6 Best Pizza Restaurants in Gary

Flamingo Pizza of Miller Pizza • $
8341 Locust Ave, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Nperch \u0026 Shrimp Basket
Nperch & Shrimp Basket
Ribeye Steak Sandwich
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Calzone with Cheese
Kitchen Sink Pizza
Flamingo Pizza
Perch Appetizer
Sausage Pizza
Chicken Wings

“Flamingos has been in town for a long time. Nice little cozy place. A good perch dinner. We like a thin crust pepperoni pizza. The flavor of the pizza dough reminds me of Onos which was one of the Best pizza places, that has a Great flavor to it that you can not find anywhere. The cheese is stretchy when hot. Good flavor! Thumbs up?for Flamingos!“

4.3 Superb146 Reviews
Miller Pizza Co. American • $
622 1/2 S Lake St, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Ham Black or Green Olives
Pepperoni and Mushroom Deep Dish
2 Deep Dish Pizza Special
Italian Beef Sandwiches
Breaded Fried Pickles
Homemade Italian Beef
Garlic Cheese Bread
With Marinara Sauce
Mozzarella Sticks
Thin Crust Pizza

“Best pizza ever since I was little“

4.2 Good179 Reviews
Beggars Pizza Pizza • $$
4345 S Broadway, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Half Onion \u0026 Sausage
Sausage and Muchroom Pizza
Medium Sausage and Peppers
Family Thin Crust Pizza
Deep Dish Sausage Pizza
Loaded Nachos Supreme
Mozzarella Sticks
Deep Dish Pizza
Chicken Wings

“I have been to this location a couple times the first time everything was right at expectations for Beggars Pizza. However when I visited 10/31/2024 it wasn't the best experience I pre-ordered a deep dish and boneless wings for 645pm. With this pre-order it gave the establishment over an hour to prepare my food. When I arrived my order was still not ready and I was given an ETA of 15 minutes this was kind of annoying but I understood it was Halloween and they did seem pretty busy. When I first arrived there was a small box up on the heater and the lady working the desk when asking the kitchen about my order only inquired about the pizza. I was so worried that my wings were already prepared in that small box and that the quality would be terrible. I was hoping they would do the right thing and re make them but they didn't and those were my wings and they were in fact not good. The lady at the front desk seemed overwhelmed and even though my order was sitting ready in the window when I returned she disappeared to the back area making me wait longer for the order I placed at this point about an hour and 40 mins for. She just needed to man her position and get the orders out that she did already have in the hot window. That was pretty annoying but overall I would go back just for the pizza because that wasn't bad I just would have liked the kitchen timing to be better so all parts of my order came out hot and fresh.“

3.7 Good102 Reviews
Samia Pizza Pizza Takeaway • $
2977 W 5th Ave, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Nachos Supreme Nachos
Chicken Tenders
Pepperoni Pizza
Sausage Pizza
Philly Steak
Cheese Pizza
Chicken Wings
Inches Pizza
Gyro Platter
Italian Beef

“Would be 5 stars but there are a couple issues. They always seem to mess up at least one item on my order. Also their tacos are very good but very dry and they don’t offer and red or green sauce with them. They by far have the best food overall in the region as far as delivery goes. Great selection I wish they would offer bacon as an option to add on to there burgers also some ketchup packets etc. would be nice. Highly recommend to anyone looking for delivery in the area.“

3.6 Good52 Reviews
Rico's Pizza Pizza • $
5404 W 25th Ave D, Gary

Customers` Favorites

Sausge and Cheese Pizza
Pizza with One Topping
Italian Beef Sandwich
Cheese Sticks
Meat Lovers 5
Italian Beef
Cheeseburger
Cajun Fries
Pizza Puff
Hot Wings

“Always Great!“

3.5 Good61 Reviews
Hunt Brothers Pizza Pizza • $
5301 W 15th Ave, Gary

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

5 Superb6 Reviews

You May Also Like