19 Best Italian Restaurants near Sellersburg

“This is by far my favorite pizza. Tonight we felt we would dine in and get hoagies. It was wonderful. The bread was so well baked.. my husband had the chicken and he says it’s the best sandwich he’s ever had fast food wise. I had the meatball. Was all fantastic“

“This is my favorite place to go out to eat. Chris, the owner, is the chef, and he is BRILLIANT! If you like Italian food, and you haven't been here yet....you are missing out! I especially like the duck pasta (when available) and the apple walnut salad. :)“

“My friends and I went to the restaurant on May 10, 2025, and we were impressed! The food was fantastic and we will be back m. The service was amazing and we had a phenomenal experience. I highly recommend everyone to check out this restaurant.“

“We had dinner here tonight for the first time ever. Our waitress was well organized and stayed right on top of getting our food out to us. Perfect! Every platter of food was tasty. Absolutely no issues at all. My one complaint would be the restrooms and the area just before entering them. It was SO cold my grand children didn’t want to sit on the toilet. It’s was freezing-no joke! Please consider a small space heater there for winter nights. Not a deal breaker and will definitely be back!“

“such an elegant atmosphere with affordable dishes. The service was fantastic. I ordered the blackened salmon Caesar salad, which was the best Caesar I have ever had. Also the tiramisu was fantastic.. this is a great ambience restaurant if you’re looking for a classy place to go for lunch or dinner that has an elegant comfortable atmosphere“

“Brett did a wonderful job serving my sons and me. We all agreed we would ask for him the next time we visit. Both my sons loved their meals and, as for myself, I felt like my meal came straight from Italy. Love the ambience and neighborhood feel.“

“Not only is the food ALWAYS delicious, but the servers are always friendly, kind, and super generous with the salad and bread sticks.
We love getting the soup, salad, and breadstick lunch!
My son has a lot of food allergies and the servers always communicate well with the chefs to accomodate his needs.“

“My wife Brittany and I stopped in on May 10. The restaurant was packed with only a few seats at the bar. It looked like the hot spot for pre prom dinner. The waitresses were working their tails off trying to keep up and we were very patient. Boy did that patience pay off. Sarah was finally able to ask what drinks we would like. I teased her that water would be great if we ever get it. lol. Sarah immediately new we were kidding and fired back with a little sarcasm of her own. She was wonderful the entire. Sarah brought our bread out. It was very good, but the sauce for dipping was the highlite. Sarah made some recommendations, as we were first time diners. I had chicken parm and my wife ordered eggplant parm. We loved both dishes. Great attention to detail was taken in preparation and appearance. It looked better than any food I have ever seen pictured in a menu, and tasted even better. We followed dinner with chocolate cake and a raspberry sauce that still makes our mouths water. It was so food, we ordered more to take back to the hotel. I would say it is the best little spot in New Albany! Sarah's service and playful personality was the best part of our evening. The food was a very close second. BOTH were INCREDIBLE!!! Hope to make it in again sometime for more great company and good food! Shannon and Brittany“

“We went through the drive-through Monday evening...really enjoyed our food...however, we were shorted a family salad and I haven't been able to reach anyone to see if that could be corrected.“

“Great food & service.“

“loved the Caesar salad!! Marg. Pizza was also great.“

“Wonderful dining experience. Highly recommend!“

“Amazing food! Get the scallops, you won’t be disappointed!“

“I came here with my daughter on a Saturday around 2pm. We were seated very quickly. Lots of tvs showing many different sports programs! David was our server. He was very attentive, nice, and patient as it was our first visit. He recommended the passion fruit marg (delicious!). My little one got a cheese pizza with apple sauce and lemonade. I got a small Tuscan chicken pizza. My little one said it was yummy and I agree! We had a great lunch and our food came out quickly without issue. For sure coming back! They even offer to personalize things for you. Highly recommend for a family outing, friend outing, or date. Great for all ages.“

“Had a great time watching the games and service by Joe C. was the best we’ve had anywhere in a long time. He takes pride in his work and it shows.“

“We ate at Mimo’s for the first time tonight. We were seated by the man himself. The place is cozy and authentic. We were served complimentary delicious warm bread knots with marinara dipping sauce and my gosh, are they amazing. Warm, fresh baked and just enough garlic. Grabbed calamari for our appetizer. It was cooked well and served with marinara. We ordered the large cheese pizza for the teenager, baked sausage ziti and linguini alfredo. We finished off with the best tiramisu I’ve ever had. EVERYTHING was perfection. Authentic, delicious and filling. Mimo, is kind, funny and a master at his craft. Please go visit this lovely locally owned spot. You’ll leave full and happy (from the food and Mimo cutting up with you).“

“UPDATE 12/16: Paul was fired and GM Jeff 1000% made it right with me. He's a great manager that understands how to treat customers. He leads by example and has a great staff here. 12/10: Paul is rude and unprofessional. I ate here often until my encounter with him today.“

“The food is always delicious“

“it wasn't bad. I do love the grilled chicken salad there.“