15 Best American Restaurants in Shelbyville

“Our cool waitress Harlee was very attentive and kicked around with my kids, despite them acting a fool at times.

All my kids got lots of thick chocolate chip pancakes for $6/kid. She was very nice and there was a great atmosphere.“

“I have steak and egg breakfast every Sunday morning. Kyle makes sure my coffee cup never gets empty.“

“👍I had a bus load of students that were taken care of efficiently, orders all correct and food was excellent. The manager offered me a complimentary dinner that I had to decline because of my duties but the ice cream cone I finished was delectable! Thank you so much for the professional service and great attitude! We will be back!“

“great games great service always a great time ��� instant Load available“

“I've eaten here multiple times, and until tonight, the last couple times have had me ready to swear off ever coming back. But tonight was amazing! The hostess was over cleaning a table but came right over to seat us. What a refreshing change! Usually, they're on their phones or huddled up talking anymore. And it only got better from there. Our server, Raven, was delightful. Just the right amount attention. And she did something I rarely see anymore, she took our dirty dishes or empty glasses. I don't know the name of the hostess, but I continued to see her cleaning tables etc throughout our meal. The food was also amazing, fast and cooked just right. But the service was just, wow! I'm gushing over something that used to be commonplace lol“

“The food was excellent“

“Excellent service! Fast cooking and really overall just really nice! Made sure everything is correct and good! Definitely will be coming back“

“The food and service here were exceptional. This is a great restaurant with great food and very friendly staff.“

“I grew up on JB's Pizza King that was on 135 in Greenwood next to at that time True Value. Early 80s and until I graduated in 87 and left for the military. I came home in 2012 and it was gone and then someone opened one in Whiteland and I'm glad it closed because they crucified everything I remember pizza king being. Then an Arnie's restaurant opened up on 135 and they said it was from the Original pizza king Bros. And it was good but not what I remembered. Until tonight. Cagneys is what I remember as a kid. The memories I thought forever gone of the pizza king pizza with my mom and dad had been located. Thank you Cagneys. Not was is delicious but I actually had a moment that got to me from those memories. Fantastic pizza. You will not be disappointed. Thank you so much Cagneys!“

“What a wonderful little Cafe! Exhausted from a day of exploring and very hungry, we decided to eat here.

We were not disappointed.
Home cooking, YUM!
Our waitress Donna was very polite and down to earth. Loved Her!

Thank you for Wonderful Lunch!
There are things in here you may critique... but why?

This place made us feel like we could be ourselves, let our hair down, so to speak and fill our bellies full! Thank you ?“

“Great Food Fun and People“

“I had the Country Fried Steak and my friend had the Liver and Onions. Both dishes were excellent, very tender and tasty. The mashed potatoes were neon yellow which looked a little odd. They tasted okay but were thin. We just found out they have a senior menu but you have to ask for it.“

“Found this place as my Dad passed while visiting Shelbyville....here for 4 days and have been here 5 times so far!! Thank you!!!“

“Great food! Good service! No waiting! Love the ice cream!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️“

“Just took my family here for the first time, ordered 2 16 oz. New York Strip, a 12 oz Strip, and a 6oz. sirloin for my 2 year old. after 40 minutes the food came, which isn't really the issue since they were busy. The only steak that was edible was my sons 6 oz. sirloin. All 3 of the stripes didn't even seem like strip cut of steak since there was no fat strip and the entire center of all 3 was full of fat and gristle and we're inedible. I showed the waitress our 3 plates of chewed up and spit out steak and explained what happened, and she brings the bill with 55 dollars removed. I tipped her 20 dollars as I'm not cheap and wasn't looking for free food, but still ended up paying $80 for 3 inedible steaks and some sides. Was also charged twice for a Dr. Pepper refill that was never ordered. Paid it anyways to just get rid of the experience. Really ugly customer service from management. Will definitely never be coming back. I'm sure not everything on the menu is trash, but if you're looking for a decent steak house to feed your family, I would definitely suggest avoiding this place. Texas Roadhouse wannabes that completely missed the mark.“