New American Restaurants in Carmel, IN

“amazing food and great service even with a packed house.“

“Came in with a group, we had the upstairs room then told we had to be gone by 7pm We reserved the room at 515. So with that said, servers ok. Food came at 645. Manager told the group that we need to be out by then. 7pm because it was reserved for another group at 7. He told us that the staff didn’t inform him about it. Really kinda not our problem at that time. We were 30+ strong. Kids and all. I walked out at 715. Doesn’t seem right. Not mad but a concern with staff and communication. Food good, service ok, slow at times , restaurant was not totally full. I could see open tables. Yes I would come back, but come on. The manager should have known of the situation and made a plan B the weather was in the 70’s they could have used the courtyard. Ok sorry done.“

“Divvy is one of my favorite places to go for an evening out! I always have a wonderful time. The food is delicious, the service is exceptional and the atmosphere is wonderful. I look forward to the next time I get to go! I can't wait to try the brunch!“

“The food here is absolutely FANTASTIC, scratch kitchen perfection. Great service and atmosphere! You cannot go wrong here.“

“Despite running through the rain to get into the restaurant the restaurant was a fantastic experience. The specials they had was excellent for the price, the cheese on the sticks are out of this world. There were six of us and all six of us enjoyed our meals and the service we had was excellent. We will be going back.“

“Wonderful lunch and waiter Rick. Thank you“

“Love the variety on the menu, the multiple dining areas and the way the history of the building has been preserved. Woodys has been a favorite of mine in downtown Carmel for a while now!“

“What a great restaurant with amazing food ! It is hidden in a hotel but wow! We are so glad we came in! The scallops were perfection and the staff all friendly and smiling ...happy to be there! It was really refreshing and the chef even made a special request for my daughter of grilled shrimp! We will definitely be back!!!“

“We only stopped by for a beer. The service was excellent. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. The food looked good but we already ate. Ordered the Church Milk Stout and it was delicious and smooth. At over 6% one was enough. Tried the Jack Ringo. Very hot finish!“

“Olivia was an incredible server — friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely enthusiastic. She created such a welcoming atmosphere that made it easy and fun to explore different wines. The vibes were fantastic, and I couldn’t recommend this place more!“

“Fantastic first experience. Great food, wonderful service and comfortable ambience. Had a rehearsal meal here for approximately 35 people early afternoon and we all had a great time. The buffet brunch was well managed and the food was thoughtfully prepared and quite tasty. I recommended will return.“