40 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shadeland

1 Arni’s Lafayette Shadeland

4.4 Superb 110 Reviews

2523 IN-25, Shadeland

“Delightful Arnis. Maned by three employees and they can hold their own. Little busy on Thursday afternoon. Boys from fire department were in as well. Placed order, and didn't seem like a long wait. Food was hot. Burnt my tongue on the pizza.Good experience during this visit. Will return and tell friends. Parking: Restaurant share lot with gas station and liquor store.”

2 Azzip Pizza

4.6 Superb 270 Reviews

105 Farabee Drive South Suite B, Lafayette · 5.93 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Visited for the first time today. Had the lunch special, 1/2 potato head pizza, sticks, salad. Everything was fantastic! Now I wish you had one in Kokomo!”

3 The Pickle

4.6 Superb 244 Reviews

914 Union Street, Lafayette · 4.85 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We just ordered delivery from Niko's. Absolutely amazing!!! The antipasto salad, wraps, and pizza sticks were delicious. This will be our nee delivery spot for sure!!!”

4 The Tap

4.7 Superb 767 Reviews

100 South Chauncey Avenue, West Lafayette · 4.07 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Extremely fast service for as busy as they were”

5 Azzip Pizza

4.8 Superb 107 Reviews

939 Sagamore Pkwy W, West Lafayette · 5.69 miles

“Visited for the first time today. Had the lunch special, 1/2 potato head pizza, sticks, salad. Everything was fantastic! Now I wish you had one in Kokomo!”

6 Pizza Twist

4.8 Superb 106 Reviews

334 East State Street, West Lafayette · 4.14 miles

• Delivery

“Absolutely phenomenal ! The food was delicious… the atmosphere is great for all ages ; the staff is so friendly… it has such a comforting feeling something completely different . Not your traditional pizza spot . I had the Tiki Masala Tacos and they were amazing ( definitely get yourself a spoon if you are a messy eater 😅) and we had the pepperoni pizza that was a 10/10!”

7 Pizza Hut

4.5 Superb 270 Reviews

100 Farabee Drive North, Lafayette · 5.92 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Pizza Hut is back folks! We were so looking forward to eating here and it did not disappoint! This is a OG Pizza Hut and it brought back the memories! Food was really great and there are so many options for crust and toppings you can’t go wrong. It is also a great value! If your spending $12 on a Big Mac, skip the indigestion and come down to Pizza Hut!”

8 Pizza King | Battle Ground, IN

4.7 Superb 66 Reviews

105 North Street, Battle Ground · 11.06 miles

• Delivery

“Brookston Prairie Township Volunteer Fire held a family dinner, on a Friday night, that required a very large order from Battle Ground Pizza King. All the pizza’s and breadsticks were perfect and tasted amazing!!! Thank you for the perfection and pride you took in putting our order together! We will be back!”

9 Magoo’s Pub & Pizza

4.7 Superb 156 Reviews

1802 Schuyler Avenue, Lafayette · 5.97 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great food , very friendly atmosphere. pricing and service outstanding. 10 of 10”

10 Parkway Pizza & Subs

4.5 Superb 80 Reviews

405 Sagamore Pkwy S b1, Lafayette · 5.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Amazing food & great service..!!😋”

11 Pizza Uncommon

4.4 Superb 103 Reviews

111 South Salisbury Street Suite 120, West Lafayette · 4.07 miles

• Delivery

“We had a wonderful experience and delicious pizza and gelato in Westfield yesterday for our first trip. Staff was great had a little problem but they fixed it quickly and went above and beyond what was necessary. Loved our hot honey pepperoni breadsticks and the pizzas we got. Can’t wait to be back for other options to try. Grabbed some gelato to go and it was great too. If there was one in Fishers we would be in trouble”

12 Arni's Lafayette Market Square

4.3 Superb 168 Reviews

2200 Elmwood Avenue, Lafayette · 5.58 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Best pizza around! Wide variety menu that pleases the entire group.”

13 Bruno's Pizza

4.4 Superb 95 Reviews

2512 Covington Street, West Lafayette · 4.14 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Stop reading reviews and go to Bruno’s.”

14 Arni’s Lafayette 350 South

4.2 Good 250 Reviews

3111 Builder Drive, Lafayette · 4.64 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Everything always so fresh and good! Service was great!”

