11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Newburgh

“Awesome pizza! Great price, fast and friendly service.“

“One of best pizzas I have ever had! So sad that we don’t have this near Nashville but nice to have when we visit family in Newburgh.“

“Ordered Godfathers pizza over the phone and when I got to the store they had part of the order wrong. It was all good though because Makayla, Jason, the manager and the rest of the staff were amazing. They rectified the situation quickly and were apologetic the whole time. I wasn't upset about the miscommunication at all but this crew is really on top of things. Great customer service all around. I love coming here and I'll definitely be back.“

“My family and I just recently tried Archie and Clydes. We've been twice now since Mardi Gras started. The service was great and the food was excellent! It's definitely a new local favorite of ours and I can't believe it took us this long to try it! We were definitely missing out.“

“Domino's is amazing. Don't let the haters make the decisions for you and tell you what is good and bad. Try it and make the choice yourself. Their thin crust pizza is incredible. My wife loves their cheesy bread. My kids enjoy their chicken wings. We order and pick up at least once a month.“

“"My wife and I dined at Prime Sports last night, and it was a fantastic experience. The food was absolutely delicious. I had the stromboli, which was perfectly baked and packed with flavor. My wife tried the pizza bites, and she couldn't stop raving about them. The service was top-notch, with attentive and friendly staff making sure we had everything we needed. Overall, it was an excellent dining experience, and we highly recommend Prime Sportsto anyone looking for great food and excellent service."“

“Stopped by Turonis Newburgh for a House Special pizza and one of their craft brews the Honey Blonde. The pizza was flavorful and the beer was great! Highly recommended trying out this local pizzeria!!“

“My family and I are from Tampa but we have family up here in Evansville and since my Dad grew up here everytime that we visit this is the absolute first place that we visit because we have to get the Stromboli because it is so amazing and is truly the staple food everytime we come to Indiana. This location in itself is also great because it has a very casual atmosphere so it is a great place to socialize with friends or family without having to worry about holding up a table for waitstaff or being rushed in any way. Overall great food and atmosphere our family loves going here for some killer stromboli.“

“Went to see JAWS on their 50th anniversary. The theater seats were NOT so comfortable, and definitely NOT like the theater seats at Showplace East!

Can you believe a soft drink is $7.75 for a 32oz. size???!!!! 🤬🤬🤬 UNBELIEVABLE!!!
It’s bad enough that you have to pay $8.00 for a ticket to get in, but $7.75 for a 32oz. soft drink is a RIPOFF!!! RIDICULOUS!!!

Definitely won’t be going back to the concession stand!!!“

“Atmosphere is wonderful and good music! Restaurant staff is absolutely out of this world! Real good down home BBQ. You need to make a stop it's well worth it. There is no longer a buffet offered any more. The price and portions are worth it. If you can try to save room for desserts. Keep eating to much to get any. The desserts look amazing.

Dietary restrictions: Has Gluten free options

Kid-friendliness: Down home country music slash oldies. Download home atmosphere.“