12 Best Pizza Restaurants in Plainfield

“One of the best place for pizzas traditional pizza or twisted pizza. Best taste“

“Such a cute spot for family dinners & amazing food! The only pizza place that doesn’t give me heartburn too. The cheese w/feta added is spectacular! The other one I’ve had is the roma and that is delicious as well. They’re fairly priced and local, love it!“

“This was the best pizza we’ve ever had. Thanks so much! We will be back next year!“

““Excellent pizza and great customer service! The pizza was fresh, hot, and full of flavor. The breadsticks were amazing, and the staff was friendly and welcoming. My order was prepared quickly, and everything tasted delicious. Definitely one of my favorite pizza places in Plainfield. I’ll be coming back again soon!”“

“We moved to Clayton in January and CJ’s has become our favorite easy dinner night! Wonderful food, amazing staff, and let’s not forget the huge portions! Tonight we decided to try delivery and Caiden was AMAZING!! Super polite and very friendly. 100/10 recommend“

“Papa Murphys is our go-to place for pizza . There is nothing better than getting a good pizza hot from your own oven. My favorite pizza was the chicken bacon artichoke, but it hasn't been right for a long time. The bottom of the crust always looks like it's been boiled in oil. But there other pizzas are still very“

“HANDS DOWNTHE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER HAD ON THE WEST SIDE & I AM A CONNOISSEUR OF PIZZA!!!¡!!!!!IT'S LIKE OLD JACK'S PIZZA, BUT BETTER,! THERE USED TO BE A JACKS OFF PENDLETON PIKE, IN INDY ! HARD TO DUPLICATE EVEN HARDER TO MASTER AND DO BETTER THEN.“

“03-12-2026

I'm eating in my pizza. The three young ladies who are working in house are awesome. I think 95% all work environments wish that they had the teamwork/respect for one another.. wait they talking about doing hair with a other custoomer, and I need a retwist... 10 stars if I could.“

“We ate here for the first time over the weekend and will be back! The food was amazing!! If you like potato soup order it, you won't be sorry!! Tenderloins are also some of the best I have ever had! Owner is very personable!!!“

“When we come into Indy for the Indy mini half marathon, we always stay at the same hotel over by Nonna‘s so Italian so we could get our carbs in the night before. Well, this last weekend we were there for a family wedding and we ordered a pizza ahead so we could have it when we got to the hotel. It was all perfect till I got to the hotel and they called me to tell me we received the wrong pizza two people with the same last name ordered at the same time. They were so gracious and let us keep the pizza we had even though it was probably more expensive than what we had ordered, but we didn’t have much time to wait or return it. So gracious of them to make it so easy on us and let me tell you that pizza was delicious.“

“This Little Ceasars location has always been pretty good to us, so I feel I should express that here. I saw all of the negative reviews were like 2018-2020, so I suppose could have been some mismanagement going on at that time. But having been to Little Cesar's dozens of times between ~ 2021-2024 they have always been very friendly and have almost never messed up our order. They also always give my little girl a free bag of cookies when we come through, so she is always excited when we go to eat here.“

“Kara rocks! She went above and beyond on Thanksgiving eve with 10 minutes to spear from the time I ordered to receiving my food was under 15 minutes!! She deserves a raise for sure family customer service and dedication she has. I appreicate you and so does Eric!!!“