22 Best Ice Cream Shops near West Lafayette

“Great, friendly service. Tons of flavors, Delicious ice cream.“

“We found this gem during our visit to West Lafayette and definitely one of the best ice creams we had. The ice creams tasted so fresh and amazing taste. They got more than 30 flavors and lot of items to choose from. They dont offer samples, but the scoops are generous. We can see lot of locals out there. The store is well maintained and clean. The staff is friendly and patient. It is 15 to 20 minutes' drive from Lafayette hotel area but definitely worth the drive.
Sufficient parking shared with other shops on this small strip mall. They have indoor and outdoor seating too. Perfect stop for a hot day and grab an ice cream!! Definitely worth trying this spot dont miss out.“

“Anyone giving this place 1 star over the “no samples” policy needs to take a breath and open a newspaper.
Do you have any idea what’s happening in the sample spoon market right now?
No. You don’t. Nobody does.
Because Big Spoon owns the newspapers.
Let me walk you through this. Those little pink spoons are made of plastic. Plastic is made of oil. Oil is made of dinosaurs. Dinosaurs are extinct. EXTINCT. As in, they are not making any more of them. I shouldn’t have to explain supply and demand to people who can’t even commit to a flavor.
That little spoon in your hand? That’s not a utensil. That’s a velociraptor. A velociraptor who has been dead for 150 million years, who got pressure-cooked inside the earth for eons, refined in Texas, molded in a factory, and shipped to a strip mall, all so you could taste one atom of pistachio, make a face, and go “hmm, what’s the one next to it?”
You did that to a velociraptor. He could open doors.
And you want a second spoon.
I tried to warn people. I called my financial advisor and told him to move everything into spoons. He said the “spoon desk isn’t real” and that I “have to stop calling his personal phone.” Which is EXACTLY what a man with heavy spoon exposure would say. He’s in deep. His whole family is plastic.
Meanwhile Silver Dipper is the only business in America with the spine to face this crisis. They’re not cheap. They’re maintaining a strategic spoon reserve. Somewhere below that shop, I believe with my whole heart, there is a climate-controlled vault of pink spoons guarded by a teenager named Kaitlyn who has orders not to crack it open until things get “Mad Max.”
That’s not a dessert policy. That’s continuity of government.
You wouldn’t walk into Fort Knox and ask to “try a little gold to see if it’s for you.” You wouldn’t ask the Federal Reserve for a taste of the money supply “before committing.” But somehow Deb, a 61-year-old woman in a tie-dye apron, is supposed to hand over sacred dinosaur remains because you, a grown adult, cannot choose between chocolate and chocolate with sadness in it?
Deb doesn’t owe you samples. Deb is holding the line at Thermopylae.
And yes, no samples means sometimes you fly blind. Yesterday I walked in, and with the unearned confidence of a man buying a timeshare, pointed at something called “Grandma’s Bourbon Pickle Marshmallow Crunch.”
No sample. No questions. No survivors.
Was it good? Wrong question. Did Neil Armstrong ask if the moon was good? Some journeys aren’t about enjoyment. They’re about being the first.
It tasted like a county fair filed for bankruptcy in my mouth. I finished every bite. Out of respect. For the flag, and for Deb.
The ice cream here, by the way, is genuinely phenomenal, which at this point is honestly the least interesting thing about my visit.
5 stars. I’d give 6 but I understand rationing now.
Thank you, Silver Dipper. Thank you for your courage. Thank you for your service.
History will remember what you did here.
The Spoon Crisis of 2026 will not.“

“Owners are incredibly kind and wonderful, and the frozen yogurt is delicious! There's options for your friends with a sweet tooth as well as people who don't like too sweet, and a ton of toppings options with fresh fruit and chocolate and more! My favorite froyo place in Lafayette ❤“

“Nice place. Cake was designed nice. Cleaned and staff were doing their best. The line could use a little more work, probably telling where the line starts and ends because I think I cut someone without even realising it. Other than that it’s a nice place. Cake was delicious btw. We had ice cream cake and the cake/ice cream inside was >>>“

“I got chocolate custard this afternoon, amazing as always! I also love to see that they have designated parking for veterans.“

“Tried your cookies last night for the first time which came highly recommended by my kids. I got a dozen of the chocolate chunk. They were amazing“

“I had a really good experience at this Culver's! The food tasted really good; everything came out quickly. The staff were all also very friendly and nice. On top of that, I was pleasantly surprised to get a free scoop of ice cream, which was such a nice bonus.“

“My son and I just had your ice cream this afternoon and it was AMAZING!!! The chocolate ice cream is divine! Will definitely be coming back again and again! Thank you!“

“The crew at this location, was absolutely amazing, to work with. They answered any question I had, and was great help. The cookies were absolutely amazing, and didn’t last long in our house!! Super soft, and very fresh!!

