13 Best Ice Cream Shops near Tisbury

Murdick's Fudge Ice Cream • $$
9 Union St, Tisbury

“I stopped in here while visiting Martha's Vineyard for the day to grab some ice cream. They had a lot of flavors We ended up getting the muddy boots, vanilla ice cream with brownie and caramel, in a cup. It came to $5 which I found pretty expensive. The person inside was friendly and the store was clean. I'd recommend stopping in for a snack.“

4 Good4 Reviews
Bernie's Home Made Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
22 Main St, Vineyard Haven

“It was delicious �, we loved the flavor choices !!! So yummy !“

3.3 Good3 Reviews
Dairy Queen Store Ice Cream Shop • $
829 Main St, Falmouth - 6.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Reese's Peanut Butter Blizzard
Dairy Queen Swirl Cone
Make It a Malt
Ice Cream Cone
Oreo Blizzard
Hot Fudge

“Always good..well usually..can say 7/15/24 was the first terrible ice cream..first asked for chocolate ice cream in my blizzard she returned with a vanilla one and instead of remaking it especially on her own mistake put chocolate sauce in it to color it and reblended it to mix it so fair to say it was no longer a blizzard just a cup of ice cream still tasting vanilla not one single solitary chunk of anything in it and it was oreo cheesecake...“

4.3 Superb24 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
242 Main St, Edgartown - 6.32 miles

“I was pleasantly surprised with my experience at Dairy Queen!! I have been to other Dairy Queen’s before and this location definitely ranks as the best one I have ever visited! We went twice during our stay at the Vineyard and both times we were greeted by kind, smiling staff and a clean and well kept interior. The ice cream was good- which was expected by Dairy Queen but this location certainly delivered! All COVID-19 precautions were followed, and my family felt comfortable ordering there! I would definitely recommend this Dairy Queen to a friend, and to you!“

4.5 Superb8 Reviews
Scoop Shack Ice Cream Shop • $$
22 Dock St, Edgartown - 7.03 miles

“best gourmet homemade ice cream on the island - local ingredients and appetizing flavor -- island strawberry, sea salt caramel, green tea, mango sorbet etc, not weird and gummy like most other spots on MV (they got the weird cake batters and lobster ones too)“

4.2 Good14 Reviews
Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
7 N Water St, Edgartown - 6.97 miles

“My favorite childhood ice cream has now become my kids' favorite childhood ice cream! ❤️ We highly recommend the Reese's Cream, Oreo Cream, Chocolate, and the Chilmark Coffee.... all at once if you dare lol! Summer staff are all so sweet and friendly as well 😊“

4.1 Good43 Reviews
Vineyard Scoops Ice Cream Shop • $
56 Main St, Edgartown - 6.91 miles

“We’ve been having ice cream in edgartown for my entire life. Go here instead of Mad Martha’s. Scoops is better. Soft serve is great and rhetorical black raspberry is delicious.
Ambiance is meh at scoops but Mad Martha’s totally removed all the fun decorations that used to make it more fun and make up for worse ice cream.“

4.1 Good27 Reviews
Rosie's Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
19 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs - 2.91 miles

“It's incredible. The staff was the most kind staff I've ever seen at a frozen yogurt shop. The owners were phenomenal.“

4.1 Good13 Reviews
Carousel Ice Cream Factory Ice Cream Shop • $
15 Circuit Ave, Oak Bluffs - 2.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Waffle Cones

“Absoulutly delicious. The fact that they are the only ones that have sugar free ice cream we will go back all the time. There are a lot of diabetics in this world. You should put up bigger sugar free signs. Thank you for letting me feel normal and be able to have ice cream.“

4.1 Good9 Reviews
Big Dipper Ice Cream & Cafe Ice Cream Shop • $
23 Lake Ave, Oak Bluffs - 2.92 miles

“Husband & I stopped in for donuts and coffee. I also bought a huge brownie & it was delicious!“

3.7 Good16 Reviews
Tisberry Cafe: Frozen Yogurt, Smoothies and Superfood Bowls Juice Bar & Smoothies • $$
29 Main St, Vineyard Haven - 0.6 miles

Customers` Favorites

Acai Bowls

“Everything is great! Seating area, toppings, ingredients, hygiene. You will for sure enjoy your drink, dessert or meal. I worked there few years ago and I only have good memories about this place. And I know you will too.“

4.2 Good5 Reviews
Ghelfi's Candies of Cape Cod Ice Cream • $
228 Main St, Falmouth - 6.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black Raspberry cc Yogurt Strawberry
Sea Salt Mocha Pretzel
Peanut Butter Fudge
Turtle Fudge

“The best candy shop on the Cape!! Great people. Love it!“

4 Good21 Reviews
Macphail's Corner Cafe Cafe • $
18 Dock St, Edgartown - 7.02 miles

“Amazing lobster rolls!!!!!!“

3 Average11 Reviews

You May Also Like