19 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

“I stopped in at Fratellis a couple days ago and had the chicken parmesan. The food was stellar, but what really stood out to me was Kendra’s service. She was prompt, friendly, and had an amazing sense of humor. When I come back, I will be asking for Kendra every single time.

I highly reccomend Fratellis. Their food is amazing, and Kendra’s service was nothing but top tier.“

“I went to Tapias On Main with my husband last weekend for the first time and it was exceptional! 5 stars for everything- the rockfish on the special menu was amazing as well as the watermelon mojito! Our server Jenna was very friendly and attentive. I will definitely be recommending this restaurant to our friends.“

“First time there, the food was delicious. Best we've had in years. The arancini were crispy and hot with a delicious tomato sauce. I had shrimp arrabbiata. Fantastic. Andrea had the mushroom ravioli. That was an earthy, tasty treat pack with mushrooms. Love the cafe style. Will go back as often as we can.“

“I had an amazing experience at this restaurant ( I think my favorite restaurant ) yesterday . I had to change the time of my reservation while already at the restaurant due to late arrival of the others in my group. They graciously switched the reservation . Enrico was very helpful with a few other concerns I had about my group. The bartender was friendly and made an amazing drink while I waited for my company to arrive . Our waiter Marcello was wonderful and the food was melt in your mouth delicious ! They also have gluten free pasta and pizza dough in case someone in your group is gluten free. Can’t say enough about this restaurant that makes you feel like you are part of the family !“

“We ordered the margarita pie and it was delicious. The desserts are amazing! Would definitely recommend“

“I’ve been eating here for 15 years. Awesome every time, but today was the best! Ellen - Master cold cut Queen!“

“The best foods!!! Happy time !“

“Our high school volleyball team banquet was held at Pistarro’s in the Amalfi room. Donna and the rest of the staff was amazing. They had the room set up beautifully and the food was great. Thank you for making it easy to celebrate our athletes!“

“Always wonderful! We love coming here!“

“It’s our go to restaurant in Frederick. Very friendly staff, great food and great atmosphere!“

“Very good pizza...?. Prompt delivery service and friendly delivery guy...pizza crust was crispy and chewy at the same time, we had the Margherita pizza pie, it had spicy peppers on it, so if you like a little heat this is the one to try..????“

“My partner and I LOVE coming here! Our server the last time we came in was absolutely amazing and so kind! His name was Matthew. The manager on duty (i’m assuming that was her position) seemed quite frazzled and was rushing employees. I understand it was a Friday night but to be like that all night seems like a lot. We have seen her every time we go here and it makes me feel really bad for the hostess and wait staff that have to deal with that sort of treatment/behavior from their manager. Especially in front of customers. It makes me hope that any tip we leave goes only to our servers.

Parking: Always full“

“Me encanta. Amo la comida. Pero los margaritas son otra cosa“

“Our first time at this restaurant and our server was absolutely outstanding . Her name is Cassandra and she was very welcoming with our 4.5 year old son. Normally we get looks and comments when we go out about him being loud or theatrical but she was SO understanding and supporting . She got him icecream cake and made sure he had such an accepting experience. As parents it melted our heart and we would 10/10 recommend this restaurant as well as her service. Come see her Friday nights for an amazing experience .“

“The owner/manager of the Balleneger creek Paisanos is the absolute best! From the great service to the great food 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ all the way!“

“This is our favorite go to restaurant! The subs and pizza are amazing. The garlic knots are the best we ever had. Not only is the food amazing the owner and staff are so friendly & kind! Please support this small local business!!!“

“Great pizza! love the spaghetti! The young man who delivered tonight trouble-shot our address quick and got hot dinner here on time! much thanks on this dreary cold Friday!“

“I wasn't planning on leaving a review, however, that all changed when a very sweet man named Daniel, who is an employee but was off the clock, made the three of us beautiful origami cranes. He walked by our table with a bag and asked us if we would be interested in having a piece of origami. He waited until we were finished with our meal completely and he confirmed this, before asking which was incredibly thoughtful.

We said yes, as my son was so excited to see the origami. He pulled a chair over and made an origami crane, showing my son how to make the wings flap, before giving it to him. The food was okay, the cheese was a bit skimpy and the whole piece of cheese would slide off each slice after only one bite BUT what made the visit special was Daniel's thoughtfulness.

That small piece of origami had made our night and we won't forget that experience. He is such a sweet person. He said that he has been working there for many many years and busses tables. I hope that by leaving this review, that he will be recognized, for going above and beyond for customers and making them want to come back. Thank you Daniel and we love our origami!“

“Great selection - there's something for everyone in my household when everyone wants something different. Everything tastes great and they have exceptional customer service! Always pleased.“