New American Restaurants near Covington, IN

“We went here for the first time this evening! The service was amazing! The waitress was very friendly, and the food was phenomenal! I got the Filet with waffle fries and a salad, my husband got the Prime rib with a baked potato and salad! Literally EVERYTHING was so good! We can’t wait to go back!“

“Stepping back in time. An old-fashioned Supper Club experience. When we travel to southern Indiana we always stop here for lunch. the food is terrific and the servers are fast, efficient and friendly. Your meal is served fast and it is pipping hot. They normally have a buffet that always has desirable choices. But it is the dinner rolls. Those are magnificent! BUT they must be eaten hot. I also traveled to Indianapolis for business and stopped by a couple of times on the way home to pick up a couple of fresh strip steaks to cook at home (the butcher departments offering is better than anything we have at home by a WIDE margin) but I was not able to get the rolls to return to their just-out-of-the-oven freshness. But eaten at the restaurant they are ridiculous. The butter melts over the soft and chewy perfectly cooked roll and I dare you not to think of your grandmas Sunday dinner rolls. Looking forward to our next visit.“

“My new husband and I were out exploring our little corner of the world during our post-wedding/pre-honeymoon staycation and happened to find I & I Steakhouse and we’re so glad we did! The food was delicious, the service was fantastic and the back patio is a whole vibe. The grapefruit mimosa was bomb and I love that there’s crayons with a butcher paper tablecloth, it would be so fun for kiddos! (and grown women with ADHD✨) It’s not too far from home and would make for a delightful night out with good vibes between the touchtunes box and great food. We went during lunch so it was pretty easy to find a table, there’s a sign that says “seat yourself unless there’s a wait” and lemme tell you, we’d wait ?“

“I am a truck driver and by recommendation started ordering from I & I with Doordash. I have ordered several times. Usually get the Bacon Double Cheese Burger. If I have a complaint it is that the Doordash app does not offer a mayo, catchup, mustard tab. The burger is amazing enough that I eat it without mayo but would be nice if I could get mayo and catchup. Order fries and never get catchup with them either. This is the sole reason for the 4's. Will keep ordering. Just hope that this can be fixed. Will give 5's when it is.“