Italian Restaurants near Windham

“We went Sat and were very disappoined. It took 15 min to get a 3rd set of silverware. The chicken parm was burned. The credit cards were reversed and we waited 45 min for it to be corrected.“

“Family friendly market in WIndham“

“Food and service is a hit or miss. A few times, the crazy bread I got seemed smaller than normal. I have noticed that the pizza was very flat like it didn't proof. The people working have been for the most part okay. I have had a few times where I saw a girl pull pizzas out by flicking the pan up to toss the pizza out of the pan, which also caused the toppings to get all over the crust. I haven't seen her there for a while so I haven't had any mess ups do to that for a while.“

“Excellent all around. I would describe the menu as Italian-inspired, given that their big thing is their homemade pasta, but it’s more of a modern menu as opposed to one of traditional Italian dishes.

For the starters: the gnocco fritto are a MUST-have. The roasted black salsify root was also fantastic - salsify root being a root veggie that’s something between a parsnip and a potato. That plate was practically licked clean.

For the mains: we went all pasta, though they do have a few larger “secondi” type plates. We had the sunchoke & goat cheese agnolotti (stuffed pasta), and the rigatoni with beef & pork ragù bolognese.

They had a good drink menu with a nice array of wines and cocktails, as well as nice mocktails.

For dessert, we had the plum sorbetto, as well as the best-dressed carrot cake I’ve ever had (topped with candied pecans, fresh blood orange, candied ginger, candied zest, rosemary).

We sat at the chef’s counter, which was amazing, because we got to see all of our food being prepared. We observed a super well-run kitchen, with staff seeming to be enjoying themselves, which made the food taste even better, as we were able to appreciate the effort put into it. It was also fun to see the other dishes on the menu being prepared and plated, plus being able to see what the most popular dishes were (the gnocco fritto was a common one, and for good reason).

The atmosphere and service were both great - our server was Molly.

Be prepared to spend (after tax & tip) upwards of $100 per person - note though that we ordered starters, mains, drinks, and desserts though, so quite a full sampling.“

“we had a very nice dinner“

“Casa Novello was the location for my daughter's baby shower. It was amazing! Hope was wonderful to work with. So responsive with texts, and made me feel so confident that all would be well. The food was outstanding, and drinks were enjoyed by all. The restaurant' atmosphere is so welcoming and cozy. It was the perfect location. Our guests are just raving about the shower. Thank you, Hope and staff!!!“

“Five diners in our party--aged six to sixty-five--all left stuffed and happy! Fantastic pizza, playful and delicious garlic bread, wonderful pasta, fabulous service. Highly recommend!

Kid-friendliness: A pizza option and a spaghetti option... what more could a kiddo want?“

“Wonderful environment excellent service and impeccable food! What an amazing experience in such a historic home. Matt was our server and he did not disappoint! Every thing we ordered was so flavourful and the wine suggested was spot on! Coming all the way from Coral springs Florida this was a wonderful dinner experience south Florida could learn a thing or two!!“

“Cozy and inviting dining rooms. The food was delicious, every plate from chicory salad, bread asparagus and the entrees! All were absolutely delicious. Just as important were the staff. So so friendly and happy. You can tell they all really like working here and value every detail. Would highly recommend this place for date night!“

“Had a Greek salad. it was so fresh and good I didn't even need dressing. Interesting concept. basically carry out but with dining room. Nice and clean and super friendly. Subs or standard Italian.“

“Thank you for providing pizzas for King Middle School’s Winter Dance last Friday! The students appreciated it so much!“

“Best pizza we have EVER had. Fries great too“

“We LOVE an evening out at Tuscan Table, South Portland location in fact we go every week! Our preferred place to sit is at the bar where we know we will always get excellent service from our favorite server Sammy. Sammy always greets us with a friendly smile and remembers what we like to drink, she also remembers how we like each dish that is ordered prepared even if we forget to ask, she knows. Sammy makes eating at the Tuscan a wonderful welcoming experience every time. Thank you Sammy and see you next week! Nancy & Eddie“

“I would give this a 10 if I could.
Our server, Brittany, was amazing. She was friendly, outgoing, quick, helpful, and very patient, as it took us a bit to decide what we wanted. Everything looked so good on the menu.
Kudos to the chef. You cooked our food to perfection.“

“Couldn't have been a better meal. The service was a 10...ask for Cassi as a server. The support staff was so helpful. Our food couldn't have been better. Great portions with a great price. My girlfriend's birthday was celebrated that night. The whole restaurant sang her Happy Birthday. Best meal we have had in Portland. The owners deserve a pat on the back.“