Kid-friendliness: A couple of the girls, trapped, and interacted with my 8 yr old daughter. They were super sweet to her.“

“The best taste so amazing and fresh“

“The customer service was nice and friendly, store was very clean and very delicious, I had the key lime frozen yogurt“

“Fast and friendly service. Clean and aesthetic. Wide variety of snacks at fist prices. Check it out :))“

“This is my favorite place for snacks in food in Lafayette.

I can't believe I haven't reviewed this place before. I would give this place a 10 out of 5 stars if I could. It is one of the last bastions of good, reasonably priced local food in Lafayette. The owners are so kind. They recognize us when we come in and are super accommodating.

You can really see the hardwork and dedication that went into this business. While they might be a little slower than a McDonald's, their quality is unmatched by anything in the area.

They are known for their Mangollada. It's delicious. The mango sorbet is homemade. The fruit is always ripe. One time, the owner felt that he didn't put enough sorbet in my cup so he gave me an entire extra scoop for free.

Our favorites to order are the Mangollada, Fresas con Crema with vanilla ice cream, Al Pastor Tacos, and Tostiesquites.

I wish I had better photos of the food but we always start eating it before I remember to grab a picture.“

“**MY EXPERIENCE**

Stepping into McCourt's Candies feels like a nostalgic journey to simpler times. The atmosphere is rich with history, reminiscent of a bygone era, where each corner tells a story. The store is a treasure trove of exquisite chocolates and candies from around the globe, offering something for every palate. You can practically taste the charm of a bygone era as you explore the selection.

The soda fountain bar adds an extra layer to the experience, with sundaes and drinks crafted to perfection. It's a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in a classic treat. Locals and tourists alike have found a beloved haven here, cementing McCourt's as a cornerstone of Lafayette's Main Street.

This isn't just a store; it's a vibrant piece of history. Whether you're a local or passing through, McCourt's offers an unforgettable experience that captures the essence of both nostalgia and modernity. I will be back!

**HISTORY & CONTEXT**

McCourt's Candies has been a staple in Lafayette, Indiana, since its inception. Established in the early 20th century, it has become a symbol of the town's rich heritage. Over the decades, McCourt's has evolved while maintaining its core identity—a place where generations have gathered to savor unique sweets and beverages. The store's continuous presence on Main Street underscores its significance as an anchor for the community.

The establishment reflects the spirit of innovation and tradition, offering a blend of classic charm and modern convenience. Its commitment to quality and variety ensures that visitors experience not just a treat, but a piece of history. McCourt's Candies stands as a testament to the enduring allure of its offerings and its place in the heart of Lafayette.

I will be back!“

“Fast, friendly and quality service with very tasty shakes, and scoops. Clean and tidy outdoor dining area. Too bad the dining room wasnt open, we would have ordered some of their good looking food. Cant complain about prices either. This place is much better than the run down Orginal Frozen Custard place with rude employees by Colombian Park.“

“Everything was super yummy as always, but the last couple times I have gone I have been helped by a woman named Cindy. At first I thought she may have just been having a bad day, but everytime she serves me she has this constant attitude. All the other employees that have served me have always been nice, but you can just tell she doesn’t want to be there! I hope it can improve, because she is not the jolliest😞“

“I was very disappointed when we went to Culver's a little before 9 pm, I check the website for closing time and it was 10 pm so we had time to go in for custard. we get there and they were already closed and this was a little past 9pm, that is not 10 pm, either someone doesn't know how to tell time or they don't want to work. we went to DQ they were open!“

“Impeccable Customer Service! The entire crew is Awesome! Food is beyond great! Highly Recommended!“

“Every time I’ve gone in here, it’s been a great experience, it’s clean, the two regular guys that work are sweet and understanding and always helpful, polite and always have a smile on their face. They are very good at what they do and I have watched people be pretty cruel to them. We came in here daily for my dying sister as their smoothies were the only thing she could really handle, and every day they would ask how she was doing and genuinely cared and even helped me out with a dead phone. Can’t find better guys than here. Their employer is sure lucky to have them.

I think people need to remember that these kids working, are thousands of miles away, from their families that are dealing with war, they can speak and understand 3+ languages, sometimes a little patience with language barrier is all it takes, how would you feel if you were in their shoes?! Let’s be nice humans here“

“The fruit drink is the best!! 🫶🏻“