11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Mandeville

“A friend and I went to Reginelli’s for the first time this evening. We do believe our order was either lost or never sent to the kitchen when tables around us that arrived after we did were getting their food. However, as soon as another waitress and another person working there (I don’t know if he was the owner or the manager) noticed what was happening they both went above and beyond to make it right. Our food was delicious and we will be back.“

“The food here is simply delicious 😋 The mozzarella dip was amazing and the pizza was cooked to perfection! Great job!“

“We had such a great experience at Coscino’s Italian Grill! The pizza was absolutely delicious…honestly my favorite in Mandeville so far. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and cooked perfectly.

Our waitress, Olivia, was awesome. She checked on us often and even repeated our order back to us to make sure everything was correct, which we really appreciated.

Overall, such a pleasant experience with great food and great service. We’ll definitely be back!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5 Stars – The Best Pizza & Experience! I’m not usually a pizza person and typically get sick when I eat it — but McClain’s Pizzeria completely changed that for me! Their pizza is incredibly fresh, from the high-quality toppings to the perfectly made crust. You can truly taste the care and passion in every bite, and best of all, I didn’t get sick at all! McClain and Maggie are absolutely amazing, and their staff is so friendly and welcoming. The whole team makes you feel like family the moment you walk through the door. If you’re looking for the best local pizza, this is the spot. Fresh ingredients, outstanding service, and a warm, inviting atmosphere — McClain’s Pizzeria deserves to be on the map! 🍕“

“I have been to Newk’s twice already. Once for lunch and once for dinner. The food is delicious, the staff was professional, the dining room and bathroom were kept clean. I would highly recommend Newk’s!“

“Enjoyed our meal this evening. very friendly staff; Mediterranean salad is fantastic; and supreme pizza was on point- cheesy, flavorful sausage, and yummy crust. Will return!“

“Pizza Hut has been serving up pretty decent pizza my entire life. It should be included in the list with apple pie and fireworks as something all red-blooded patriots recognize as American goodness. Only a communist would hate on Pizza Hut. I do miss their Cavatappi and their sandwiches were downright cosmopolitan to a young girl growing up in a small rural town. But I can forgive them those errors as long as that greasy, delicious pan pizza crust holds out.

I can only give the atmosphere two stars since I'm now picking up my pineapple and ham masterpieces at strip malls, instead of those cool old mid-century buildings designed by Richard D. Burke in the 1960s. Nowadays they are anything but a pizza hut, but everyone recognizes that that local funeral home, dry cleaner or, starter church was definitely an old school Pizza Hut at one time. Bring back the old school, Pizza Hut, so I can upgrade my ratings!“

“This place is amazing mostly due to their manager Mr. Allen and his staff. It is apparent that they all care, and take pride in their job. They are always friendly, and address me by name every time I come in. The Covington location could learn a lot from here as I always get what I pay for.“

“Customer service usually sucks everywhere, I got to say that from my personal experience, Pizza was given to us within 15 minutes there wasn't any line though. They were not smaily meaning they were busy you can tell when when workers are not happy about working in customer service field but I would say they were just busy.“

“Had the best time playing games and the staff was so friendly“

“This is my second time at this location & when I tell you this is the best Dominoes ever!!! Jacob needs a raise cause he makes my pizza so good omg! I haven’t even made it to my destination and the pizza is gone😩😩 Keep it up guys, yall are awesome!!!“