13 Best Sandwich Shops in Elkhart

“Mae always does a great job bringing in lunch!! Very dependable 😃“

“Restaurant is small, so not much seating, but not a problem as it's never been packed when I have been in there. Sandwiches are really good, toasted, with a solid amount of meat. They also have a propriety Mountain Dew flavor called Vibe, which isnt bad, worth a try if you like Mountain Dew. Parking lot is more than adequate for easy parking. My only complaint was that the kids don't fit their medium cups, it was very weird. Won't stop us from coming back again. Definitely recommend the sandwiches.“

“I have had good luck with this Jimmy John’s. Not every order has been perfect but nothing that has made me regret ordering. Today the delivery driver went above and beyond. I spilled my drink just inside my doorway and she stayed to help me clean it up. I’m a paraplegic so cleaning liquids on the floor can be a little tough for me. She even drove back and got me another drink after we cleaned up the one I spilled. I didn’t get her name but she definitely went above and beyond when she didn’t have to do any of it. I appreciate her help and kindness. She’s definitely a keeper.“

“I was wondering if the driver of the Jimmy Johns jeep found the duck on the door handle?“

“Vegetarian options: Don't do vegetarian but they have veggie anything

Dietary restrictions: Best subs EVER

Parking: Easy in and out

Kid-friendliness: Absolutely

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“Wonderful worker there tonight on 2/5/23 around 5pm. She was absolutely sweet. I have a big family and order 7 subs. Normally we get some kind of grunt or attitude when saying how many subs. She was cheerful and said we would get through it together. She made everything perfect, with no attitude and a smile on her face. Didn't get her name but big kudos to her for being so pleasant.“

“My girlfriend and I stopped at this Subway for dinner after an exhausting week. Just a couple days ago, we had a funeral service for her son who passed away from leukemia. As soon as we entered this Subway, our spirits were immediately lifted by the cheerful demeanor of Dre and Brian who were running the place.

It is extremely rare anymore to encounter workers who seem genuinely happy and make you feel like you've been best friends with them for years. We got to talking and sharing our experiences with each other, including heartache that both of them have been enduring.

This was more than just a food pickup. This was a complete reawakening of our faith in people and I am deeply grateful to Dre and Brian for the hope and smile they helped put on my girlfriend's face. If either of them read this, Dre, my girlfriend was the lady in the black cap who held your hands and told you never to forget her face and she wouldn't forget yours.

Both of you are a true testament to the strength of humanity in the most difficult times and any place of business would be lucky to have you representing them. God bless both of you and may your light continue to shine. Thank you both. Truly! - Josiah and Regina“

“They're pretty good. Every now and then they'll run out of my fav bread, italian herbs and cheese, but it is the best!? occasionally the bread is dry, but we usually order later, like 7-8 pm so... Usually they're great! Would recommend.“

“The store is always so clean and organized. They have very friendly staff and I feel comfortable eating there. They are fast and efficient as well, always making sure no one stays in line very long, bringing additional team members to help when needed.

Vegetarian options: Veggie pizza was very good!

Parking: Plenty of parking options“

“We came in around 7 o’clock and Thomas helped us, he listened when I said EXTRA pickles. Usually people only put a little extra but I really wanted a ridiculous amount of pickles and Thomas did not disappoint. I’m never going to another subway“

“I always check to make sure my favorite Sandwich artist, Samantha, is working before I place an order. She makes the experience fun, and puts your sandwich together in some kind of magical way that makes it taste just a little bit better than anyone else. She should definitely be the one in charge around there.“

“Today, a coworker of mine came to your location and ordered a Philly cheese steak sandwich. To his chagrin, it had peppers and mushrooms. Both of which he apparently hates. In his disgust, he offered me his sandwich after which he called to complain. All the while, I ate and very much enjoyed the delicious sandwich. This is the 2nd time this has happened to him thus the 2nd time I got a great sandwich!! Thank you!!“

“Whenever I'm passing through for lunch, I come here. The people here are friendly and work fast.Just today I came in and one of the guys greeted me with a smile. I got a vito sandwich and the guy has it ready before I finished paying! Dude is faster than the card reader.“