New American Restaurants near Cape Elizabeth, ME

Sea Glass American • $$$
40 Bowery Beach Rd, Cape Elizabeth

Customers` Favorites

Farm House with Eggs Benedict
Gnocchi

“The Sea Glass Restaurant was always one of my parents' favorites in the greater Portland area. It was an easy selection to know we wanted to have a reception there following my Mom's Memorial Service. Hana, the events and catering manager, was wonderful to work with. She listened with such great compassion and ensured every detail was attended to. Jessica and Andre were amazing servers... attentive without being intrusive. Toward the end, Jessica volunteered that she overheard so many wonderful stories about my Mom. Just the right thing to say! And, BTW, the food was delicious and the gathering space perfect. I can't recommend Sea Glass more highly!“

4.5 Superb48 Reviews
The Good Table New American • $$
527 Ocean House Rd, Cape Elizabeth

Customers` Favorites

Eggs Benedict
Cinnamon Buns
Fish

“We visited The Good Table Restaurant with a large party that included children. We were seated on the back, indoor porch, which was perfect. It was light and airy and actually felt almost like we were eating outdoors. I tried the side Greek Salad, which was excellent and the Baked Haddock as my main course. The fish was fantastic. It came with very well prepared mashed potatoes. Others at the table had clam chowder (reported to be great) and scallops ( I tasted them and they were awesome), lobster risotto, lobster pasta, mussels and a burger. Everyone was happy with their food. For dessert we tried several including the pound cake with strawberries, bread pudding, cheese cake and almond cupcake. All fantastic! There is a children's menu. We were told by our friends from Portland that the restaurant was recently sold. We can only hope that the new owners carry over some menu items and continue to provide such excellent food and good service!“

4 Good44 Reviews
3

Scales

Scales Seafood • $$$
68 Commercial St, Portland - 6.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cloverleaf Rolls with Garlic Butter
Scales Warm Buttered Lobster Roll
Steamed Clams with Drawn Butter
Grilled Octopus Chorizo
Grilled Whole Branzino
Steamed Maine Lobster
Butterscotch Sundae
Pan Roasted Halibut
Maine Clam Chowder
Seared Scallops

“We had a great time for lunch in a great setting by the water. Lots of windows and a cool space. Our server Sofia did a great job with recommendations and service that really enhanced our experience. The scallops on half shell were so fresh and sweet. The octopus was tender and flavorful. And my son had a lobster roll where the buttered toasted bun got just as many accolades as the tender lobster lol. Thank you alll for a great time with my son!“

4.5 Superb980 Reviews
Fore Street Restaurant New American • $$$
288 Fore St, Portland - 7.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Aroostook County Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Fore Street's Dry Rubbed Pork Loin
Oysters Front and Clams Back
Bourbon Brined Half Chicken
Day Boat Scallops
Sourdough Bread
Halibut Filet
Hanger Steak
Cornbread
Seafood

“I was in the area on other business and this old warehouse building looking like it’s built with parts of wrecked ships that washed on at waterfront. I’m like what kind of cool building is this?? It turned out to be restaurant that I cant wait to try! I don’t know if they’ll let an old pirate like me in but I’m gonna give it try! Full review coming soon!“

4.6 Superb530 Reviews
Duckfat American • $$
43 Middle St, Portland - 7.13 miles

Customers` Favorites

Donut Holes with Duckfat Caramel
House Smoked Pulled Pork Cubano
Roasted Pork Belly Panino
Poutine with Duck Confit
Flight of Sauces
Cubano Sandwich
Truffle Ketchup
Brussel Sprouts
Creamsicle Soda
Belgian Fries

“Duckfat has always and will always knock it out of the park. It's out top place to visit when we're in Portland. For first timers...the restaurant is very small with communal tables so it is very likely that as a small group you will be seated with others. The outdoor dining was available and we had the perfect day for it. The fries are the obvious choice here, but spring for the poutine with a duck egg on top. You won't regret it. I'm a sucker for a Cuban on any menu but THIS one is literally the best I've ever had and that was even without the pickles (I have an allergy ?). Worth noting that instead of the typical ham in the sandwich, they exchanged it for soppresatta. While that's not a typical go to for me, I trust in anything they make and it went together SO well. I can't wait to make it back already and it's only been a week.Parking: There is a very small lot for the building if you're lucky to find a spot. We got there within 30 mins of opening and a few were still open. There is also street parking and a couple nearby garages. Portland is a great walking city anyways so find any lot in/near Old Port and you can pretty much walk everywhere you want to go.“

