50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Bargersville

“Just finished an amazing dinner and our waitress, Izzy (sorry if I spelled it wrong), was amazing!! And to have the manager (Amanda) super sweet, serve us our food, special touch! Pizza is great, calamari was fresh, at the atmosphere is so relaxing. We will be back.“

“Outstanding service, good food, highly recommended“

“This was my first time trying NY Slice, and I’m hooked! Easily the best pizza place around. When I walked in to order a slice of cheese pizza and some garlic knots, what would typically be a routine and not-a-second-thought-given stop, turned out to be the highlight of my day and amazing food. Dan, the owner, immediately welcomed me and wanted to have a conversation. This was so refreshing compared to today’s service industry. Dan is a one man show and I was so impressed with the quality of his food. You can tell he takes pride in his food and his customer service. The food is freshly made to order and so delicious. Please support this local small business - I promise it’s better than any chain pizza place around.“

“Great breadsticks and deep dish pizza with friendly service“

“We had a party of 16 to celebrate Mother’s Day. The manager sat us at two large tables, ran a tab on us so I could pay after all orders were in. Kelly was our server and did a fantastic job. Everyone got what they wanted and the food was delicious from pizzas, salads, pastas, breadsticks! Thank you for making our meal a huge success!“

“I got a pepperoni pizza and the garlic bread. First time trying it. Food was delivered and was hot and fresh. Pizza has a familiar classic flavor which is absolutely delicious and what I was craving. Excellent cheese sauce. I tried to find something to complain about but couldn’t. This is perfect. Don’t change a thing!“

“Great food and unique menu that adds a bit of goodness to an already old style pizza.“

“We had an early dinner here. First time at the Spicy Donor, and don’t have much experience with Indian food, but really enjoyed the chicken Marsala. The food was really good but a little pricey. However, we had lots of leftovers, so we’ll get more meals from it. We’ll be back and bring others!“

“Went through the drive through to pick up a mobile order, and was greeted with a warm smile. The guy went to go pick up the mobile, but it unfortunately wasn’t ready. After he told us that it would take 2 more minutes I expressed my interest for his hat, and he told me he would get one on his next order for the store, which was very kind of him.

Dietary restrictions: For gluten free and sugar free the wings really work, with many flavors to choose from they become a favorite in my family with everyone fighting, and craving for them.“

“I’m from the East coast and Midwest pizza doesn’t do it for me, This place has the best pie I’ve had since moving to Indiana. Star is very friendly and fast!“

“My wife n I love this place“

“Best owner and restaurant. For about 5 years I've been eating here and never once have had a bad meal or service. The owner takes care of the customer quite surprisingly well. I'm always eagered to eat here. My favorite is the deep dish pizza. It's a signature joy to eat and never get tired of it. Highly recommend“

“This locations is FANTASTIC! We reserved their party room this afternoon for my 3 year old’s birthday party. I was able to decorate how I wanted, and the manager on duty asked if I needed help with any of it. Our party was a bit bigger than the room and we ended up spreading out to another good half of the restaurant, and they didn’t mind. The food came out hot, they provided all the plates and silverware, and ice. They said not to worry about trash, that they would come and get everything but we wanted to take care of it ourselves so they rolled a trash can over for us to use, told us to help ourselves to the ice dispenser and whatever else we needed they helped with. We weren’t charged to use the room and the bill was extremely budget-friendly even! They were incredibly patient, kind, and accommodating and I could not thank them enough, they earned every penny of their tips and more. This location and its employees are wonderful!“

“worst Marco's experience ever this evening. phoned in a delivery order at 605 pm. took over 10 minutes to take my order correctly. confirmed correct delivery address. was told about an hour for delivery. paid by card over the phone. hour and a half go by so I called to check on the order. was told they had the wrong address. I said it is the correct address, my home, was confirmed when ordering. was told then that I could come pick it up. was told they do not have delivery anymore tonight. asked if they were going to comp anything and was told no. said I could get a refund. no apology from mgmt. was told manager on duty's name was Mercedes. WORST experience at this location EVER“

