supporting this amazing small, local business.“

“Just ordered from them for my family and loved the pizza. I believe this store is Family owned and very friendly, talked to the manager for future catering orders and seemed like a sweet deal. I was pleased with the great coupon deals they had to offer. Looking to order from them again.“

“Been going here for DECADES! Great Pizza“

“We have been going there for over a year on the first Friday of every month to see the free live music! It is always a great time and family friendly. The kids really get into the music. The band is excellent, providing music of all genres. If they have live music every Friday, we would be there every Friday! The staff is great and the food above average! See you the first Friday of every month!“

“We called in earlier in the day just to see if they could accommodate a group 15 boys for pizza right after a birthday party at Altitude nearby. When we got there, they had decorated an area for us with signs and balloons for no extra charge. Much appreciated!“

“Friendly invirrment slots,music,“

“Peter and Devon make the yummiest food! Always love coming here, fast service and great costumer service“