33 Best Ice Cream Shops in Evansville

“Great ice cream and great service. I highly recommend them.“

“After a long morning baking and then delivering pies for Pi Day, We stopped in for a couple slices and a quick break. The service and pizza was perfect! The pistachio slice is absolutely perfection! 🍒❤️🍒“

“We had an amazing lunch and service was exceptional!
We had Cierra to assist us and she was more than helpful and helped us decide by suggesting a few of her favs and we now have our own favs!
Last time we were there our service was not that great so having someone like her this time made us miss not coming in lately from past experiences!
Big top is where it’s at!!!!

Kid-friendliness: I have a 5 year whom was made to feel right at home right away and Cierra as well suggested the chili to him so of course he had to have it and loves it now!“

“First time ever here today. I got a large double cheese burger and fries. Both were amazing. The girl who took my order was very friendly and the owner was nice too. I'll definitely come back!

Parking: Easy parking. Plenty of room.

Wheelchair accessibility: Easily accessible for everyone“

“The eastside location is so good when it comes to making your cookies look like they should in the advertisements and the workers always make sure to show you the cookies/cakes so you don't walk away unsatisfied, the workers are also super friendly at this location and I can genuinely tell that they love making making customers smile when they hang them the pink box! 10/10!“

“Wow 😋 We were in from out of town and it was 9:30pm and suddenly I needed ice cream🍦🍦Saw that Lic's was less than two miles up the road, AND OPEN UNTIL 10:30!! We swing by and get a regular vanilla cone and the choco cream treats... So quick and they did not disappoint!! So good, I wish we lived closer so we could have these tasty treats all the time, 10/10, highly recommend!! Definitely get some good eats here“

“My granddaughter loves the frozen yogurt“

“amazing food and experience!“

“Love going into this store! Wide variety of candy, especially jelly beans and gummies. All kinds of flavored gummi bears, plus a ton of gummi animals and food shapes. Their stuffed animal collection is amazing. Exotic animals plus an A+ unicorn selection. Young lady working was very pleasant. Most candy was $3.75/lb.“

“it was very good we had a great time“

“Wow 😋 We were in from out of town and it was 9:30pm and suddenly I needed ice cream🍦🍦Saw that Lic's was less than two miles up the road, AND OPEN UNTIL 10:30!! We swing by and get a regular vanilla cone and the choco cream treats... So quick and they did not disappoint!! So good, I wish we lived closer so we could have these tasty treats all the time, 10/10, highly recommend!! Definitely get some good eats here“

“Wow 😋 We were in from out of town and it was 9:30pm and suddenly I needed ice cream🍦🍦Saw that Lic's was less than two miles up the road, AND OPEN UNTIL 10:30!! We swing by and get a regular vanilla cone and the choco cream treats... So quick and they did not disappoint!! So good, I wish we lived closer so we could have these tasty treats all the time, 10/10, highly recommend!! Definitely get some good eats here“

“Wow 😋 We were in from out of town and it was 9:30pm and suddenly I needed ice cream🍦🍦Saw that Lic's was less than two miles up the road, AND OPEN UNTIL 10:30!! We swing by and get a regular vanilla cone and the choco cream treats... So quick and they did not disappoint!! So good, I wish we lived closer so we could have these tasty treats all the time, 10/10, highly recommend!! Definitely get some good eats here“

“the service was Epic and I was so excited to try this type of ice cream for the first time. My kid chose to get the strawberry ice creme and it Divine as can be. we originally bought two of the bobo teas....and they were so good before we left the mall we decided to go back and grab two more drinks and got the ice cream we spoke of above. I think the best part was the two workers and how kind they were, dedicated to explaining to us everything we asked questions about and how they went over the top to make it healthy...was even better. 10/10 we will absolutely be returning for more“

“My family and I have bought ice cream here multiple times over the years and it never disappoints. I love their signature creation ice creams.
This year my daughter decided she wanted a cold stone Ice Cream cake for her birthday. We have never purchased a cake from them before. I placed my order for a custom cake online and mistakenly entered in the wrong date for a week later then when I needed it. I unfortunately did not realize my mistake until I was standing in the store to pick it up on the actual date I needed it. Sam helped me and was incredibly nice and apologetic even though this mistake was completely on me. He was able to locate a one of their standard Signature cookies and cream cake in the size we ordered in their deep freeze. Sam advised that they could ice it and decorate it in the morning, and I could pick it up prior to my daughter party. I was so happy with this resolution, but Sam was not done. After we left the store Sam continued to search the deep freeze and actually found my custom cake. He called me to let me know that he had located it and they could have it ready for me in the morning. Thank you, Sam for going above and beyond this customers' expectations and fixing my mistake with a smile of your face and making such a seamless interaction. We will definitely be ordering more ColdStone Cakes in the future.
Also, the cake was absolutely delicious.“

