Browse menus, reviews and photos of the best places to eat in Spencer.
Wineries · $$
491 Timber Ridge Road, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“We’ve been coming here for over two years and have never had any complaints. The staff are so friendly, and the wines and food are to die for!”
Diner · $
1 North Main Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“I had the Affogato today and it was amazingggg. Even though I've been going here for years, I don't think I ever appreciated how good their espresso really is until I got to taste it by itself and then with ice cream! so good”
Thai · $
6 East Market Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“I can’t recommend Jits more. The food amazing and the staff is awesome. We are so grateful to have such an amazing place in this cool small town. Thank you Jits.”
Brewpubs · $
14 North Washington Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“Great service and excellent food! If you want comfort food, this is the place to go. I had the Cuban with a side of mixed veggies. Their in-house mustard and poutine are amazing.”
Family · $
661 West Morgan Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“This Diner is amazing. Wait staff are related and kitchen staff on point. Anna and Billy make the food and it always taste good. I quit Chambers and Busy Bee just because of this Diner and how they go above and beyond. The New Owner and Management have kept and improved the restaurant. PS: I’m a large man, if the place was bad I’d be the one to let you know. Yes sometimes people make mistakes but if Crossroads does, they’ll fix it with a smile they don’t get offended at all. Try it once and see, you’ll return it’s that good.”
American · $
72 West Market Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“Great place to eat”
Family · $
2434 US-231, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“I took a couple of friends there yesterday and we all were very happy. One ordered 1/4 chicken, another got the ground sirloin steak with onions and mushrooms. I got the ham. The sides are wonderful, especially the green beans, excellent! My wife was in Texas but I told her that when we get moved back to Bloomington next month, we'll patronize these folks again. The couple and I have been there before, many times and never had a complaint. Their food is always good, no complaints. I enjoy the decor also. We also had a very acomadating waitress, sorry, I forgot her name. We'll be back.”
Mexican · $
405 East Franklin Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“This place is always a great time! Great food, excellent service, and the best margaritas around!”
Pizza · $
330 IN-46, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“If you’re looking for something familiar (like the former Pizza Pantry favorites) and done well—this is the place!! We called in a large order the night before for lunchtime pick up on a Saturday. The pizza was ready on time, delicious, and perfect! They weren’t happy with a few breadsticks and even remade them so they were exactly perfect. We couldn’t have been more pleased with the whole experience! The people were kind and worked hard to get us squared away! I would highly recommend Pantry Pizzeria in Spencer!”
Mexican · $
330 IN-46, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“Extremely fresh and chef made meals to order. High end cuisine, beverages, and atmosphere. Not your typical restaurant. Excellent Mexican and American menu. The jack daniels burger is over the top! Worth the trip to Spencer Indiana. Ultra clean!”
Chinese · $
641 West Morgan Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“Absolutely love Bruce and his crew...awesome food...good prices...they don't make anything anywhere else as good as they do it here...thanks so much for all the food food...”
Sandwich Shop · $
168 East Morgan Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“Always using their manners, bags everything neatly and gently. no matter what they show up with smiles on their faces!! they are so kind. definitely one of my favorite places to eat!!”
Pizza · $
168 East Morgan Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“The best chicken bacon ranch pizza! We had a birthday party last Saturday and they were so sweet and accommodating. And we had 7 kids! Didn’t even ask for refills. She was just right there. All the pizzas were amazing. And the best part of course is the BREADSTICKS ???”
Fast Food · $
280 IN-46, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“I went through the drive thru. Food is always good here I've never had any problems. I ordered the spicy chicken and it was warm when I got it so I'm happy.”
Fast Food · $
480 East Morgan Street, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“Staff was great. There was a miscommunication but there was a lady who was very apologetic which was not needed still I appreciate it! Always my favorite McDonald's to go to in 2 different states!”
Ice Cream Shop · $
330 IN-46, Spencer
Customers’ favorites
“Delicious ice cream! So creamy.”
Bakery · $
109 South Main Street, Spencer
“Sweet Escape has been a great addition to our community! Their service is top notch as is the quality of the treats. I love how they change up their menu throughout the year. I am thankful for the delivery option!”
Ice Cream Shop
2661 Cunot-Cataract Road, Spencer
“So cool to step back in time at this historic one-room school house from the 1800s turned ice cream shop!! Many pieces from the past are on display; it is super interesting! And the ice cream is delicious as well! The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable about the history of the building, and they love to share with visitors. The outside area around the school house is very cool to check out as well!”