Stonington Ice Cream Company

We discovered this hidden gem 8 or so years ago when we stopped in for an ice cream. Their ice cream is excellent but we soon learned that they had an lobster roll that is arguably the best around. Admittedly, the “best lobster roll” is a hot button topic but what out family likes about this one is that it has a light seasoning with fresh herbs and green onions and of course, a buttered and grilled bun. If you like your roll with a mayo dressing, this may not satisfy you but...read full review

Love it here!! The owner is so awesome and has a fantastic gallery next door! The sandwiches are delicious and the menu includes staples such as lobster rolls but also features rotating sandwiches with delicious creative and inspired recipes. The ice cream is fantastic as well!

Best lobster roll we had while on the island - we tried at 4 places in all. It was fresh, perfectly cooked and not swimming in sauce or mayo. $25 so not the cheapest we had ($21-29 range). And a small extra touch - Cape Cod brand kettle chips instead of the standard boring Lays chips we had everywhere else. Ice cream was also very good and reasonably priced. Flavorful, fresh and firm. Service was friendly. Not much on the ambiance since a few tables right on the street, but there...read full review