13 Best Sandwich Shops in Terre Haute

“Friendly workers and the smell of good sandwiches!! Way better than Subway! 5 stars!!!!“

“I eat here regularly. Good, fresh, food at a reasonable price with many numerous choices and combinations of cold roll ups or hot pressed, salads, soups, fresh-baked cookies, ice cream treats, and chips. Friendly staff. Quick service. Very clean restaurant. They have punch cards for frequent visits.“

“Very kind and helpful staff. Being displaced small business from the tornado, they were very helpful and welcoming.“

“Only in today's economy would I rate a place 15 stars / 15 stars for food, service, and atmosphere but rate the place overall 4 stars bc of cost / pricing. $7 for something that has just meat and cheese on it? That's their Slims I'm talking about, so you can't just say well condiments are free bc they don't (and won't afaik) put any condiments on those. Otherwise this place is bomb. Always good food, always super fresh ingredients. To this day, I've only had one sub-5★ experience at Jimmy John's, and I've easily eaten there ~100 times. (Yes, that many. I was once a college student when Slims cost $2.)“

“Food only gets 3 stars bc this place is so dang expensive that I'm not sure the quality of their food, which is pretty high mind you, is worth the money that they charge. About 10 years ago, the "Slim" sandwiches were $2, and some would say that while their price has gone up 150% since then that it is fairing relatively well in relation to inflation. However, the cost for such a basic sandwich should have remained under $4, not the ~$5.50+ that they charge now. I mean all that you are getting is meat, cheese, and bread. What makes it weird for me is all of their "freebies" - veggies, mustard, oil, etc - are not free on the Slims. They will give you packets of mustard because they aren't "allowed" to use their fresh mustard? Surely that's just not cost effective at all. But I guess that's the whole idea behind the Slim subs. But to compare, for the same price as some footlong subs at Subway, the Slims are crazily overpriced.

Parking: Plenty of parking available in front of store.“

“Small place with lots to offer. Freestyle soda machines, also the place is very, very clean everytime I've been in here. The workers are kind, making a sandwich is straight-forward and smooth, and the sandwiches themselves are amazing.

Parking: Connected to a gas station, there's not many spots but most likely you'll be in and out. But there's also a drive through here.“

“We just had a great experience at this location. In a world sorely lacking in good customer service, they had 2 young woman on this shift who were so friendly and sweet! They had genuine smiles & good attitudes while at work. It’s was so unlike other fast food locations in the area where you almost feel like your bothering them for being there. Such a refreshing experience!

And of course…we always love a good Penn Station sandwich! Nice, fresh & delicious!!“

“I come thru this subway everyday Tues- sat every week for lunch. Out of all the times I’ve came here I have never been let down. The staff here is super friendly and very fast and efficient in the work they provide. I would most certainly say this is the best subway location in Terre haute! Amazing job guys, keep up the amazing work!“

“Ordered online last night (Friday 8/14) and when I entered to pick up two gentlemen were working. One of them greeted me when I entered, which is good. I was a little early so had to wait, but since I had a beverage with my order they automatically offered me the cup so I could fill up while I was waiting. The order was filled correctly, the food was delicious and it was done with a smiling face. Something you just don’t see everywhere you go. We visit TH often to visit family. This place will certainly be on the shortlist of places we will frequent. Thanks!“

“We visited this place on Saturday, August 8, 2026. We were served by a very kind older gentleman. He was always smiling. By the way, he worked alone, but the place looked clean, and it was the first time I'd seen a covered food counter, protecting the vegetables from flies. Soft instrumental music was playing, creating a peaceful atmosphere for eating.

That gave me the confidence to eat there.“

“The subway has a large dining area. I really like that. It's not cramped into two booths like some other places are. The food is good as always. It's great to be able to make your own condiment decisions. Still don't have very many sides, just chips, but it's a good meal.

Parking: Large parking lot.“

“Cherelle was extremely helpful and provided excellent customer service. She had a great attitude, was friendly, professional, and made sure everything was taken care of quickly and correctly. It’s always nice to be greeted by someone who genuinely seems to care about the customer experience. Thank you, Cherelle, for the great service! Highly recommend this Subway location.“