16 Best Pizza Restaurants near Centerville

“I’m in Centerville Indiana I’m from New York City that Godfather pizza is absolutely the truth. I mean I can eat this all damn day good. Definitely another stop worth it while passing through 5 stars guys you know it’s good when you stop eating it just to write this review“

“Hostess refused to seat us because she was told they had to "leave a table open incase people are on a wait". However, no one was on a wait... just us, waiting for a table. and another table was leaving, and she refused to sit us there too because we were a party of 2. told we would have to wait 20-25 minutes, just incase that table needs to be given to someone else. Make it make sense. We won't be back.“

“I’ve eaten here 2-3 a week for a few years now and never once had bad food. The local employees are always friendly and service with a smile! Also, make sure you park outside please.“

“Great quality food and service..we love the staff they're like family and know us by name! Local Great food options with sandwiches and pizza! Love the convince. We generally get carryout, always hot and fresh! Thank you to all the staff! Great job!“

“We are visiting from Maine, after reading the previous reviews, we headed over and got a large sub to go, back to the fairgrounds. It was giant, fresh & delicious! I felt the price was low, considering the ingredients. The bread was so good. Fast & friendly & they were very busy as it was lunchtime. Well done!“

“Food was fantastic service was great“

“I been ordering here for 4-5 years and have had 3-5 orders messed up other than that has always been perfect they go above and beyond whenever you need them to as well and have no problem accepting special requests either over the phone or in person.“

“They still took my order even though it was 1:29 p.m. haven't had anything to eat all day. And my girlfriend is going to be hungry when she gets home I figured this was my last option. They took my order without hesitation was very nice about it and I couldn't give they are compliments to Samara and the crew. Absolutely fantastic!“

“The best every DAY“

“This is the best pizza in town. The ingredients are quality and the food is amazing! Nothing better than a home town pizza place that blows the competition away! 🍕“

“I can't stay away from the Brie Burger. Its so good. Every time I go there it is always great. The staff, the food, the drinks and the atmosphere is on point. Try it and you won't regret it. Not to mention the great photos on every wall. Thank you Legends.“

“We just had the best pizza we’ve had in years delivered to us!! Everything was so fresh. It was amazing! Thanks guys, you will definitely be our go to place for pizza for now on!“

“The kid’s spaghetti ?“

“Looks clean and well taken care of. Don't be fooled by the rough exterior. Only downside is it's pretty small so you're probably not going to find a crowd to mingle with. Mostly local regulars. Friendly atmosphere, friendly people. Food is acceptable for bar food but nothing special.“

“Have to get half my pizza with no onions because of an allergy in my house. Even had a long talk with a super sweet girl last time who said she added it to my order. Got my order tonight with onions all thru it, not a huge deal, just stopped eating and called the manager. Well he said that HE made the pizza and he knows it’s made correctly because he did it himself. Sir, I legit am looking at the things…..whatever you think u did, was just a facade….cause you’re delusional. Super rude and condescending. Tried to be nice at the end and offer to remake the pizza, like not now that you’ve been a jerk, I don’t wanna eat body fluids…..needless to say, won’t be eating here again. Sad day…….UPDATE scott from corporate called me and made everything better. For the most part. Still a crappy supper, but it’s nice to be called and validated in what you said when he had already verified through recorded lines that what i said was the truth. Thanks scott.“

“The ladies running the front are always so nice and helpful. Great attitudes and kind hearts.

Amazing steaks, the salad always hits the spot and the brownie with ice cream for dessert so yum.

This place is a must to go.

Relax, watch your game, eat some amazing food and don’t forget to tip these wonderful people serving you. Without them we wouldn’t have such a great place to enjoy. 💛🙏🏼☀️God bless.💕“