“This is a very convenient place to get pizza when my wife gets her hair done next door. And the pizza is very good. They will take an order to pick up later and it is always ready. They have lunch specials which we haven’t used yet, but they seem popular. Good variety of pizzas, reasonably priced.“

“A Big shout out to Dave and his staff for being so gracious and accommodating. Miss Betty's suprise party was a huge success. The food as always was delicious and the service fantastic. We will definitely be back! Thanks again.“

“Today we went here to eat, they were very busy and under staffed. everyone was trying their best to do what they could. Our food took a long time to come out and one of our meals was cold. They were so apologetic and comped our whole meal which we were not expecting. The food was fantastic and the employees were great! We will be back. I will recommend this place to other people.“

“Everything the food and service were great!!“

“Great place. Never disappoints.

9/15/24- Service was a little slow, but I heard there was only one server. Prices are high for basic pizza. I brought 2 kids and a large, one topping pizza with 8 bread sticks and 3 drinks was $46. So about $56, with tip. I feel like I could get a lot better pizza for that price. Prices seem to have just about doubled since COVID. I wish they offered some type of meal deal. I can get a large pizza and 2 liter from Jack's for half that. Obviously, the experience adds value, but there should be a more economical option.“

“I recently had the pleasure of experiencing outstanding customer service at Domino’s, thanks to the manager, Eric. I brought an autistic teen to the store who is passionate about working at a pizza establishment, but someone had recently discouraged his dream. Eric went above and beyond to make this visit unforgettable. Not only did he welcome us warmly, but he also allowed us to watch him make pizzas, which was incredibly exciting for the teen. Eric took the time to explain the history of Domino's, offering valuable insights and encouragement. His words of wisdom—urging the youth to follow his dreams no matter what others say—were truly inspiring.

Eric was kind, thoughtful, and genuinely invested in making a difference. He was a beacon of positivity and encouragement, and I am so grateful for the impact he had on this young person. Thank you, Eric, for your time, your kindness, and for being a true role model. You made a lasting impression, and we left the store feeling inspired and hopeful. You truly made a difference today!“

“The pizza is out of this world! A ton of beer choices. Pretzel appetizer was delicious. Server was cheerful and perfect as far as checking in on us & what we needed. We're from out of town and it's one of our favorite places every time we visit. Get you some!!!“

“Great food, fast service and super friendly employees!👏🏻🍕“

“This is our favorite date night place! Great service and food!“

“FAMILY IN FOR LATE LUNCH AND ALTHOUGH A OFFICE PARTY WAS UNDERWAY THE SERVICE WAS EXCELLENT AND QUICK.
FOOD WAS 4 to 4.5 ALL AROUND
NOISE LEVEL AND CHAIRS WERE COMFORTABLE.
WILL BE BACK SOON. ?

Parking: Handicap accessible spaces close to entry.

Wheelchair accessibility: Excellent“

“Very nice, professional staff. Good pizza. No complaints.“

“Great pizza beer and drinks.
They need a vestibule at entry door - just a little cold each time door opened
Service and staff excellent. Very quick and checked in with us often
Cannot believe been in Greenwood for many years and this is first visit
Will come in often now. 😎

Wheelchair accessibility: Handicap accessible throughout.“

“Jacks pizza always comes through. I call, they already know what I want, and they get it here pipping hot! Tonight I was told 45-an hour and on my custom order. Was here in 20 smokin hot!!! Thanks Jacks!!“

“Roscoe Tacos launched Lisa's Pizza. if you are in or near Indianapolis, IN this is a must stop. The pizzas are made to order with fresh ingredients and the best cheese and crust around. i had the opportunity to try the Snake Bite and have to say it is a new favorite. The pizzas are loaded with toppings and they don't skimp on cheese. they have dine in and take out. Seen dashers walk in and its ready to go! There is something for everyone.“

