New American Restaurants near Yarmouth, ME

“Our family had an amazing time at Gather last Friday. Krista was great to work with and helped organize a reservation for our party of 19 people. She was very accommodating and quick to respond to any requests. The spot is beautiful and the food was delicious. I think our group tried almost everything on the menu and everyone was very impressed. The food, drinks and atmosphere were all perfect. I would highly recommend for a date night or a private event. You won't be disappointed.😊“

“The menu is creative and interesting and every dish delivered was wonderful. Our entrees took a long time and at least two of them arrived cold (but still delicious.) The noise level is high, but it always is and matches this venerable restaurant's energy level.“

“Impossibly wonderful food and vibe! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Had brunch at this restaurant and it was fantastic!! The atmosphere in the hotel is cute. It used to be the newspaper building, so they carried this theme through. They have vintage typewriters on the wall in the lobby, so cute. Our server, Anna, was so sweet and kind! Food was sooooooo good. I would highly recommend this place. This is off the beaten path in Portland, it’s not in the port area, but the walk is so pretty to get to it. You can go up to exchange street, with so many cute shops. Definitely worth the short walk, especially if you’re there on a Sunday and all the other brunch places by the port have 45 minute waits.“

“We had such a delicious meal at Scales! Everything was presented beautifully and tasted excellent. Service was on-point and the atmosphere is super chic. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone in the Portland area!“

“Last month our flight to Portland was delayed a considerable amount of time due to weather issues and it looked as though we would not be able to make our 5p.m. reservation. My daughter called from the tarmac in Boston where we were rerouted and refueled and explained the situation. The hostess, Susie, was very understanding and compassionate And said that even though our table was booked for another party a 7, we should come in and she would see what she could do. We got there late but Susie greeted us warmly and told us not to worry about being rushed that she had arranged things so no one would be inconvenienced. The atmosphere was warm and cozy; the food so very delicious and our waitperson, Anika, was the best. Atmosphere, impeccable service, food and warmth all rate 5 stars and another visit next time we are in Portland.“

“Absolutely amazing! Each time we visit I am reminded of why it’s my favorite restaurant ever - the food, the service and the atmosphere are all top notch, every time! Thank you!“

“Awesome fries with lots of sauces“

“Wonderful service and excellent food!“

“If you can call the ocean a “farm” this is the place. I have enjoyed this place at least 40 years. I always pick up lobster packed to go from them. They always tell you to eat them within 12 hours. I picked them up Wednesday AM and cooked them Thursday night. A couple of them were sluggish but still alive. I fully anticipated to loose at lease one but all 16 were cooked and enjoyed by many. I did steam them briefly to reheat and even that worked great. Tonight I just plopped the lobster in the corn water while we ate the corn. All I can say is thank you! Your place is amazing! And the view is priceless. BTW if you dine - take cash 💰 NO CC accepted. And have dessert! 💝💝💝“

“Great cocktails, food, and atmosphere! We will be back!“

“Every dish was fantastic!“

“karaoke Wednesday and Thursday nights. Very chill people to hang around with, my favorite place in town to have some beers!“

“Cocktails were not our favorite. The jalapeño margarita was bitter didn’t taste good. Enjoyed the hummus good price point generous portion. Cozy lounge good music and plenty of seating available. Nice ambiance and excellent customer service.“

“This place is the definition of real food done right. Everything on the plate is fresh, intentional, and full of flavor-no filler, no fluff. You can actually taste the quality. It’s beautiful, flavorful food that hits differently. The kind of place that makes you want to slow down and enjoy each and every bite.“

“Amazing from start to finish ~ love the decor and everything we tried was delicious 🦩“

“I loved the place and the good. Great service and atmosphere too. Joe from Virginia Beach.“

“Grace in Portland, Maine, is a venue that blends historic charm with modern elegance, offering a truly unique setting for weddings and special events. Housed in a beautifully restored former church, Grace combines soaring cathedral ceilings, original stained-glass windows, and a stunning mezzanine, creating an awe-inspiring atmosphere that leaves a lasting impression. It easily lends itself to a bouquet toss.

