50 Best Pizza Restaurants near New Haven

“a very hands on owner, family oriented“

“We stopped in at this location during a hockey tournament. Got a small order. The person on the phone was very friendly, give some options, and the conversation was simple and easy.

When we picked up, the service was great right down to a staff member offering to take my son’s straw wrapper when she noticed he was holding it after unwrapped his straw. I know that seems small, but it shows a level of attention to detail for the guest that you don’t often see in fast food or chain establishments.

The food was hot, made to order, and came out in less than the promised time. Great experience, and we will visit again!“

“owner super nice Highly recommend!“

“Absolutely fantastic experience with Marco’s Pizza in New Haven! I got delivery, and the delivery option was incredibly convenient. Everything showed up hot, fresh, and ridiculously good. My order was correct, the food tasted great, and the delivery was quick and friendly.

Also, special shoutout to the delivery guy with the beard. Sir… respectfully, you are sexy as hell. 😂🔥 Great pizza, convenient delivery, AND attractive delivery drivers? Marco’s clearly understands customer service.

Five stars all the way. Definitely ordering again! 🍕“

“Very good! We were driving through and looking for a place!“

“I live in Michigan work in Ohio and come to Indiana alot. They say the workers make a difference, which is true. Ivy was a fantastic worker and the service was great. She was busy but she was doing great. I absolutely love this place and everytime I come to Indiana I will be coming here for lunch everytime. Give that girl a raise she's a beast and she deserves it. One of my favorite workers here. Keep it up!!!!!“

“Order was ready in the 5 minute window.
1 customer came in for hot and ready but none available while I waited (arrived a few mons before my pickup window)
Probably a busy day as other visits hot and ready was available.
Atmosphere 3 of 5 as Noone asked if they could help me. A smile or you here for pick up? Name? Let me check.. yea he's almost done with it.
Overall we will come back. Great value (price for what you get)

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly... check

Wheelchair accessibility: No automatic door, but does have ramp“

“THIS LOCATION IS UNDER NEW MANAGEMENT Please come see our changes to the store“

“We absolutely adore this local Pizza/Sub joint. One of my favorites actually, as they don't just specialize in only Pizza.

The only reason Atmosphere got a 3-Star is:
The last time we were in was on a 90 degree day, and awfully enough, it was cooler outside than inside. I could not manage to wait on our order inside because of how hot it was. Obviously, I don't know how much management/owners could do anything about it, as I don't know if they own the building itself, but I hope that the workers/management/owners were okay. I hope they got home and got some much needed hydration and rest when they did get home. 🥵💙“

“I overall had a good experience at Chuck E. Cheese UNTIL I was asked rudely why I didn’t give them an 8 or 9 out of 10 rating. Not only was I caught of guard by managements approach within seconds of submitting, she made a scene infront of other customers. In my opinion, it’s extremely unprofessional to be talked to like that in front of other people. “A 8 or 9, is the only rating that benefits our location” if I could go back and rate differently, that rude encounter would have changed my rating to a 2.“

“The place was beautiful & the customer service was great! 10/10 recommend!“

“I when visit Fort Wayne this my go to for a sausage roll. Great food!!“

“Got pizza today at Electric Works with my daughter!! This was the best pizza I have had in long time!! Excellent!!“

“Tried the mamma sandwich today so good amazing food as always“

“We called ahead on short notice to the Pizza Hut on Coldwater in Fort Wayne with a dine in order for 18 people, mostly teenagers. The whole crew and especially our server Rachel was AMAZING!! We were in and out in 30 minutes!! Food was fresh and hot and service was great. Thank you!!!“

“Good wings. Good rolls. We will be back!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐☆
Elmo’s is exactly what you expect — fair tasting food and you pretty much get what you pay for. It’s not overhyped or anything fancy, but it does the job when you’re in a hurry 👍
Honestly, I’d pick this over McDonald's if I need something quick and filling. It’s especially convenient if you’re already stopping for gas — definitely a one-stop shop kind of place. Grab food, drinks, snacks, and be on your way.
The bathroom was clean and bright, which I always appreciate. There’s also sit-down seating available by the windows if you want to relax for a few minutes instead of rushing out.
Located right off a main street, so it has that easy in-and-out feel. Solid choice when you’re hungry and need something fast without making it a whole event.“

“Great pizza and a fun atmosphere! Hard to say it's the best in the city - we have some really great pizza places - but we really enjoyed their options, the dough was just right, and there were several things for the kids that made the patio seating quite nice.“

“Tried the mamma sandwich today so good amazing food as always“

“Got home and didn't have all of my order. I even had them repeat it to me when I placed my order 😔“

“I was in town to see a friend as part of my quest to see all 50 states. I am glad this was the recommendation because I tried the local pork tenderloin sandwich with a side of really great coleslaw and had a really great chat with my friend. I managed to park in the back, but it seemed like parking could be a little bit difficult in the area. We also decided to head out when trivia night was starting as it was getting a bit loud and crowded. However, we could have enjoyed the patio!“

“the guy I dealt with was super nice. it was my 1st time there didnt know about cash only. I was 2 dollars short give or take. he let me go on that. he also updated me on time with my pizzas. food was good.“

“Always delicious!! My favorite pizza place“

“Want Thank Tom Fife it was a pleasure meeting you your restaurant is amazing the food brings back memories of my home Chicago but in Fort Wayne Indiana beautiful restaurant services is awesome friendly staff if you want a taste of Chicago come check out Giordano's Pizza 🍕“