“I order an extra large pizza about every two weeks. The pizza is amazing. I order through uber eats. I would highly recommend if you want some good pizza.“

“No complaints on the food but service was not good. I was there 5 mins while I saw 2 older dudes preparing a large order 2mins went by I saw a young dude walk by didn’t ask if I’ve been service.Then another 2 mins went a different young dude walked by didn’t ask me anything. The first young dude came back took an order over the phone then walked away. Another 2 mins the same young dude came back to ask to take my order.“

“I had an issue on Saturday night with my pizza not being delivered and I called the store and spoke to Chris the general manager today. Extremely impressed with his professionalism, kindness, and understanding. He made it so right. Very happy customer. Thanks for having such great employees domino’s❤️“

“My first time here and the Pizza Bowl was AMAZING!! I wish I had found you guys sooner!“

“My husband and I always order from Jacks, and it is ALWAYS really good! Today is was AMAZING!! The Madison store is the one we always go to. I talked to the manager Derek, to tell him how great the pizza and breadsticks were today, and come to find out hewas the one who made the pizza today..... Thank you Derek, the pizza was A.M.A.Z.I.N.G!“

“Staff went above and beyond to make my son's birthday special after he picked Kacey's for his birthday dinner. As always, food was hot, fresh and delicious.“

“Great origan Pizza connect with Nature“

“Good ole home style Indiana pizza. Fast and friendly service, and the pizza is absolutely delicious. Helps me get my fix from similar pizza I used to get in Knightstown. Love it!“

“We ordered Noble Roman’s through DoorDash. The pizza, wings, and cheesy garlic bread were truly impeccable! Their Sicilian style pizza is unlike anything I’ve had before! The cheese goes on the bottom, and the sauce goes on top! Sounds wild, right? It was delicious! This place is so awesome, I took my girlfriend here for a nice date and was treated to the same delicious food, and incredible service. Thanks guys! Good job!“

“This Jet's Pizza is a good one order ahead
Although if you order for lunch for two slices of pizza you're going to give me 45 minutes time frame that's completely unacceptable shouldn't you have slices for when people come in? This is the second time I've been told 30 to 45 minutes for two slices of pizza“

“My favorite pizza place!! Me and my family have been going here since I was a child. I would recommend the Carson St location. Not a sit down place they have carryout or delivery which is good for us.“

“Really good pasta just skimpy as usual on the salad. Your company has been doing this for at least 2 years.“

“Absolutely delicious pizza and breadsticks once again! Thank you for great service and delicious pizza! Kirby C.“

“Jacks pizza always comes through. I call, they already know what I want, and they get it here pipping hot! Tonight I was told 45-an hour and on my custom order. Was here in 20 smokin hot!!! Thanks Jacks!!“

“Love this place. Great Food and Service“

“I order an extra large pizza about every two weeks. The pizza is amazing. I order through uber eats. I would highly recommend if you want some good pizza.“

“My favorite day of the week is Friday, when straight after work, I order a pie from this location. Not only is their POTW half price (such a lifesaver on a tight budget), but I have never had anything less than great food and great service. The food is always fresh and never once has my order been wrong or something forgotten. I order delivery and they are always on time and the nicest delivery drivers I have ever met. Shoutout to my usual delivery drivers Chase and Giovanni! Hotbox Pizza in Greenwood will always have my business as long as they continue the excellence.“

“I am so happy to see Papa Murphy is open. I have been waiting almost 9 months since the Thompson's closed on the southside. I was pleasantly surprised seeing the "Captain" from the Thompson store come out and welcome me. This establishment is all the same, the pizza was delicious with generous portions of the toppings. The staff was so friendly, and the store is very clean. I told them I will be back at least once a week. HAPPY customer.“

“We had the BEST birthday party experience. I he staff could not have been better. Easy, affordable, and would definitely recommend.“