19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Gardner

“The pizza is always great. They do not skimp on toppings. They perforated the crust correctly so you don't have large bubbles with no toppings. The salad bar is always clean and well stocked. I've been going here for nearly 4 years and will continue to be a loyal patron of this location. Thank you for your consistency and friendly service!“

“I have great experiences here. I do wish they would put small boxes and sauces in a bag. That's a lot to juggle going home. I've ordered a pizza, 2 sandwiches, chicken, bread, and dessert. Plus sauces and they just pile it on top of one another when bringing it out to curbside. A bag would be nice for the small boxes and sauces. Otherwise, no complaints.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“We don’t live in Gardner, but if we are passing through on a pizza night, we order from this location rather than the location closer to home. The manager is beyond kind and helpful. The quality and atmosphere are always great, and the wait is never long.“

“We dined in and the people working were awesome! They brought out coloring books and crayons for the kids and we had great service the whole time. The food was delicious and the restrooms clean. I will come back next time we’re in Kansas!

Kid-friendliness: Coloring books and crayons for kids“

“Love this place. Great bartenders/servers-Geoff and Brandon. Was there with my wife. Salad. Pizza. Great cocktails and a beer I never tried before. Great service. Great food. Located in the same building as RoKC. Awesome place. Small outdoor area, bar, tables. Will be back!“

“It was my first time at Mod Pizza and the food was fantastic, but the food wasn’t the best part, the service I received was fantastic!
The young crew member whose name was Aidan was very welcoming and walked me through how the process works, recommending me what he thinks would work best.
I got the mod sized unlimited topping and the toppings were very fresh, the member also didn’t have a problem with changing gloves when I asked.
The pizza was fantastic and the customer service was out of this world! I will be back.“

“Stopped by Sarpino’s Pizzeria on Harold and Hwy 7 and had a standout experience. Ordered a pizza to go, and what set it apart wasn’t just the food– it was the people behind it. The staff was genuinely welcoming, not scripted. The gentleman who made the pizza came out, introduced himself, and it was clear– he takes real pride in what he’s putting out. That kind of ownership is rare. The pizza delivered. Fresh, balanced, and made with attention. You can tell when a place is just pushing orders– and when a place actually cares about what leaves the kitchen. This one cares.. Tip: Grab it to go and head over to Ernie Miller Park & Nature Center just across the way. There are tables where you can sit, eat, and watch deer move through the field. Quiet, simple, and worth it.“

“Compared to all the other “pizza chains” I feel Papa Murphy’s is a cut above. Every time I order from them the pie is loaded with fresh ingredients and is easy to bake. My biggest like is the taste.They never disappoint“

“Love having Pizza 51 in downtown Olathe! What a great addition to our amazing downtown. The pizza is amazing, if you dine in Pizza 51 has such a fun vibe with indoor and outdoor dining options. The staff is amazing and friendly. Highly recommend! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“Love the food but today I wanted a pasta with cheese on the bread and I got a single bread stick with cheese. Seems very lack luster compared to the 2 pieces of toast with cheese. Kinda disappointed“

“They use real ingredients and you can taste the difference! The pizza gets loaded up, you’re not just eating crust.“

“A great pizza place with televisions for games and fun. Service was absolutely slammed with orders which caused a slight delay but the food stayed consistently good. Servers are on top of their game! Our only complaint was the tiramisu was a solid brick straight from the freezer which made it difficult to eat. We made the best of it and considered it ice cream.“

“The pizza that was made was not what I ordered. I ordered one Hawaiian and one All Meats. I received two Hawaiian pizzas. Update… since this initial post the store owner contacted me and offered me a free pizza and said they were going to improve their training in the store to be sure customers receive what they order. I am changing my rating from one star to four.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“We had pizza tonight, at Pizza. Shoppe, on 151st and Ridgeview! Our pizza is always cooked to per-fection! The place was “absolutely packed” this evening, but that was NOT a problem for supersonic Jennifer, the OnLY waitress there! She “memorizes” everyone’s orders and prepares all salads! She moves swiftly and promptly, with outmost efficiency, and then, she picks up and cleans the tables!! We were in absolute disbelief, and have never seen anything like it, anywhere!!
Jennifer, you deserve to be recognized for your outstanding performance at Pizza Shoppe, and they are one very lucky place to have you work there! Take care,
Sylvia Cruse“

“We go to both locations, both are great! Love Taco Tuesday for sure but Burger Monday is yummy as well The wife loves the wraps. We both have eatem salads there and they are exceptional.“

“I have had nothing but good experiences here. It seems like they got some new staff members but the guy who’s usually there during the day has stuff on lock enough to keep things consistent. I usually go mid day due to my working hours, but they are consistent across the day and night.

The tip to a good pizza every time is getting the pan crust. It makes it 10x better every time. I like their pastas and garlic bites especially, but getting pasta from a pizza place seems like I’m letting myself get ripped off. They’re good though.“