50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Windham

“all the pizza is good! they offer regional styles and they do them well!!!!! great staff and ownership“

“Our party was split and half the people really loved their food and half the people thought it was okay. The service was slow. Disappointed they charged extra for a side of ranch with chicken tenders for a kid (which they didn’t bring out for 10-15 min after the food),“

“We went Sat and were very disappoined. It took 15 min to get a 3rd set of silverware. The chicken parm was burned. The credit cards were reversed and we waited 45 min for it to be corrected.“

“Great service. The best pizza.“

“We opted for Sammie's and calzones for our lunch and we're not disappointed! Delish southwest chicken wrap, tasty chicken sandwich and calzone. Was looking for a dry cider and this one didn't disappoint! We had incredible service and a great time. They also pour a mean Guinness!“

“Family friendly market in WIndham“

“Our catering order today was excellent, as it has been other times for our employee lunches. Thank you to the team there! ⭐️“

“The pizza was very delicious. The atmosphere was amazing. Customer service was awesome. I picked up some pizzas on New Year’s Eve afternoon and there were the cutest sweetest employees working thank you for being the best Dominos 🍕🍕🍕🍕🍗 and my neighborhood.“

“This place is a gem. Once a month, I treat myself to a little late Sunday night Italian Cheesy Bread, and every time, without fail, everything was a dream.

Easy online ordering was easy as a pre-made pie, the food has been tops and grand, and the gentleman working behind the counter is a prince among thieves.

Thank you, Little Caesars for making my Sundays wonderful. Please, keep staying awesome.“

“Popped in on a whim for happy hour and we were so glad we stumbled on this restaurant! I had a spicy marg and my husband had a charro negro, both were delicious and full strength! We had the perfect snacks to go with it - salsas and tostados and some fish tacos. The staff were warm and friendly. Would recommend!“

“I have been going here since I was very young. Maria has always been the hardest dedicated worker I've ever met. She always made the pizza perfect. Always recommended. I watched Maria's kids grow up into young adults and work there as well. Be in soon Maria“

“Just the best 🥰 I recommend they’re made to order cannolis and raspberry linzers 😍 and the best types of people work here too, just so freaking kind!!“

“Went for a lupper date with my husband on the referral of a friend. Had the Natalie house drink which was well balanced and bright for us gin lovers. Enjoyed thier spin on Poutine with a tater tots base. Lots of goo goodness with bacon and sausage. Sausage pizza with Vodka sauce had real Greek olives and was delicious. Will be back again!“

“Some of the best beer in Southern Maine, always a ton on tap“

“While I dont normally give out 5's for thick crust pizza, The Beacon does a great job with their thicker pies. Well coked great toppings and dough is thick but great tasting and not, well, doughy! I had a sausage and onion pie 16" for 25$ (inc 15% tip) amd it could easily feed 3 hungry people or 4 not ravenous...point being, great value for money. Thanks Beacon!“

“Claire didn’t recognize me, Jake was keeping it metal and being the man, Nico nailed the sandwich, pizza was great 6 stars def will go back“

“Love Sev’s!!! Great beer selection, and amazing pizzas! Staff is always friendly and check out is always quick!! I tell all my friends to grab an authentic Italian from Sev’s in Westbrook!“

“A hidden gem for when you don’t want to head into the old port. :)“

“Best pizza around. Try the hamburger with pepperoni onion and mushroom! Meatballs are great too! Cold beers next door too!“

“The young people who work here give stellar customer service. They are appropriately friendly and engaging. Bravo to ownership and managers for this!!!“

“Found this great restaurant while on vacation. The Acadia Apple /Turkey sandwich is on my top five best ever sandwiches. Absolute perfection. My hubby fell in love with his salad and not knowing how large the wrap was he tried to eat that too. Oh my this place is on my must return list. I have to work my way through the rest of the menu“

“Fire pizza service everything about this place is awesome if you haven’t tried not tried it your losing out amazing food get some“

“We had our first Angelo’s pizza tonight. It was a Carbonara pizza and it was fabulous! It was the best pizza I have had in a long time. Delicious and cooked to perfection, NOT over cooked! We loved the crust, thin-ish but not flat bread thin with a nice rim, not 1/2 the slice! Thank you, delicious! We will be back, for sure!!“

“Moved to Gray recently , was asking around about pizza, as I grew up in NY and we eat it 3 days a week down there . Anyway , I ordered a plain cheese pizza the first time I went, and that was so good I just did the same tonight. Very close to NY style pizza, more specifically long island pizza where I grew up.. They definitely put some good stuff in their dough as it is seriously on another level of anywhere else I been in 13 years in Maine . And it being a HOP, looking forward to getting the Gyro next!!“

“…Yesterday-finally-my ladyfriend & I got our 1st 2 large Chicken Parm “bucket list” subs with melty Provolone: They have now since taken the pole position of bein our newest local favorites !!! D says the counter lady was super nice & hopes she got herself one made for din din 🇮🇹“

“Brought my family here for lunch this afternoon! Wonderful food and friendly! Was great place to come sit with the family, also has take out! We will for sure be back! 💚“

“Great service, lovely atmosphere and the food was delicious. Pizza was the star of the show, but the rye cavatelli was a nice, bright dish.