“Wow 😋 We were in from out of town and it was 9:30pm and suddenly I needed ice cream🍦🍦Saw that Lic's was less than two miles up the road, AND OPEN UNTIL 10:30!! We swing by and get a regular vanilla cone and the choco cream treats... So quick and they did not disappoint!! So good, I wish we lived closer so we could have these tasty treats all the time, 10/10, highly recommend!! Definitely get some good eats here“

“I had never been before. I chose La Campirana for lunch. There were 5 vendors and an ice cream shop. I will come back. Go there and try it, Evansville!“

“Food was as always, great. The biggest problem is the way the place is laid out. The entrances are on both sides of the building which are at the ends of the space in front of the counter. The condiment station is precariously set at one end and becomes an area of congestion and hazards. There's not a big enough place to put more than one tray. Which is already a task to carry after the cashier / server / hostess has loaded it down with all of the food and mainly the unwieldy soft drinks. Then there's the elevated dining area that has chrome separation bars, which add to the awkward layout of the dining area.“

“As I was dropping my son off at work in Northpark, I witnessed the owner and an employee rush outside to save a lost dog. First Ave is very busy at this time of day and the poor dog could have been killed. We have been in baskin Robbins many times and they have always been so polite!“

“We live in Columbus Indiana and go to the local Culvers a few times a month but we were in Evansville Saturday night and as we were heading back to Columbus we hadn't eaten so we drove through this Culvers. Everything was pretty decent except there was an abundance of salt on my onion rings. Who puts salt on onion rings??? I had to scrape it off just to eat them. Is it just me or has fast food service gone in the toilet the last few years?“

“Insomnia Cookies is a must-visit! The warm cookies are absolutely delicious, and they offer an impressive variety of flavors to choose from. The service was great and incredibly friendly, making the experience even better. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a sweet treat!“

“Some of the best food on campus. The staff are nice and everything tastes great. However, if you go at the wrong time you could be waiting for about twenty minutes for your order. If you avoid the rush it’s fine, but the time it takes during busy times keeps it from 5 stars.“

“I love coming there the people are nice and they are quick to get the food done and not to mention I love the food. We love goin to the west side location.

Dietary restrictions: Can't eat the bread and they offer lettuce wraps

Kid-friendliness: They are always so nice.“

“We live in Columbus Indiana and go to the local Culvers a few times a month but we were in Evansville Saturday night and as we were heading back to Columbus we hadn't eaten so we drove through this Culvers. Everything was pretty decent except there was an abundance of salt on my onion rings. Who puts salt on onion rings??? I had to scrape it off just to eat them. Is it just me or has fast food service gone in the toilet the last few years?“

“I recommend downloading the app. If you have multiple family members I would put the app on each phone to pay separately and use a coupon for each order. You can use the in app $3 off coupon for either a regular 6 pc. strip basket or tossed in sauce. Orders tend to be correct much more often when order is in app and food is ready when you arrive. It gives the store more time to prepare your order. My TOSS N SAUCE strips today were excellent. We work hard to be able to afford a meal or ourselves and our family and in this economy we need to save all we can when we can.“

“Went through the drive through kinda late and they were all in great moods and made GREAT blizzards for us! They're an awesome night crew, most of the time you get hit with bad attitudes and ppl who don't wanna be there. This place was the most positive place I've been to in awhile.“

“The service here is always stellar! We usually pop by for breakfast between 7 and 8 in the morning. Order on the app and we only wait a few minutes for fresh food/drinks right to our window!
I recommend the ultimate breakfast burrito. Very flavorful. Really anything with their bacon in it is wonderful. Their brioche is very good, as well.“

“DQ is great! I visit there often!“

“Average enough Sonic, but for the love of God, label if a stall is to go only on BOTH sides of the panel. I don’t want to have to pull into multiple stalls until I find one that isn’t a mobile only stall. While we are on that subject, there is NO reason to have 6 stalls for mobile orders.“

“Great service. Very friendly employees. Good food.“

“First visit to this place in a few years. It is still great. I will definitely have to come back. Their burgers and five way chili are excellent. The staff in here were so enthusiastic and friendly. They all seemed to enjoy what they are doing. The restaurant is very clean and easy to find using Google Maps.“

“I really do wish they would build one out here in the North Park area I love the number one combo cheeseburger tots and I always get my favorite cherry limeade drink They were really really busy today but I didn’t mind waiting because the food is always hot and fresh“

“Lunch with my wife and 3 year old daughter. Anytime I can see my girls smile is a good time : )“