15 Fox's Pizza Den

4.2 Good 150 Reviews

4921 IN-26 East, Lafayette · 7.87 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Our food was DELICIOUS! Fast, friendly and clean. We will be back”

16 Burt’s Place

4.3 Superb 74 Reviews

623 Main Street, Lafayette · 4.41 miles

• Delivery

“My family is from Chicago and this was close to what you can get! When fresh.. the cheese pull on the deep dish was perfection and the crunch and flavor of the crust was all around delicious! The waiter was very attentive and generous. Made sure we had all of our needs met. Loved the atmosphere 👌🏻 if you dont want it to be too busy and want a great lunch.. definitely come in when they open. Thanks for the great experience 😀”

17 The Black Sparrow

4.4 Superb 238 Reviews

223 Main Street, Lafayette · 4.24 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Our 1st choice for beer + pizza [despite lackluster server attitudes], but my Blue Moon has been lukewarm the last two visits. :( Asked the waiter for a cold option and was met with an annoyed “meh” response and excuse for the warm beer vs interest in a customer issue/solution seeking…so we left for our 2nd choice. Might return to the Sparrow, might not.😕”

18 Monical's Pizza of Lafayette

4.2 Good 56 Reviews

3500 State Rd 38E, Lafayette · 5.28 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“First time ordering from this location, everything was perfect from ordering to delivery! Highly recommend!”

19 Arni’s West Lafayette Pay-Less

4.1 Good 57 Reviews

1032 Sagamore Parkway West, West Lafayette · 5.86 miles

• Delivery

“Our staff picks up lunch from Arni’s every Tuesday and it’s always the best experience! We have about 15 meals we order each week and everything is always totally correct and delicious! They are also the friendliest bunch you’ll run into.”

20 Pizza Hut

4.0 Good 236 Reviews

506 Sagamore Parkway West, West Lafayette · 5.83 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“fantastic service, great food, and the salad bar is amazing!”

21 Luca Pizza di Roma

4.3 Superb 15 Reviews

2415 Sagamore Parkway South, Lafayette · 5.3 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“It's always a nice place, to stop by, for spaghetti and meatballs. It's my favorite item that I've tried. The pizza is delicious. The employees are excellent with their customer service and good to chat with. It's always a good stop, while at the mall.”

22 Hunt Brothers Pizza

4.8 Superb 5 Reviews

1901 Schuyler Avenue, Lafayette · 6.04 miles

• Delivery

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

23 Hunt Brothers Pizza

5.0 Superb 4 Reviews

4601 Dale Drive, Lafayette · 7.02 miles

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

24 Arni’s Lafayette Pay-Less

4.0 Good 70 Reviews

2513 Maple Point Drive, Lafayette · 5.61 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“They always have the BEST pizza ever.”

25 HotBox Pizza

4.0 Good 61 Reviews

302 Vine Street Ste 120, West Lafayette · 4.21 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This was some delicious pizza! We tried the Philly cheesesteak pizza, and some breadsticks, late one night, and everything was perfect. The breadsticks in their cheese dip is everything you want and breadsticks. The pizza was delicious, and impossible to stop eating.”

26 Pizza Hut

4.0 Good 59 Reviews

35 Beck Lane, Lafayette · 2.62 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Tonight (09/29/24) my Fiance and I were trying to purchase dinner for a birthday event late after work; I placed this order at another location and had a terrible experience to say the least. We did not take the food but we did receive a credit from said store. Afterwards we had called the Beck LN location to see if they would transfer the credit seeing as we really didn’t want to use it at the store had a bad experience with. Unfortunately this is not their standard practice. However, after explaining what had happened the manager working tonight (Dylan) expressed extreme hospitality as well as a sincere apology & offered to remake our order at no cost of our own to provide a better experience. When we went in to pick up the food at Beck LN it was hot, made with love, and executed in a timely manner! Dylan even surprised us with cinnamon rolls! 10/10 the best experience I’ve had with a local restaurant in YEARS! GIVE THIS MAN A RAISE ??? Thanks for your kindness Dylan!”

