13 Best Italian Restaurants near Plainfield

“Absolutely amazing restaurant! The food was perfect and the waiter we had was just such a great person. We truly felt we were in a 5 star high end restaurant in NYC but with good portions and very reasonable prices. We plan on going back many times to this restaurant and also getting the word out about how great this place is.“

“When we come into Indy for the Indy mini half marathon, we always stay at the same hotel over by Nonna‘s so Italian so we could get our carbs in the night before. Well, this last weekend we were there for a family wedding and we ordered a pizza ahead so we could have it when we got to the hotel. It was all perfect till I got to the hotel and they called me to tell me we received the wrong pizza two people with the same last name ordered at the same time. They were so gracious and let us keep the pizza we had even though it was probably more expensive than what we had ordered, but we didn’t have much time to wait or return it. So gracious of them to make it so easy on us and let me tell you that pizza was delicious.“

“Very casual atmosphere and the food was awesome! Sals pizza was our choice today. Will definitely be going back.“

“5⭐️ Very friendly & accommodating staff“

“Olive Garden is my comfort food and today was a long day after a long month after a long year, so coming in and meeting Amy was a true blessing! I got my drink right on time as I always, the food was spot on delicious and Amy was super attentive and with me ! Thank you so much for continuing to be my favorite restaurant to visit whenever I’m celebrating or just wanting to feel good again !“

“Great food and good friendly service . Priced right for what you get“

“Always a great time and a wonderful team and great atmosphere and attitude. The service is always attentive especially with my little whose on the Autism Spectrum.We've been going here since 2020 never had a bad experience. Thank you Fazolis for being so kind and supportive. And definitely our favorite place to go in Avon!!“

“My wife and I like to just take off to a random town close and visit a Resteraunt that is not a chain Resteraunt . So Italian exceeded all of the expectations we had . Service from staff was on point and friendly . Menu was easy to navigate . Food was awesome !! Definitely a 10 out of 10 on all levels . Will be recommending and visiting again .“

“This location allowed my high school reunion class to be hosted here. The Sals team on Saturday night 9/28/24 were fabulous! We had approximately 70 people and the place was packed. The Sal's team handled everything like Pros! I recommend this place for their excellent service and food. Support a local small business when you can!“

“Stayed at the hotel all weekend for the NATO Tournament and got the chance to eat here each night, Jamie was a excellent server and was quick and had the best memory I’ve seen in years she knew what we wanted before we even walked into the door!“

“It's always amazing. Service and food are always on point. There was a large group of women (about 18 of them) who were extremely loud and made the experience of being in the restaurant pretty awful. We love the food and service, so we will obviously be back, but it was difficult to enjoy anything with that much noise in the background“

“Always great food and friendly staff“

“The food quality at this Avon location has always been good for us, but today I feel compelled to leave a review after the manager (Manny) far exceeded my expectations.

In short, my son has a peanut allergy, which we briefly noted for consideration in the comments when ordering online. Upon visiting the store for pickup, Manny came out to personally discuss with great transparency the potential sources of contamination/risk.

Not only did Manny offer order adjustments to ensure we had edible food for what we paid, but he clearly prepared for the discussion and went out of his way to ensure my family's safety -- I can't adequately express my appreciation for someone going this far.

If you want great pizza (and more) and value the quality of service/support behind the counter, this is the place for you.“