magdalena
$$ • Cocktail Bar, Wine Bars, Seafood Book a table: 7:00 PM 7:15 PM 7:30 PM MoreAbout magdalena
Customers' Favorites
Whitefish Dip with Fried Saltines
Stuffed Collards
magdalena Reviews
89 ratings
Share your opinion about magdalena
Quickly becoming one of my favorite central Indiana restaurants
Dined on Friday and had an overall pleasant experience, but wanted to share some feedback to really knock it out of the part from a dining experience!
- The Fried Green Tomatoes, Duck Gnocchi, and Crawfish Pasta were EXCELLENT! Highly recommend ordering again
- The Oysters were a little pricey but delicious overall
- Cocktails are a 10/10 - if you are eating here, I recommend you go the cocktail vs wine route!
- We sat down at 6:30 and did not have a waitress stop...read full review
- The Fried Green Tomatoes, Duck Gnocchi, and Crawfish Pasta were EXCELLENT! Highly recommend ordering again
- The Oysters were a little pricey but delicious overall
- Cocktails are a 10/10 - if you are eating here, I recommend you go the cocktail vs wine route!
- We sat down at 6:30 and did not have a waitress stop...read full review
Magdalena was a completely unique dining experience. The service was second to none. The food was one of a kind and delicious. We started off with the pimento cheese dip and the smoked white fish dip. Both dishes are served with fried saltines. Who knew I needed fried saltines in my life. I know now. Both dips were great. My wife and I shared the City ham with grits and red eye gravy. I had never had red eye gravy, but had heard of it. I now crave red eye gravy. If...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 5 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 5 - 11PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 11PM |
| Sunday | 5 - 9PM |
Magdalena is a great addition to Fountain Square, offering high-quality food and drinks in a top-notch ambiance. The menu features flavorful small plates, including crowd-pleasing Brussels sprouts and delicious ceviche paired with seasoned saltines. The oysters are a standout, with some considering them the best they've ever had, and special mentions go to the Momma Mia and Bruce’s Beach House for their fresh and bold flavors. The Crawfish Monica is described as light, creamy, and incredible, while the chicken schnitzel is also highly praised. The service is exceptional, with friendly and kind staff providing a unique dining experience. The atmosphere is chill, enhanced by great music and a lively vibe. Overall, Magdalena is a must-visit spot, perfect for those looking for a great meal in a great atmosphere, especially with the appealing 2 buck oysters on Tuesday nights.