8 Best Italian Restaurants in Columbus

“The lasagne was seriously the best we have ever eaten! It was definitely homemade and authentic. The flavors of the meat, cheese, sauce, & pasta blended into a delicious entre. I would highly recommend Angotti's Restaurant if you are in Columbus, Indiana.“

“So glad to see a high quality butcher shop back in downtown Columbus. I recently had them do a specially seafood order for me - fresh mussels and crawfish for a seafood boil. The seafood boil turned out great and the mussels were super fresh as all opened and tasted great. The mud bugs made a unique add to the presentation.“

“We were traveling from Florida & it was a stressful day of driving so we stopped for dinner (it also happened to be my birthday). Katelyn was our waitress (along with 2 trainees) and I cannot say enough about how good she was! She is a phenomenal employee & truly made the end of my day special.“

“Great place..............“

“Y'all I drove all the way from Hilton Head Island, South Carolina to try them out!! BlackSheep Pizza did not disappoint at all!! from the drinks to the appetizers to the meal, every thing was fresh and how we ordered it!! Our server was exceptional and kept our drinks filled without asking! Y'all the service we received was top notch and I can't wait to return!!“

“Had another delicious supreme thin crust pizza. Generous toppings & friendly staff. My server was Justin (very nice). Even explained how to get a better deal (love that). If you're looking for a delicious pizza you don't have to wait an hour for - this is the place. They will not disappoint. Everything is great 👍“

“Sadie & Lauren behind the bar were awesome. My first time there & I will definitely be back. Thanks ladies!“

“I had a awesome delivery driver named Avery and the young lady that took my order was very sweet the pizza was awesome thank you“