New American Restaurants near Old Orchard Beach, ME

“Fresh and delicious! Have a margarita! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Big Daddy’s has the best food, staff and atmosphere. I could go on and on….but there’s no need to. Simply the BEST! Never had a bad meal, drink or bad experience.“

“What a great find! Booked a table after reading the reviews. The meal was perfect, the new to us cocktail was potent and delicious, the servers were amazing, the owner was gracious. Thank you Barb, Dot and Dawn. We will be returning next year at the same time to celebrate my 70th!! Seems it will only allow 1 picture.“

“I come specifically to Old Orchard Beach every year just to eat at The Bell Buoy. They serve the best seafood and are very closely located to the pier and beach. You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu, but the lobster is a huge selling point. Friendly staff, great food, good service, and a mere walking distance from many of the other attractions. I cannot recommend this place enough, and hope it remains open forever.“

“After reading a mix of positive and negative reviews, we decided to give Tiki Bar a try ourselves. The food was excellent! But the biggest surprise was the service. In a busy, seat-yourself restaurant, it would be easy for things to fall through the cracks, we saw two women working an entire patio and they didn’t miss.

Anna was our server, and she was exceptional. She offered great recommendations, drinks never empty, and even noticed when my child’s water needed to be refilled. A couple next to us had a complaint about a dish and it was handled flawlessly.

While the food was very good (get the mussels and the haddock sandwich) the standout part of the experience was the service and the atmosphere. It was genuinely impressive to watch. We’ll definitely be back.“