15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Henderson

“we wanted to get out of Evansville and try something new this place has a great view of the Ohio River outdoor seating also available the pizza was great we also tried the cheesy bacon fries great service great atmosphere can't wait to come back and try the strombolis and onion rings!!“

“Definitely one of Henderson's better pizza joints. Got an all meat with banana peppers and extra cheese and it was well worth the money spent.

Parking: Parking can be tough. Best to pull on the street to the left of the building and walk up as the parking lot is not the easiest to get in and out of.“

“the best pizza in the tri-state“

“Picked up a large meat lovers pizza on our way home. This is the best we’ve had in a long time. Will be trying the Stromboli next.“

“We tried the pizza and thought it was very good. Bread sticks were good too. Good flavor!“

“Best pizza in Kentucky! Crust is perfect, and sauce is great. We had the super deluxe, so good! We have also tried the deluxe appetizer with mushrooms, fried banana peppers, and onion rings. All the veggies are fresh cut and hand dipped. You can definitely taste the homemade aspect. The best thing about this restaurant is customer service, from the owner to employees. Prices are very good. We will definitely be back.“

“ordered our first pizza. got wings and 2 pizzas, $32. felt the wings were small and didn't get many. flavor was good for spicy one. pizza was more like a medium sized but tasted good not greasy. ingredient amount was awesome. Will get again. loved how you express your love for God on box.“

“The local Henderson pizza place everyone enjoys. Gets really load when full and service is usually good but slower. The pizza is a thin crust crispy throughout the small 2” square slices. They also have several other good things on the menu, the Stromboli is bussin’ too!

Kid-friendliness: There’s a few 80’s arcade games in here as well as a jukebox.“

“some good stuff and convenient at most stores I love it“

“boneless wings were fantastic great atmosphere for the UK game“

“The pizza was hot and fresh. It was absolutely delicious!! I'll definitely be going back for more!! The workers where fast to answer any questions I had.“

“Love the cauliflower crust pizza. Can get them made anyway you like and it’s a great option for someone who can’t have the regular crust. Tasty.“

“To all the Papa Johns workers on Halloween night... thank you a thousand times over for above and beyond service to provide hundreds of pizzas to all of us who forget you are human beings too!!! So thank you and job well done and so sorry for the tough moments we forget to be human back ? we appreciate you all ?“

“We usually like Fazolis, however we stopped yesterday to try the subs. Me and my husband got the Italian sub. $10 a piece. We got home and tried to eat them but they were so spicy we couldn’t. We both like spicy. But for one it didn’t say it was spicy, and for 2 it was entirely too spicy. They should advertise if it’s spicy! My daughter got the club, and it only had meat and cheese on it. That’s not what the picture showed. Waste of $30!!! Do better!!!“

“In the world of 'Pizza', Pony Express offers something unique and very American. I haven't eaten here long, so, I cannot speak on consistency or anything like that. But I can tell when a place has crafted something of their own. I can recommend the All Cheese. Really reminded me of this awesome pizza you can only get at the county fair. The crust, the cheese blend. Get the garlic dipping sauce for your crusts and you're all set.

Vegetarian options: Typical pizza place situation. Toppings allow one to customize. If one has a meet allergy or anything serious, pizza places are not a good choice, as gloves don't get changed often and even cheese will have meat contamination.“