14 Best Italian Restaurants near Webster

“The ravioli and garlic bread are absolutely delicious 😋!“

“We absolutely love this bartender we showed up in a Sunday September 1st 2024 she makes the drinks perfectly she is welcoming and not rude.We ordered mozzarella st8ck and the lake special pizza whoch is always our favorite we noticed other people enjoying this bartender as well please keep her she is such a refreshing worker to this place we will be back“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Papa Gino’s never disappoints! The pizza is always fresh, perfectly cooked, and loaded with flavor. The crust has that perfect balance of crisp and chewy, and the sauce tastes homemade. The staff is friendly, fast, and makes you feel welcome every time. Whether dining in or grabbing takeout, the quality is consistent and worth every penny. Definitely my go-to spot for pizza night!“

“My parents bought a house here in Webster been trying some spots got a sub here a couple days ago it was good my signature chicken finger sub lettuce, onion, jalapenos and bbq sauce toasted it hit the spot. Today I was like I gotta try the pizza got a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza small. This was solid pizza your basic Greek style style pizza which personally I really don't mind I really like Greek style pizza crust is on the thinner side which I love was crispy I will definitely come back here. Def a solid pizza place for when I come visit.“

“i remember being so excited when this place opened as had been many times to the Plainfield location. They never disappoint is always a good experience and good food. great deals for lunch specials all the time.“

“Have been there multiple times. The food is always great, and the portions are always large. I mean large, you aren’t eating a whole dinner in one sitting!
Caitlyn has been our server on most occasions. She is always quite pleasant and does an amazing job!!!
I would definitely highly recommend Calabria to anyone looking for a great meal in a great place, who obviously works hard to retain a great staff. Thank you Calabria and Caitlyn for many great dining experiences, and many more to come!!!!“

“This place is legit. The vibe, music and.... The food! The portions are legit and priced super reasonable. $12 for a chicken parm sandwich Italian style. I am taking half home!
Stop here. Enjoy. Support small business that does it right!“

“Picked up a ~45 person order including hot and cold trays, and staff were very helpful despite it being the middle of their dinner service. Restaurant was full but seemed vibrant. I was afraid my pickup timing would be stressful but it was prompt and easy. They accommodated our group’s various mutually exclusive allergies and food restrictions with flexibility and care, and everything was delicious. Looking forward to coming back for a sit-down meal and trying more of their menu.“

“Pic is comments 1. Great owner so very welcoming. Serving sizing - well ask for a take out box a head of time ;) so good. Sooooo I’m a wing girl. I never get frozen tenders or wings. He told me he gets the best of the best meat and it was frozen. OH MY GAWD 🤩 amazing wings and their mango spicy sauce is delicious! 2. Kids sizing Holy smokes! That is the biggest kids cheese burger I have ever seen. 3. Sea food platter hubby loved and I was able to have some Haddock and it was so good. 4. Owner and kid that hooked us up outside was fantastic. What a great presence and attitude! I definitely recommend. My only complaint is they only had Coke Zero in bottles not fountain. ;) Thanks“

“Stopped on way home from RI very friendly staff and the pizza was awesome 😋“

“Amazing food, waiter was geat.“

“Such a great find! Cozy atmosphere warm and welcoming staff. Everyone is very friendly makes you feel at home! The food is incredible my son and I went for breakfast! Highly recommended if you haven't tried it yet!“

“First visit to oxfords casual dining this past weekend in Oxford and absolutely not our last. Everything was absolutely delicious, and our waitress was super busy but took good care of us. Also got to enjoy some great music from The Drunken Uncles.“

“i delivered on a Friday night at 6pm. when i called i was told first that delivery would be an hour. seeing as cooking would also take me an hour, i persisted with my order. the phone call was easy and am grateful for the forewarning on the delivery time.i ordered a cheeseburger no tomato no lettuce no mayo. my boyfriend is picky and would get upset if he ended up not enjoying his meal. he also got onion rings. i got a chicken cutlet club sandwich with french fries. delivery was only 35 minutes max. the driver was friendly. i had no problem tipping her, she was serving with a smile in the pouring rain. food came hot and cheap. my boyfriend ate his whole plate and im looking forward to finishing my sandwich off tomorrow. will be ordering again!“