15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sheridan

“We ordered from here last night and the Manicotti was so delicious. The prices were great too.“

“The employees there are very welcoming.Great attitudes, great service, and the food is always good. You have the only pizza that I will eat everything veggies and all on it.I will not do that with any other pizza.If I go somewhere else, it's pepperoni, only l o l good job, guys.Great food very worth it two.“

“perfecto para largo partes“

“Great hot food!!!“

“Solid pie and kids plate. Good service. Good beer selection (although they often “just ran out” of the one I order).“

“I ordered pizza on Memorial Day and the service was amazing! They said it would be an hour or more wait, but they came to my place earlier! The pizza is not super greasy, and they always have the perfect amount of sauce! Most places slack on the sauce.“

“Jackson who was at the window tonight was so kind, considerate, and communicative! On National Kindness Day, it is a breath of fresh air when we can all give each other grace!

Everyone who works in customer service who shows up to do their best work should be appreciated! Jackson, thank you. Always remember it costs nothing to be kind and in doing so you can make someone’s day!

Pizza Hut help Jackson to know how much he’s appreciated!“

“Can't say enough to compliment the staff here. Every time I've been in, either as a customer or a delivery driver, they have been kind and professional. Beyond that, the food is fantastic. The pizza is perfect every time and the gelato is always a delightful experience. This place is great!“

“Large order for an annual meeting. A fellow board member recommended the place, staking his reputation on the quality. Taking him at his word, we ordered the day before (always give at least 24 hours notice for large orders) and I volunteered to pick it up. They were cutting the last pizza as I entered the store, perfect timing. Then, without my asking, they helped me carry all the pizzas out to my vehicle, excellent customer service. The pizza arrived hot and was devoured. Several people asked me afterward where it had come from and I was happy to also recommend Bella's.“

“Food was great and easy to order online“

“We read the reviews before placing a DoorDash order. The great reviews were spot on. This pizza is terrific, crust has a hint of garlic and perfect amount of sauce. We are very pleased and will be a repeat customer. Well done, thank you!!“

“3/4 of the staff are competent, timely, personable, and courteous. Food's more than adequate for a neighborhood watering hole. It *is* pretty bright in there all the time but I imagine that's due to the issues inherited from before (🤷).“

“When I first entered the store I was greeted by the workers and they were very welcoming. It had been a while since I last came to this location and I decided to give it another try. Im so glad that I did because you can definitely tell that there is new managment. Everyone was really friendly and I think it was the fastest I received a pizza. I will be coming back again and im so happy for the new improvements.“

“Perhaps the best pizza I've ever had? Marco's has so many options you're able to tailor the pizza exactly to your tastes. I tried thick crust, lightly baked, hot honey pizza with really yummy crust seasoning and I'm upset I finished it today. It was perfectly done to my preferences! I ordered a small and it was a very generous small. We also got their brownies, which doesn't quite clearly state that they are going to give you the whole pan of brownies but they did and it was very chocolatey and gooey and yummy.
I was able to have the pizza and brownies for two days as the only thing I ate and I didn't go hungry. Somehow I also didn't get sick once, and I get sick quite easily (TMI) so that's pretty impressive. The ingredients must be pretty fresh and safe! I like that they include all of their calorie information in your order as well. As I adjusted my order (thick crust vs thin crust), the calorie count per slice at the top adjusted with it. I've been counting my calories and I was able to have a brownie and half a small pizza (hot honey pizza with just pepperoni, not old world pepperoni) every day for just about 1200 calories. Wow!
This location is very generous as well. They send us great deals and you can tell they really care. Our delivery was very quick and prompt, the pizza was hot and fresh when it got here. Kelly herself was even out in our neighborhood delivering an order. They care about feedback and hearing why you haven't been back in a while if that's ever the case. They actively seek out how to do better which I've never seen from a pizza place.“

“Picked up a scheduled / call ahead order of over 30 pizzas for a high school performance. Everything was hot and ready to go on time. Staff were super nice and made sure we had everything we needed.

Not really a dine in location but they turn out a lot of great delivery and take-out orders.“