17 Best Ice Cream Shops near Hyannis

“A wonderful family place. Mini golf and soft serve ice cream. They have pizza, sandwiches and snacks as well. It is cash only but there is an ATM at the location. Been going there for nearly thirty years. A fabulous place to relax and enjoy“

“The best fudge, chocolate, and ice cream on Cape Cod!

Kilwin's is my favorite place to indulge in sweets on Cape Cod.

The fudge is absolutely addictively delicious.

I cannot stay away from the fudge. Love that they had a special, buy 2 get the 3rd free.

Definitely the sweetest place in town...

Parking: Plenty of parking in the public parking lot behind the store, no charge.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly“

“SO happy to have a delicious vegan option in the area! We tried all 3 non-dairy options available the day we visited and all were great. A heads up that they provide wooden spoons to eat with, so if that gives you a nails-on-a-chalkboard feeling like it does me, either plan to get a cone or bring your own spoon. Two clean single-stall all gender restrooms in the back of the store. A+.“

“Quick service with decent ice cream. The girl working last night was an ice cream guru. She knew every ingredient in every ice cream and didn’t hesitate for a second when asked. It was actually the most impressive thing I’ve ever seen.“

“So disappointed I waited all year for the peach ice cream. I bought a pint to take home and put in the freezer. (I only live 2 1/2 miles away.) when I took it out to eat, it had ice crystals all throughout.
** I returned to Cape Cod creamery a few weeks later and bought a quart of peach ice cream to take to a friends dinner. I must say it was the same peach ice cream I remembered. I must have received a bad batch previously. My faith is restored! Love it!“

“I finally tried this place. The strawberry shortcake ice cream is amazing. My son thoroughly enjoyed his hot fudge sundae. Everyone that works here is very friendly and they move the line fast.“

“Katie's Ice Cream on Main Street in Hyannis is easily the best ice cream spot on the Cape! We tried the limited menu window, located to the left of the main entrance—often missed by those heading directly inside. The Cookies and Cream and Death by Chocolate we had were exceptional. Alexis was friendly and knowledgeable, recommending flavors that perfectly suited our tastes. Amazing service and a fantastic local business you shouldn't miss!"“

“Friendly service fresh delicious ice cream. I love the outdoor decor seating areas.“

“I DoorDash from this place like three times a week I love it so much. The Açaí is delicious every single time and they add soooo much Nutella❤️❤️ if you guys are reading this, I love your little shop and you guys are amazing! :)))“

“The staff was nice although seemed very new, which does not come as a surprise since the whole place seems new. Flavor selection was very limited. The main reason this gets 4 stars and not 3 is the portions were generous. I would say that there are other better icecream places nearby but this is a solid choice.“

“My husband and I have a cottage around the corner and discovered this gem! I’m a bit of a pizza snob and this is great bar room pizza! We regularly order the mushroom pizza and bacon pizza and love it. Highly recommend“

“While a piping warm hot dog on a steamed bun with potato chips, with or without chili, will never be deemed fine dining, most folks occasionally enjoy it. And after a recent visit with my wife - and with the chili topping, my feeling is, "Heck, that was excellent!" Of course, the clean setting and awesome Elsie behind the counter taking orders -plus meeting Teddy, the affable owner, what's not to love? And, o yes, there's more: because my wife and I also shared their ginormous banana split; here, soft ice cream meets enough hot fudge (or caramel), mini-pineapple wedges and strawberries with whipped cream to wake up any famished swimmer, tired worker or sleepy taste bud. In short, this site does DQ proud! Perhaps the next time you crave friendly service, smooth ice cream in various styles (also in take-home popsicles and cakes in the freezer case!), saunter in. This place makes it hard to leave!“

“Takeout counter style restaurant but with a large and comfortable seating area. Traditional New England seafood place with fried clams, fish, etc. I go for the clam Chowder. I also tried the lobster bisque but it is a little sweet for my taste. You could comfortably sit a large group here and relax after a day at the beach.“

“Great atmosphere and some of the best ice cream you've ever had. This place has been around forever and has a real classic and authentic feel. It's always hopping and has a line out the door, but for a good reason. I've been coming here since I was a little kid and don't plan on stopping any time soon. If you're in the area I highly recommend giving Four Seas a visit. Try the melon flavor.“

“It has incredibly creamy and delicious ice cream. They offer tasty sundaes with a good variety of flavors. Refreshing drinks and shakes are available. Additionally, they offer an excellent option for ordering an acai bow. Very polite and amiable is the woman working the window. A place for breakfast, lunch, and dinner was also suggested by her. It's a big assistance! This location is without a doubt recommended.“

“I bought a handful of sodas last week. Best sodas I’ve ever had in my life. Highly recommend visiting if you’re in Cape Cod. Please make these available in Chicago!“

“Great food and friendly staff“