19 Best Bakeries near Tisbury

“By far the best desserts on Martha's Vineyard! My family and I have been on Martha's Vineyard for a week now and I have gone to Sweet Bites every day lol Amazing coffee, great dessert treats and the cheese bread!!! don't get me started. YUM!! You have to try the Cheese Cake. It is by far the best I have ever had! I will be taking some back with me on the ferry!“

“My favorite spot for sandwiches and pastries on the island! I’ve been coming here for years, and both the service and food have been consistently excellent. The portions are generous, so I usually have leftovers for a second meal. The last thing I had was a linguiça sandwich with plantains — it was so good that I finally went out of my way to write a review :) They’re also very accommodating toward gluten sensitivity.“

“the #9 chicken breast avocado and pesto sandwich was absolutely delicious, the only thing better was the amazing service from Natalie and her crew. definitely such a friendly and welcoming environment. wish I had more time so that I could try more.“

“I’m a hater and I hate to admit when places live up to the hype. But The Black Dog certainly surpasses its reputation.

I got the Spicy Woofer and the reason I have no picture to attach is because I practically swallowed it whole. I’m forever adding slightly cooked spinach to my breakfast sandwiches. The bacon was perfectly crispy (I love when the fat is cooked out). The clam chowder was also great. The chocolate chip cookie? Gorgeous. Spectacular. Perfection.“

“To DIE for! Fresh snd delicious! Super service and worth every penny…in one week visited twice!! Ohh lala! 💗“

“Lisa & Delicious Desserts came highly recommended by our venue and we could not agree more! Lisa is so warm and welcoming and made the whole process so fun and easy. We had about 80 people at our wedding and so while that wasn't typically large enough to have a traditional cake tasting, Lisa still made it happen for us. She really went above and beyond to make our 'cake tasting' experience fun and special. The cake we decided on was beautiful and she so kindly added a third tier relatively last minute. The whoopie pies were also a hit. Would work with Lisa again in a heartbeat!!“

“One of the best ham & cheese croissants I have ever had.“

“the best one, I love all the sweets made there“

“I was staying at the hotel across the street woke up early and needeycoffe. Hotel did not have any until 7 am. Walked over, forgot my wallet and Destiny who was working the counter provided me with a cup of great coffee on the house as they only take cash. That is service! I'll be walking back over shortly to take care of my bill and then some! Thank you Destiny!!“

“Stop 3 on our State Rd morning bakery tour! When I say fresh baked goods, I mean warm right out of the oven scones. Great service from who I would assume are the Pie Chicks. Good patio seating area to enjoy their wares. Only complaint was that there wasn’t more to try - was really counting on this place to have an abundance of baked fruit desserts, like small tarts, jam cookies, mini pies for a single serving - the large pies looked excellent but were more than a baked good tourist could manage at this stage in the game.“

“I have been a customer for a long time and I highly recommend this place, in my opinion it is the best Brazilian food on the island. The place is great and the service is excellent. The parking lot is very good. Whenever I stop there, there is plenty of space and I always park with a truck. For those who are in a car or truck, there is plenty of parking, plenty of space, an excellent place.“

“2am pick up is the best. apple fritters“

“Lovely waiter and a chef who cares. The dishes seemed inspired on paper and although good on the pallet, would have benefited from a bit of intensity on the flavor profile. I could barely taste the pistachio on our chicken and the citrus flavor was mild. The striped bass was likewise mild in flavor with no detectable herbal notes...the accompanying gnocchi was on the dry side. The Sicilian cherry tart was wonderfully flavorful.....personally would love a little more than a curl of chocolate on the top. Bread, salad, ambience and Susan! all contributed to a welcome evening out. Looking forward to seeing what else the kitchen has up its sleeve in the future.“

“Having had MANY bagels in New York during 20 years there - I can say these bagels are the best possible outside of New York. Not perfect but best available. There as a huge Sunday morning crowd but they had 7 workers lined up cranking out the orders so it went more quickly than it seemed it would. I noticed many who had online orders received their orders more quickly so I will do that next time.“

“Excellent portions even on small pies. Delicious fresh ingredients and pie crust. A great gift to give and receive . Highly recommend.“

“Amazing coffee served by cool and original people!“

“Fantastic, wonderful and delicious“

“We took a spontaneous day trip from Boston to Falmouth in mid-May. When deciding where to go for a post-run meal, we were inspired to check out The Black Dog Heights Cafe and boy are we glad we did. The service, the food, and the ambiance was outstanding. It will be our go to place whenever we are in Falmouth.“

“They are the best. We just love everything there.“