4.6 Superb265 Reviews
6

Twelve

Twelve American
115 Thames St, Portland - 7.15 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll on Laminated Croissant
Macaron Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate Pudding for
Uni in Lobster Stew
Parker House Rolls
Chocolate Sundae
Chips and Dip
Apple Crisp
Milk Bread
Monkfish

“This is a great up and coming restaurant in Portland. They have a few minor details to work on, but overall a very good experience. The wait staff is clearly working on Michelin style service techniques including uniform plate setting at tables, napkin etiquette, and plate presentation. Our waiter was overall good, but a bit cold and stand-offish. The menu has some great local ingredients, but it seems like they are trying too hard to get the buzz words in the menu. For example I enjoyed the Cauliflower Gratin and the menu description included local uni and lobster. The flavors of the cauliflower and the sauce were strong and really overwhelmed the delicate flavor of local uni to the point that the uni just took a back seat. The dry aged duck was wonderful and the aging process truly brought a unique texture and moistness to the duck. I also sampled the Atlantic cod dish which had a delicious broth, but was served with charred union which just did not match the delicate flavors of the broth. Overall a very good experience and worth a visit. I expect they will only get better with time.“

4.7 Superb121 Reviews
Wayside Tavern American • $$$
747 Congress St, Portland - 7.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Whole Wheat Tonnarelli
Foie Gras Truffles
Broiled Oysters
Roasted Chicken
Tiramisu

“Super cozy, fun new eatery in the West End. We truly enjoyed the food, and the service was both friendly and professional. The foie gras "truffle" was rich, sweet, and nutty - a perfect combination. And only get one each! It's too rich to have any more. The fried sun-chokes were perfectly crisp, with a real "roasted" flavor. Cabbage salad was a table favorite; crunchy and rich, yet almost light in a way. The pork schnitzel was absolutely incredible - breaded crisp with thinly sliced greens on top. My only small criticism was that the aïoli sauce under the pork schnitzel didn't add to the flavor, and I didn't think it was appropriate for that dish. It also tended to get the entire bottom of the pork moist, instead of keeping it super crisp as it should be. We still really loved it, and would order it again, but I would ask that they leave off the tonnato-aïoli the next time. The wine list (per my sommelier wife) was extremely interesting, creative, and fun. Plenty of wines by the glass, along with just a ton of interesting bottles to choose from. Lastly, they had only two dessert choices, neither of which jumped out at us. Tiramisu and chocolate mousse? I was hoping for something with sweet local fruit, maybe a savory option, but not two traditional European sweets. Maybe they'll update the menu for summer. Overall, an absolutely terrific place for a cozy, delicious meal with friends or family.“

4.8 Superb85 Reviews
Bread & Friends New American • $
505 Fore St, Portland - 6.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Charred Rainbow Carrots
Everything Pull Apart
Herb & Fennel Salad
Cannoli Croissant
Orange Cream Soda
Jamón Iberico
Crispy Potatoes
Demi Baguette
'Deviled' Egg
French Toast

“This place is a must go for breakfast. Great staff and service, excellent food. I would give it 6 stars if I could. The bread and viennoiseries are expertly done. Everything on the menu is excellent, I would also say that the scrambled eggs is a must have.Big thanks to the staff and see you next time we come to Portland!“

4.8 Superb150 Reviews
Street & Co Seafood • $$$
33 Wharf St, Portland - 6.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Octopus with Butter Bean Puree Chili Oil and Crispy Garlic
Mussels Provencal with Garlic White Wine and Butter
Whole Grilled Branzino over Winter Vegetable Stew
Grilled Lobster with Linguini Garlic and Butter
Octopus Appetizer
Clams White Sauce
Lobster Linguine
Lobster Diavolo
Shrimp Linguine
Sole Francaise

“Amazing experience. We called to make reservations the day of and they were fully booked but told us we could try as a walk-in so we did. We were very lucky they had three seats available at the bar when we showed up at 7:30pm. The bartender was very friendly and really made sure we had everything we needed. We started with a special for our appetizer, a cod fish mashed potato spread and it was DELICIOUS! My daughter has the seared tuna and she loved it. My husband had the linguini and clams and it was very flavorful. The portions were also pretty generous. My swordfish was also cooked to perfection. We would definitely return. The bar is in a big open lounge area so it was a nice setup. And everyone was very friendly.“

