26 Best Sandwich Shops near New Whiteland

“I wanted to commend the young men who served us during our recent visit. They handled our request for additional items on six of our sandwiches with remarkable professionalism. In contrast to the often indifferent attitude encountered in similar situations, their respectful and ethical approach was truly commendable. Their exemplary service reflects well on their commitment to customer satisfaction.“

“Knuckle Sandwich had delicious pizza. I don’t order their meals because they refuse to evenly substitute the fries for any other side. I think that could only hurt their business.“

“I don’t normally leave reviews like this, but the incredible staff at this Subway absolutely deserve it. The ladies who work here are hands-down some of the kindest, most thoughtful people I’ve ever met.

I had called earlier just to ask if they had the Happy Gilmore cup from the special promotion. That’s it—just a quick check. When I showed up later to see what cups they had, they had actually saved the exact one I was hoping for. I never even told them which character I wanted—but somehow, they just knew. That small act of thoughtfulness genuinely meant the world to me.

It’s rare to be treated with that kind of care and attention anywhere, let alone at a fast-food spot. I was truly touched. I can honestly say I’ll never go to another Subway again. This is the one. Loyal for life.

Thank you again to the amazing women working there. You made my day in a way you probably didn’t even realize.“

“Love their variety of foods ( Reubens are my favorite). Salads are huge and good. Best Sweet Tea .“

“Delicious food and fast service.“

“First time to go to Chicken Salad Chicks, and we loved it ! Pleasant ordering service and advice on the choices, and great lunch. We will definitely keep this restaurant on our go to list. A plus service, atmosphere and food!“

“Fun atmosphere. Music bingo, games, karaoke is fun!“

“*****7-25-2025 UPDATE *****
Called in and spoke with Zane for my delivery order. He was patient and efficient with my request! Thank you Zane, for the exceptional care you showed to my family tonight!
**********
Always a great experience and delicious food. The staff is personable and welcoming and that is hard to come by these days :)“

“Food was great but tired of the cook yelling at a newer employee abusivily in front of all the customers, it was uncomfortable sitting here listening to it and the music with offensive terms blaring in the kitchen, very thankful we didn't have our kids with us. Food was amazing though as always.“

“The chipotle cheese steak is never a “mis-steak” lol.

I honestly worship this place and accept the oblong sandwich creation as my lord and savior. When I perish ,due to old age, I hope I float into a bread like cloud and am covered, Mikes Way, in the same love and passion that my taste buds received while feasting on this submarine masterpiece.“

“Turkey sub is to die for and I love their brownies..“

“5-Star Catering Experience!

We recently placed a catering order with Penn Station for our company meeting, and everything was absolutely perfect! A huge thank you to Corbin, the General Manager, for ensuring that the entire process was smooth and professional from start to finish. The order arrived right on time, the food was fresh and delicious, and all of the toppings were packaged separately just as we had requested — which made serving so easy for our team.

Corbin and the entire Penn Station team went above and beyond, and we truly appreciated the attention to detail. We received tons of compliments from our staff about how great the food was.

Fantastic job — highly recommend this location for any catering needs!“

“First time stopping in. Heard a lot about McAlisters so I had to try!“

“Five stars Friendly staff and always clean!!“

“I previously worked at Penn Station. The food and atmosphere are both fantastic. I always tell customers to try the cookies.

Also, is this something that would work for a corporate client? I think you should give your reliable customers a free cookie or wipe their fry. When I worked there, I used 1/3 of our food tab for cookies and then passed them out. You could also have a separate day for advertising. Mark half of your items to maybe 60% off and watch the money pile in. Turn on something interesting on the TV or give free drinks and play music. Advertise yourself a bit.“

“We usually go to this location. I am very happy with them. The food is usually fresh. I have to say that when we order online, there is almost always errors. If we stand right there, no problems.
Clean dining area and bathrooms! :)“

“The staff was very friendly and greeted me upon walking in as well as preparing my food the exact way I wanted which many other subways don’t have time or even try, but best experience I’ve had in a long time at any subway, and was very surprised by the cleanliness of the overall store. The workers tonight definitely deserve a raise in my opinion but do whatever you will with that knowledge.

Parking: Not bad at this time of the day“

“I ordered from the subway mobile app kept the sandwiches basic asked for no tomatoes and toasted.

The sandwiches were delivered fast I opened to see none were toasted and they had tomatoes in them still and so much sauce it was leaking everywhere.

I attempted to call the location a gentleman answered I advised the sandwiches were made improperly he was polite and advised to bring them in and he would remake them both. As I am not able to come in for this right away I advised I would come with both sandwiches after 4pm as this was my lunch delivery and I have no time before being off work.

Now I will not get my deliver fee back or anything but keep in mind it was not the delivery guys fault and the shop is willing to fix this as well.

I appreciated the way the staff/owner/or gentleman handled my call with white glove service and respect and will order again for those reasons.“

“It is Ok.Kind of overpriced.I had a sandwich and lasagna soup and lemonade. The lemonade tastes like those powder juice, so bad. The sandwich was simple and the soup was so canned tomaty.Service was ok, they were courteous. The place is nice.“

“Penn Station has my favorite fries, bar none. I used to go to one by an old job so often, they put my picture on the wall. My girl laughs at the sign every time we pass one, because she says it look like it says, "Peast Coast Subs" I also like the chicken parm“

“Ordering online was so convenient and easy , I received my lunch in a timely manner 👍🏾 also my sandwich itself wasn't bad at all. I had a turkey sandwich with bacon they definitely could have put more than one piece of bacon on there, but all in all, the sandwich was great 👍🏾.“

“The people here are so nice, they even know my order when I come in I refuse to go to another subway due to the fact this is the cleanest one around and the workers are professional and sanitary. I love this Subway and everyone in it...plus the food is always on point not once has it disappointed“

“Best tuna sub around. Customer service is top notch, which comes from management that has a heart of gold!“

“Ordered several sandwiches through doordash. One of our sandwiches was toasted in error. The Mgr immediately replaced the sandwich and apologized for the inconvenience. Really appreciate the quick resolution and great customer service. Thank you!“

“I had placed a mobile order and picked up in store.
I got home and realized they gave me the wrong sandwich.
I called and they were so great about it, they offered to remake it and gave me a credit.
They didn’t have to do all of that but I really appreciated it!

The sandwich was nice and fresh when I got it home.“

“I have never had a problem with anything about this location expect they need people that love to come to work and love what they do until they come home i would love to work for them but for whatever reason they told me they are full staffed and they need help very bad but its ok i guess they dont care about people who are reliable and ready to work lol its ok but i will always be a loyal customer“