Brotherhood of Thieves

Name: Brotherhood of Thieves
Address: 23 Broad St, Nantucket, Massachusetts, 02554, US
Telephone: (774) 325-5812
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.6

$$ • Bars, Burgers, Bar & Grill

Hours:
23 Broad St, Nantucket
(774) 325-5812

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Brotherhood of Thieves

Brotherhood of Thieves is a well-run restaurant that excels during busy times. The service is attentive and friendly, with staff creating a cozy, old-secret-bar atmosphere. The bar food is exceptional, especially the burgers and braised short rib, which are highly recommended. The atmosphere is charming and full of character, making it a favorite spot for many visitors. The drinks are flavorful and well-crafted, and the food is delicious, making it a must-visit when in Nantucket. Although prices are a bit high, typical for the island, the overall experience is worth it. The restaurant is open during the winter season and offers a memorable dining experience that keeps guests eager to return. While there can sometimes be delays in food service, staff work hard to accommodate dietary needs and provide good service. Visitors have enjoyed dishes like the traditional lobster roll with a hint of lemon in the sauce, and the surprising deliciousness of the burrata and tomato app with balsamic pearls. The salmon nigiri is also excellent. The pub atmosphere is cool but can be a little loud, and service may sometimes be slow, but overall, it is highly recommended. The place has lots of history and a unique vibe, making it a favorite for many travelers seeking good food and friendly service.