14 Best Ice Cream Shops near Edgartown

Ice Cream and Candy Bazaar Ice Cream Shop • $
Waterfront, 11 Dock Street, Edgartown

“The Ice Cream & Candy Bazaar is a family tradition in Edgartown. Every year we visit the shop with our guests/family and they are always delighted with their selection of available treats. They have a great selection of candy for the kids, ice cream and their chocolate candy is to die for! They have the nicest staff! ❤️❤️“

4.7 Superb74 Reviews
Vineyard Scoops Ice Cream Shop • $
56 Main Street, Edgartown

“Vineyard Scoops on Main Street in Edgartown is hands down the best ice cream shop on Martha's Vineyard. The soft serve here is incredible, honestly the best you'll ever have.

My top recommendation is the Chilmark Coffee soft serve, made with locally roasted Chilmark Coffee beans. If you're a coffee lover, you definitely need to get it. It's rich, smooth, and full of real coffee flavor.

A friend (thanks Leah!) put me on to swirling it with the black sesame soft serve, and it's very good. The nutty, toasty black sesame pairs perfectly with the coffee, and it's a combination you won't find anywhere else.

Whether you're strolling Main Street on a summer evening or just need a sweet treat, Vineyard Scoops is a must. Don't leave the Island without stopping in!“

4.2 Good105 Reviews
Dairy Queen (Treat) Ice Cream Shop • $
242 Main Street, Edgartown

“I was pleasantly surprised with my experience at Dairy Queen!! I have been to other Dairy Queen’s before and this location definitely ranks as the best one I have ever visited! We went twice during our stay at the Vineyard and both times we were greeted by kind, smiling staff and a clean and well kept interior. The ice cream was good- which was expected by Dairy Queen but this location certainly delivered! All COVID-19 precautions were followed, and my family felt comfortable ordering there! I would definitely recommend this Dairy Queen to a friend, and to you!“

4.3 Superb84 Reviews
Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
7 North Water Street, Edgartown

“My favorite childhood ice cream has now become my kids' favorite childhood ice cream! ❤️ We highly recommend the Reese's Cream, Oreo Cream, Chocolate, and the Chilmark Coffee.... all at once if you dare lol! Summer staff are all so sweet and friendly as well 😊“

4.2 Good168 Reviews
Ben and Bill's of Edgartown Ice Cream Shop •
22 Dock Street, Edgartown

“We were greeted with smiles and genuine friendliness! I had their butter brickle ice cream … it was honestly “the best” ice cream I have ever eaten … they make the candy and the ice cream right there. After we finished the ice cream, we went back and bought the candy … unfortunately, the ice cream wouldn’t have made the 8 hr trip home. Highly recommend this place!! 🤩😃“

3.6 Good13 Reviews
Macphail's Corner Cafe Cafe • $$
18 Dock Street, Edgartown

“Amazing lobster rolls!!!!!!“

3.5 Good65 Reviews
Nauti Cow Ice Cream Shop • $
28 Lake Avenue, Oak Bluffs - 5.26 miles

“Nauti Cow has, hands down, the best dairy free/gluten free frozen desserts I have ever had. Their homemade treats are always amazing, and what's even better than the ice cream is the staff. This family run business truly cares about its customers.“

4.8 Superb93 Reviews
Carousel Ice Cream Factory Ice Cream Shop • $
15 Circuit Avenue, Oak Bluffs - 5.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Waffle Cones

“Our favorite ice cream place on circuit ave. The line moves fast and all of the flavors are delicious. I would recommend ordering the kiddie size (I think it's still 2 scoops you can get 2 flavors) because portions are huge. A small is too big for 1 person. Also get an extra cup because it's too hard to eat that much ice cream before it falls off the cone. I also really loved the hand made waffle cone.“

4.3 Superb64 Reviews
Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
24 Union Street, Vineyard Haven - 6.59 miles

“My favorite childhood ice cream has now become my kids' favorite childhood ice cream! ❤️ We highly recommend the Reese's Cream, Oreo Cream, Chocolate, and the Chilmark Coffee.... all at once if you dare lol! Summer staff are all so sweet and friendly as well 😊“

4.3 Superb52 Reviews
Bass Best Coffee Coffee Shops • $
12 Kennebec Avenue, Oak Bluffs - 5.27 miles

“Stopped in for a bagel and a smoothie. Great scallion cream cheese and a lovely fresh Asiago bagel (extra toasted). Husband got an everything bagel with plain cream cheese and said it was good. If you like your bagels crispy, ask for it triple toasted. Smoothie was very creamy and delicious!“

4.9 Superb27 Reviews
Vineyard's Best Ice Cream and Coffee Co. Ice Cream Shop • $$
12 Kennebec Avenue, Oak Bluffs - 5.27 miles

“Great breakfast sandwiches.“

4 Good57 Reviews
Mad Martha's Homemade Ice Cream Ice Cream Shop • $
12 Circuit Avenue, Oak Bluffs - 5.21 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Ice Cream
Ice Cream Soda
Black Raspberry
With Hot Fudge
Oreo

“My favorite childhood ice cream has now become my kids' favorite childhood ice cream! ❤️ We highly recommend the Reese's Cream, Oreo Cream, Chocolate, and the Chilmark Coffee.... all at once if you dare lol! Summer staff are all so sweet and friendly as well 😊“

4 Good116 Reviews
Rosie's Frozen Yogurt Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt • $
19 Circuit Avenue, Oak Bluffs - 5.2 miles

“It's incredible. The staff was the most kind staff I've ever seen at a frozen yogurt shop. The owners were phenomenal.“

4.1 Good24 Reviews
Big Dipper Ice Cream & Cafe Ice Cream Shop • $
23 Lake Avenue, Oak Bluffs - 5.27 miles

“Husband & I stopped in for donuts and coffee. I also bought a huge brownie & it was delicious!“

3.9 Good30 Reviews

You May Also Like