9 Best Pizza Restaurants near Hamilton

“After the horse-drawn parade, it was a great way to warm up. It was my first time. I found the food was great. Even though they were very busy, the staff was right on top of things. People were seated and waited in a prompt manner. Very friendly and helpful. I will be back.“

“I recently savored the Tasty Supreme pizza from Tasty Pizza in Waterloo, Indiana, customizing it without green peppers for my first trial. The experience was nothing short of delightful. Right from the first bite, the crust impressed me with its perfect bake and texture. The toppings were cooked to perfection, each ingredient melding harmoniously while retaining its distinct taste.What stood out the most was the sauce — it had a unique flavor profile that set this pizza apart from others I’ve tried. Despite the older, somewhat worn appearance of the building, the quality and taste of the pizza spoke volumes about the family tradition of making "Pizza Fantastic Since 1958!" It’s a testament to not judging a book by its cover, or in this case, a pizzeria by its facade.I’m already looking forward to my next visit and would highly recommend Tasty Pizza to anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience in Waterloo. Their craftsmanship in pizza making is evident, and it’s no wonder they’ve been a culinary staple since 1958. Two thumbs up for Tasty Pizza!“

“There is no better Italian restaurant to go to in the tri-state area. Went this evening and sat at the bar. Bar staff was amazing and the food was fabulous as always. Thank you Caruso's for doing what you do for as long as you have. You are loved.“

“Great local place in the square. Very affordable, good portion sizes, and cheap drinks.The grilled cheese and lasagna soup was a great choice on a cold February day. And happy Kaitlyn talked us into splitting the vanilla peanut butter pie!“

“I was pleasantly surprised to find an actual Pizza Hutt in operation after a long day at the Pokagon beach as all of the ones near my house have closed their doors. The food was excellent and the server was very polite and I felt welcome and well tended to during my visit. I noticed the cleanliness of the banquet area, and the restrooms were a definite priority to the staff. The windows were clean, the carpets were clean, and the bathroom looked well maintained. I was very impressed all around.“

“I've known the family that owns this shop a good portion of my life. Very wonderful people whom equally run a very sound and worth visiting business. All that having been said. Come try their eats. Their pizza is delicious but that is surely not the only menu venue to be explored here. You can't go wrong on anything they provide from my experience. Stop by and find out, you won't be disappointed.“

“Dominoes Pizza , Angola, IN is a great "go-to" for delivered pizza in the region. True to their word, you always get ...a. A good quality pizzab. Delivered timely and hotc. By a delivery person who is friendly and personable!Ambiance...home always works!!Great job Dominoes!!“

“I placed an order for delivery and everything went very smoothly. I got the 10 inch Royal Feast, and it did not disappoint. Just as others commented, it was delicious. Onions were especially noticeable, which is great for me. I'm a bus driver for a University in West Central Ohio and have tried many pizzas, and this was right in the top 3 so far.“

“Good food and great employees! They have a wide variety of hot food to choose from. Fresh made salads, subs and wraps are made in the store and in the cooler to grab and go. There is a wide variety of drinks to choose from. The pizza is made fresh so you never have to worry about grabbing a stale slice. The atmosphere is very friendly and welcoming. The Casey's Rewards are a great additional way to save.“