27 Hunt Brothers Pizza

5.0 Superb 3 Reviews

1803 Veterans Memorial Pkwy S, Lafayette · 3.8 miles

• Delivery

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

28 Hunt Brothers Pizza

5.0 Superb 3 Reviews

9150 W 500 N, West Lafayette · 10.68 miles

• Delivery

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

29 Hunt Brothers Pizza

4.2 Good 10 Reviews

1920 Main Street, Lafayette · 4.81 miles

• Delivery

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings”

30 Hunt Brothers Pizza

5.0 Superb 2 Reviews

4 IN-28, Romney · 8.26 miles

• Delivery

“Husband had this pizza years ago at a rural location. He completely forgot about it until seeing sign at a different location in another very rural area. I personally have never had it and I'm extremely picky when it comes to pizza. It's one of my favorite foods. Well he suggested I try it because he remembers loving it over a decade ago. So I agreed and got a simple pepperoni pizza and then drove 15 mins home. Only cost $11.99 plus tax for a 12" Pizza which is cheapest pizza I've ever purchased. I had to rewarm it which made me hesitant on the quality. I was totally wrong. THIS IS BY FAR THE BEST PIZZA I HAVE EVER EATEN. First purchase for me was yesterday and today I went out and bought 2 more. Great dough, sauce, cheese the works. I will forever be a Hunt Brothers Pizza only..”

31 Cravin's To Order

5.0 Superb 2 Reviews

3898 State Rte 38 Suite C, Lafayette · 5.97 miles

32 Pizza Hut Express

4.5 Superb 2 Reviews

3630 South Street, Lafayette · 6.21 miles

• Delivery

“Our Server, Michael, was outstanding ! Although it appeared he was the only Server at the time, he was not hurried, was attentive, friendly, and accurate with our order and needs ! He was very friendly and personable ! A Great Employee and Person ! He should be Recognized and Rewarded !”

33 Hunt Brothers Pizza

5.0 Superb 1 Review

3029 Old Romney Rd, Lafayette · 2.03 miles

• Delivery

34 Mad Mushroom

3.9 Good 102 Reviews

3014 Underwood Street, Lafayette · 6.36 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I used to order from here all of my free dollars!! Until I lost my job:( Everything here is always made free and mouth watering delicious!! Delivery is always prompt on the time they say! The food is also always delivered or even picked up greeted with smiles!!! Feed your Mad Head;)”

35 Arni's Columbian Park

3.9 Good 73 Reviews

2323 Wallace Avenue, Lafayette · 4.88 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Arni's is a nostalgic favorite for many Lafayette natives. The crust is rolled flat with no edges. The pepperoni is ground. Pizza is ready in 10 minutes. Small no frills dining area inside. Customers mostly opt for carry-out. This location is right next to the Frozen Custard. A veritable twofer!”

36 Monical's Pizza of West Lafayette

3.9 Good 70 Reviews

3457 Bethel Dr C, West Lafayette · 6.46 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Son had a sub and we ordered two types of pizza. Great atmosphere and pizza.”

37 HotBox Pizza

3.9 Good 55 Reviews

2049 Veterans Memorial Parkway South Ste 11, Lafayette · 4.08 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Came here for a pick up order on a Saturday night. Ordered extra Large They made it wrong and made a large The employee was so nice and remade the correct one and let us keep the large. While I waited she offered me a drink as well. This place has great customer service and they actually care about correcting their mistakes. Whoever runs this place is doing a good job in taking care of the customer. Thank you”

38 Hunt Brothers Pizza

3.0 Average 2 Reviews

2210 Teal Road, Lafayette · 4.36 miles

• Delivery

39 Boomerangs Social House

4.5 Superb 43 Reviews

352 East State Street, West Lafayette · 4.15 miles

• Delivery

“Fantastic…. That doesnt even begin to describe how awesome Thanh Tran did as my server. I walk in thinking itll be just some normal regular bar. Thanh Tran sits me down, and i was just talk about how boring my days been. THEN BOOM! THANH TRAN INTRODUCES TO ME THE ARCADE SECTION. I get on that thing, and my day…no my entire MONTH got ten times better all because of THANH TRAN!!! she even brings my food and drinks to the game i was on. HOW AWESOME IS THAT?! Keep it up Thanh”

40 Mad Mushroom

3.7 Good 27 Reviews

307 Sagamore Pkwy W #300, West Lafayette · 5.13 miles

• Delivery

“Excellent pizza and excellent service! Upon ordering, I found they knew what I wanted better than I did. They were very helpful and patient, making apt suggestions. This team was obviously very busy but they busted their butts and executed on our very large, last-minute order very efficiently and courteously. Vegan options are amazing and once they realized it was my granddaughter’s birthday, they brought her out a complimentary cookie! Great group! Great experience! Dietary restrictions: Great vegan options!”