Original Frozen Custard

Name: Original Frozen Custard
Address: 2319 Wallace Ave, Lafayette, Indiana, 47904, US
Telephone: (765) 447-2492
Price range: $
Rating: 3.1

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
2319 Wallace Ave, Lafayette
(765) 447-2492

Menu Order Online

About Original Frozen Custard

Original Frozen Custard is a local joint serving delicious ice cream with generous portions. Despite long lines and understaffing, the service is generally good. They offer homemade specialties like the nut bar and cookie ice cream sandwich. Note that the facility is not nut-free or suitable for those with extreme gluten sensitivity, and sugar-free options are limited. Enjoy their classic soft serve ice cream, a nostalgic treat that remains largely unchanged over the years.

Recently added reviews highlight that this place is a favorite spot for many, especially in summer, where families and loved ones gather for ice cream. Some customers mention specific flavors like marshmallow vanilla or cherry Coke as personal favorites, which add to the nostalgic charm. The ice cream is praised as amazing and reasonably priced, especially for the small size, though larger portions may lack value. The outdoor seating area, however, has been noted as extremely dirty and in need of cleaning.

The shop has an old-school, straightforward vibe that appeals to those seeking a classic frozen custard experience. Visitors often stop by after road trips or while exploring nearby parks and playgrounds, making it a convenient and nostalgic stop. Despite some issues with cleanliness and portion size, many appreciate that it has been a beloved local spot for decades and is still open today.