The staff at Grace is nothing short of phenomenal. Their attention to detail and commitment to creating a seamless event experience make planning stress-free. They go above and beyond to accommodate every request and ensure the day unfolds perfectly.

The food is another highlight. Their catering team delivers an impressive menu that pairs elevated flavors with fresh, local ingredients. Guests raved about the inventive dishes and impeccable presentation. See the Lobster Rangoon at this Maine wedding shot by JMorr Photo

What sets Grace apart is its ability to feel both grand and intimate. Whether hosting a large wedding or a smaller, more private celebration, the venue can adapt beautifully. The combination of breathtaking architecture and exceptional service makes Grace a top-tier choice for any couple looking for a one-of-a-kind experience in the heart of Portland.“

“Amazing place, food and service! We ordered a lot of pizza for my son’s birthday party and they made it so easy. I ordered and paid over the phone and my husband picked it up. Everyone at the party loved the pizza and we are so thankful they could accommodate a large order of take out pizzas! Thank you for helping my son’s birthday party go off amazingly!“

“Rivalries is one of our go-to spots for great food, a welcoming vibe, and catching the game in a fun atmosphere. Whether we’re meeting friends, unwinding after a long day of moves, or grabbing lunch during the workday, the experience is always solid.

The menu hits the mark every time—fresh, consistent, and with plenty of options. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the space has just the right mix of comfort and energy.

As a local business ourselves, we appreciate places like Rivalries that continue to deliver a great experience, time and time again.

— S.B. Taylor Transport“

“Went for the music, stayed for the laughs. Fun place. Chowder was delicious. Us Minnesotains were not so sure on the brown ketchup though 😆“

“Have always loved Bayside Bowl, but their parking situation is a disappointment. Admittedly it was clearly my fault for not paying attention to the parking signs, but my car was towed yesterday from the premises and I was charged $260 cash to retrieve my car from Riverside Street in Portland. It was my birthday and we were celebrating first at Batson River and then we planned to go to Bayside's rooftop deck to continue our evening's celebrations. After leaving the distillery, after only one hour, I was shocked to see that my car had been towed away. Again, my fault. Please be mindful of the parking signs if you visit this establishment. The money charged for an accidental parking violation is greedily exorbitant and predatory in my opinion. I hope that the owner is not profiting from this, and if he or she is, I hope they are putting the money towards a good community cause to better the Portland Bayside neighborhood.“

“I am sure Councilman Dion and Mrs Dion were just having an off night - my wife and Granddaughter and I had dinner on Friday night and my veal parmigiana was awesome and my wife’s asparagus and Gorgonzola ravioli was as great ! Jim our waiter must have lit the table candle 50 times for my granddaughter to keep blowing it out ! Brunos rocks !“

“Came to Dockside Grill for our first dinner in Maine and were seated quickly (had reservations). The drinks were great, and the food was delicious — the Caesar salad with scallops was absolutely amazing.

Of course, we had to try the Bang Bang Shrimp and the chowder — both lived up to the hype and did not disappoint.

Overall, it was a great experience. While the service was a little slow, the place was packed — so just be patient and enjoy the time with family and friends.

Definitely recommend checking this place out — and don’t miss the Lobster Grilled Cheese!“

“So I stepped into a bear-trap on social media in the form of a fresh-from-the-oven squash pizza - and immediately smashed out the number on my phone. 10/10 would recommend! This pizza was delicious“

“Burt was our server and helped us make excellent choices. Nachos were delicious for an appetizer. My dirty martini was just right! My husband had grilled salmon and I had broiled haddock which were both perfect! Easy to get seated. I would definitely recommend to anyone visiting the Freeport /Yarmouth area.“

“Caroline was so helpful to me in arranging my wife's surprise birthday party. It was perfect and my wife and friends had such a great time! The food rocks and service is awesome! Thank you so much!“