“Stopped in last evening for a quick bite to eat and our waitress took us to our table ...who's name was Caitlyn... (possibly a K not sure). But we had the BEST customer service that I have had in as long time. She was so Sweet and checked on us continually. She also suggested when I wanted a wrap...that I didnt have to have it with Buffalo sauce could get it just plain with ranch. When she bought the food she said, "Would you like an extra side of ranch". I thought that was so kind. Then when she bought boxes to the table for our left overs she bought a lid for my ranch and a sack to Carry our containers in...ALL without me asking. I asked for the manager to come to the table for her to be recognized for her impeccable customer service!! He said, " He appreciated me bringing that to his attention". I made sure she got an excellent tip for her Kind , caring and quality customer service. BUT I ALSO THINK SHE DESERVES A 5 STAR ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ rating here as well. Most of the time these days you dont get that kind of customer service...so when you do it needs to be reconized!! Thank you again Caitlyn on a job well done!!“

“I Love❤️ Union Street Market💘 such an amazing✨️ place with many different local delicious 😋 food/small businesses, and restaurants inside. Amazing✨️, beautiful, i love the location, food, service, and the atmosphere in here. And excellent choice for dining here. 5 Stars⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I've been comming here for years. Amazing 👏🏻 place and A Classic❤️ in Fort Wayne❤️, Indiana💘.“

“BEST pizza (besides Pizza King a few weeks ago...) I have had in a long time. Hot. Fresh. Delicious. This location has always been one of the best ❤ Had a medium thin crust, meat lovers. Incredible. Great job today!“

“Great sandwiches,grinders and pizza. It's in the gas station but the food is delicious. Great fresh bread, unfortunately because it's in a gas station the seating is peculiar and uncomfortable. But at least there's tables and chairs to sit at and enjoy your food. The Cheese steak is not the best sandwich of choice but there are burgers,subs,pizza fries, and other great sides.“

“Good food people are so very nice I love it so very much thank sevice“

“Keep it way it is no changes“

“Was in town delivering and was trying to find a place to eat. Found this small bar. Grabbed an Uber to come here. Walked in and wasn’t expecting smoking inside. Didn’t bother me much but I don’t smoke so it was different. Still walked in and sat down. Got a beer. Ordered the 6 mile personal pizza and the 6 mile grinder sandwich. Both were amazing. Had a few beers. Bartender was really nice and took care of me. Nice place to hang out for a bit. But the smoking did get to me after a while so I decided to call it a night. But I still highly recommend coming here to have a beer and some food.“

“Not everything was exactly to my taste, but those subjective bits aside they were actually very good. Very polite service and quick service, reasonable prices, and overall great food. Maybe a touch too much parmesean in the caesar salad for me, and their pizza sauce is maybe a shade or two under what I've gotten from other restaurants, but the crust was delicious with just a touch of char and no actual burning; sane goes for the cheesy bread.

Their selection of music was inoffensive, and quiet enough that it wouldn't be a bother even if you weren't a fan of it.

Overall, my wife and I both really enjoyed it! $30 for more than enough food for two people isn't too bad at all.“

“Food was delicious and arrived quickly. Great waitress and support staff and clean, well decorated vintage diner atmosphere. Our party tried the beer queso,cinnamon dough puffs, breaded tenderloin, French Dip, and Porky Mac and would recommend them all.“

“Amazing thai and Burmese food!!“

“Pizza Hut on Stellhorn was on it today!! We had a party of 20+ people. Pizza was great!! Service was amazing!! Couldn’t have asked for a better place for a family gathering :)“

“Ordered a 1/2 grinder so good definitely will order again very cheesy and meaty“

“I when visit Fort Wayne this my go to for a sausage roll. Great food!!“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“better service and food quality. the mgr was a total jerk almost because I asked for dry breadsticks cause I have to watch my salt an normally the other manager that use to be there was great at making this with no problem. 15 min went by n no dry bread sticks yet even after our food came out and then the girl went back to get them and then 10 more min went by and now we r almost done with our food so a family member went and asked about them and they forgot and just put them in and not even 2 min later they brought them out half raw so I took them back and asked if it were possible to get dry cooked bread sticks that its already been over 20 min cause you kept forgetting n then bring me under cooked bteadsticks to 5-10 min later the rude manager up front brought them out with a grin but now they are black. I asked him as a mgr do you think this is presentable and represented fazzolis? with a smile hr say I don't know I don't eat dry bread sticks and I told him this was poor service and uncalled for and with a smile he says have a merry Christmas..this was 3 weeks ago and I'll be happy to send u a pic of all the bread sticks that I still have a photo of. I filed a complaint online before leaving and obviously this is how you people handle business because no one replied back. we spent almost $30 that could have been spent where they care about their food and customers.“

“I love Marco's pizza, have no problem with this location. I do have a problem with coupons. I get a flyer that has Fort Wayne, Auburn & Leo, but the coupon code won't work. call the store and they say that code isn't in their system. Corporate needs to be better organized.“

“I just wish all Pizza Huts would have the same quality of food that this particular restaurant does. I'm highly impressed by the food quality and the friendly staff! they have no problem with special requests and they are an amazing crew!!“

“Caliente has evolved a lot over the past couple years. One thing that is consistent however , is the awesome food. Priced well and worth the money. Anytime I'm working in downtown fort Wayne , I make it a point to stop in for lunch at least once a week!“

“I love on track pizza. We get Groupons and the employees don't know how to ring up the order with the Groupon. We wait at least 15 minutes and they say we will figure it out and take your food. Please show your employees what to do. We will appreciate that.“

“great service, food was great and fresh!! definitely will be back.“