6 Best Pizza Restaurants near Saint Joe

“I never remember to take pictures before we devoured everything! This time, I think we had the all meat pizza. As usual, it was LOADED with meat AND cheese. They never skimp on toppings, including the cheese. I have been blessed to actually meet both members of the couple who own this place. They are both very personable people who take pizza seriously! I have had a great amount of pizza in my adult life, having been a GM for both a Domino's and a Papa John's. The pizza that we have had here far surpasses ANY chain store pizza I've ever tasted. Everything we have ordered from here has far surpassed my expectations of a small town pizza restaurant. ?“

“The food was fantastic, but service was horrendous. We seated ourselves per the signage in the foyer and then sat there...and sat there...and sat there. When the server finally came out and greeted us, they didn't even apologize for us having been sitting there forever. This was a portent of things to come because we never saw her again after our food was brought out.As we were eating several other groups of people came in and sat for nearly ten minutes before going back into the kitchen and calling out asking if there was anyone working. We were just about to go do this ourselves as we had finished eating by then and were going to be late for an appointment if we weren't out of there within five minutes. We ended up being quite late to our appointment because it took over fifteen minutes for her to come out, get us boxes for our food, give us a bill and come back for our credit cards. Considering there were only two other tables in the whole restaurant and she'd already brought them drinks and turned in their orders, I don't know what on earth could've taken that long to do those few things!! We even told her repeatedly that we were in a hurry and she acknowledged that and moved about as casually as you please like she had all the time in the world! The waitress was as sweet as could be, but clearly not cut out for the service industry. We don't hold this against Italian Grille, but plenty of other people probably would. Service is an important aspect of a business, and having an inattentive server with no sense of expediency--especially when the customer tells them they're in a hurry and have somewhere to be--can impact a business' reputation.Wheelchair accessibility: Six handicap spaces right in front of the door, three on each side of the wheelchair ramp.Nice big handicap stall in the bathroom.Limited space between tables which aren't set up in rows, so you will have to zip zag a wheelchair or walker through a maze of tables if you don't sit at the first one you come to or want a booth.“

“I recently savored the Tasty Supreme pizza from Tasty Pizza in Waterloo, Indiana, customizing it without green peppers for my first trial. The experience was nothing short of delightful. Right from the first bite, the crust impressed me with its perfect bake and texture. The toppings were cooked to perfection, each ingredient melding harmoniously while retaining its distinct taste.What stood out the most was the sauce — it had a unique flavor profile that set this pizza apart from others I’ve tried. Despite the older, somewhat worn appearance of the building, the quality and taste of the pizza spoke volumes about the family tradition of making "Pizza Fantastic Since 1958!" It’s a testament to not judging a book by its cover, or in this case, a pizzeria by its facade.I’m already looking forward to my next visit and would highly recommend Tasty Pizza to anyone looking for a top-notch pizza experience in Waterloo. Their craftsmanship in pizza making is evident, and it’s no wonder they’ve been a culinary staple since 1958. Two thumbs up for Tasty Pizza!“

“They were so friendly and I had to wait for my pizza because it had been made wrong..which I was not upset I just waited, they offered me the messed up pizza free and a 2 liter..i said you didn't have to and thank you..it was very sweet of them..great service and even better pizza“

“I was hosting 38 robotics teams (about 10 - 15 people per team) for a large competition. The teams ordered pizza and East of Chicago delivered in a big way. The teams were very happy with the food, which was delivered on-time, nice and hot. East of Chicago stepped up in a big way. Fantastic service, great to work with for the event. Recommend considering them for your next event.“

“Delicious pizza, ordered carryout. Tried the thin crust 13" taco pizza and a 16" hand tossed 3 topping ( pepperoni, mushrooms, and bacon). There were plenty of toppings and cheese! A bit pricey, but worth it. Will definitely be going back. They have a large menu of items other than pizza as well.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust available“