4 Best Ice Cream Shops near Mitchell

1 Dairy bell Ice Cream

4.3 Superb 149 Reviews

2478 IN-60, Mitchell

• Take-Out

“Absolutely fabulous place for ice cream and shakes... and pup cups!! After an adventurous day we wanted to end it with a sweet treat and that landed us here. I was shocked to see that they had black cherry hard ice cream!!! It was creamy and sweet and reminded me of growing up in upstate NY and going to the Stewart's Shoppe 45 minutes from home get black cherry ice cream!! My better half had a chocolate malt and he loved it, said it was perfect! This is definitely the place to get ice cream and when we are back in the area we will certainly stop in again!”

2 Hometown Scoops

4.9 Superb 37 Reviews

255 West Washington Street, Orleans · 5.05 miles

“Donuts were great, come to see them at Bedford parade”

3 Jiffy Treet

4.5 Superb 124 Reviews

142 16th Street, Bedford · 8.86 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We've been going to Jiffy Treet for over 40 years. My hubby's ole college roommate is from Bedford, and he introduced us to Jiffy Treet. I highly recommend their Sloppy Joe's, Foot Long Sloppy Joe Dogs, and BBQs. I'm not a big ice cream eater, but I absolutely love their ice cream! We live a couple of hours away, but go to southern Indiana often, and we stop by on either the way down, or the way back, (sometimes both) when staying at the French Lick Resort. We stopped by almost 30 times in 2024, and again in 2025. The food never disappoints. It's all yummy! 😋 We've started carrying a cooler in our car just so I can bring home their homemade ice cream. My favorite ice cream on the menu is their JT Crunch. Some of my favorite hand dipped flavors of the month are: Big Red, German Chocolate Cake, and Gooey Butter Cake. I always get a single dip, but it always is generous and looks like a dip and a half. My favorite soft serve is their seasonal Persimmon ice cream. In our 40 plus years we have never had a bad meal from Jiffy Treet. We love it that they stay open until December, and open back up in either January or February. That allows us to spend more time at one of our favorite restaurants.”

4 Culver’s

4.0 Good 82 Reviews

3150 John A Williams Blvd, Bedford · 9.56 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I love this place! Me and my family come here every now and then for some burgers and culvers does not disappoint. Their chicken and burgers are the best (in my opinion) and their ice cream is wonderful. They have more flavors and toppings than I've ever seen before. The downside though is that the place is never clean. Its not awful but the tables and chairs/booths always have crumbs on them so you know they dont get wiped down. Also the service kinda just depends on the night. It is usually relatively quick.”