Pasta serving was too small for the rather high price, but supporting quality neighborhood places like this outweighs the slight wincing at the final bill.“

“We went to Blaze Pizza in Portland Maine today. What a great experience. They overheard us mention it was my son’s birthday and when we were almost finished, they brought us free deserts and said did we hear it’s someone’s birthday? The staff was so amazingly sweet. So welcoming. I can’t say enough great things about this first time experience.“

“I got the Greek Pizza last night. 10 in size which is the only size. Had it to go and once I got to it for eating it was delicious. Cost about $17 which at first I thought was a lot. But it is worth the money for me. When you park there please don't park behind the building, that is for employees. I found out by having a unpleasant talk with the manager/owner. No hard feelings sir“

“karaoke Wednesday and Thursday nights. Very chill people to hang around with, my favorite place in town to have some beers!“

“Always good energy when I step in the establishment, and that is because each and every employee provides a rare kind of comfortability that you can't find most places that involve customer service. I appreciate their food and energy keep up the good work.“

“we had a very nice dinner“

“I’ve been searching for a bbq chicken pizza that compared to the first bbq chicken pizza I fell in love with up in Greenville when I was a kid. Jess n’ Nicks has delivered ! Best bbq chicken pizza I’ve had in so long!“

“Food came on time as promised, there were two things out of stock, but they called me before the delivery to offer substitutions or refunds, The girl that called was very professional and I believe went above and beyond to make my delivery what I wanted.“

“I LOVE THIS PLACE. The Salad bar is awesome and inexpensive and the sandwiches are amazing. I go all the time.“

“We do not eat out or order out. BUT for our 60th wedding anniversary. we chose Otto' Pizza. The best pizza we have ever had !“

“Our family had a great meal tonight. We had a large pizza, small pizza, gluten free pizza, and a Caesar salad. They were quite busy when we arrived but our food came out quickly and everything was great! The sodas were nice and cold and bathroom was well kept. Their team in the kitchen seemed to be working well together.“

“I enjoy the people that work very hard and the interactions with consumers. The food is great.“

“Never a bad experience here.“

“My family loves this place…food is delicious …tried Many menu options.. host always warm, Welcoming and fun, and prices Family friendly!!!“

“Our server was Sal and Sal was great. For clarity, we went on a week night with very few people in the restaurant - just before close, so wasn’t sure what to expect. We were a table of 6 with 6 different pizzas. Food was good and all of it came out at the same time. Sal had a nice balance of helpful but not overbearing.“

“Fresh, hot pizza (and other assorted goodies)! The employees are always friendly, sometimes they look a little frazzled but don't we all at times. There is no dine- in so the atmosphere is merely the sweet smell of pizza in the oven, a cash register and a cooler full of soda. lol“

“The food is awesome and for those that are not willing to wait if they are making it fresh you are going to miss out The best Italians ever“

“We stayed at the Westin Hotel in Portland, ME. The pizza was amazing and the service was great! It was cooked perfectly and had a nice crunch to it! No fork/knife needed.“

“I love this place. They have a humble little spot, stocked with a great variety of quick grab items. For over a decade, I’ve always had pleasant encounters with the owner and his son—and my goodness, this community sure does miss Erica ♥️“

“Thank you for providing pizzas for King Middle School’s Winter Dance last Friday! The students appreciated it so much!“

“really good food here and professional staff“

“If we’re being honest, moving to a new city comes with one very important question: where’s the go-to pizza spot? After one visit to OTTO Pizza in downtown Portland, I can confidently say, we’ve already found ours.

This may genuinely be some of the best pizza we’ve ever had. The seasonal pie right now is absolutely phenomenal. You can tell they don’t just make pizza here, they craft it.

What truly made the experience memorable though was the service. Cat, our waitress, was incredible. Warm, attentive, and thoughtful. She offered great recommendations and made us feel so genuinely welcomed to OTTO and Portland. That kind of hospitality makes a lasting impression.

Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice (which is a great deal, by the way) or sitting down to share a full pie, OTTO strikes that rare balance. It feels like an elevated version of your favorite childhood pizzeria, comforting, nostalgic, but undeniably high quality.

Safe to say, we’re completely spoiled now. This will absolutely be a regular spot for us, and I can’t recommend it highly enough.“

“Loved the loaded steak pizza!“

“Just happened to stop here yesterday for a late lunch! So glad we did! My husband has had their pizza before I hadn't. The pizza was soo delicious! I ordered a Pineapple, Bacon & Hot Honey small pizza. It was one of the BEST pizza's I've ever eaten! I didn't take my receipt so I can't remember our waiters name & I wish I could because he deserves a shout out! He was amazing!! Would definitely recommend! & will definitely be back!“