4.4 Superb484 Reviews
North 43 Bistro New American • $$
1 Spring Point Dr, South Portland - 6.09 miles

Customers` Favorites

Honey Sriracha Glazed Shrimp with Local Greens
Cafe Bistro

“I've worked with Stephanie on two events in her upstairs dining room -- one for 20 people and one for 32. She and her staff exceeded my expectations both times and were delightful to deal with at every phase. The dining room is private with spectacular views through the glass doors. The deck is perfect for pre-dinner cocktails and the entire experience is high-end. If you need to dazzle a group, Stephanie will make you look good.“

4.5 Superb55 Reviews
Broken Arrow Tapas/Small Plates • $$$
545 Congress St, Portland - 7.06 miles

Customers` Favorites

Maine Bluefin Tuna Crudo
Smashed Maine Potatoes
Smashed Potatoes
Burrata

“My cousin and I decided to try this place, during Maine Restaurant Week, because we've never been here before.We so impressed with our lovely hostess/server Elizabeth, she treated us like queens! She's the primary reason I would return!Close second is the food. OUTSTANDING!It met all my dietary needs, and it was so fresh and beautifully presented. Absolutely delicious, we licked the plates clean!My cocktail was yummy and beautifully presented too.Such a beautiful atmosphere, and I can't wait to return this summer“

4.4 Superb87 Reviews
The Armory Lounge Lounges • $$$
20 Milk St, Portland - 6.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gin Blossom
Lemon Drop

“Located within the Portland Regency Hotel but clearly a spot for local after work patrons as well. Food is reliable and consistently good, as is the service. Atmosphere is comfortable but can get a little loud sometimes - a happy kind of loud. Recommend.“

4.6 Superb32 Reviews
Davids 388 Restaurant American • $$$
388 Cottage Rd, Portland - 5.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Beef Carpaccio & Crispy Polenta GF
Filet Mignon with Mushrooms
Brussels Sprouts
Crème Brulee
Seared Tuna
Arancini
Haddock

“We have been going to this restaurant and the downtown location for 15+ years. Consistently good food, good service and comfortable setting. Our waitress was pleasant and solicitous. Apps, entrees and dessert was a 90- minute experience. Carpaccio was excellent as was my seared tuna and I split an orange crème brûlée. Two parties in our group visiting Maine from our west had seafood pappardelle and the other had the duck. The port trio was terrific with my husband giving the waitress carte blanche with the ports!“

4.5 Superb230 Reviews
The Brass Rail Bar • $
1171 Forest Ave, Portland - 9.72 miles

“All the recent bad reviews of this business is the result of them being targeted by a private facebook group of antivaxers upset about the mandate. Most do not even live in Portland. Most running the group 1k strong are the same leaving the reviews. Feel free to DM me if you'd like the receipts or the names of the people going after you.“

4.8 Superb22 Reviews
Salt Yard Cafe & Bar American • $$
285 Commercial St, Portland - 6.84 miles

Customers` Favorites

Salt Yard Breakfast Sandwich
Cinnamon French Toast
Smoked Salmon Toast
Sweet Potato Hash
Avocado Toast
Chai Waffle
Iced Latte

“We had a lovely stay at the Canopy. Per recommendations we had brunch at the Salt Yard. Our food was delicious and customer service was outstanding. Ellie made our delicious lattes and was super friendly. Will definitely come here again. Overall experience was great.“

4.3 Superb89 Reviews
Woodford Food & Beverage American • $$
660 Forest Ave, Portland - 8.54 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Brussels Sprouts with Lemon Cream Sauce
Caramel Brownie Sundae with Toasted Pecans
Fried Chicken Sandwich
Roast Half Chicken
Roasted Mushrooms
Casco Bay Mussels
Burger and Fries
Croque Madame
The Burger

“Wow. This place is absolutely wonderful. Went here for the first time ever on a date with my boyfriend. The food was so delicious and seasoned to perfection. The dessert we got was divine and the service was excellent. This is a great place to go on a little fancy dinner with your partner or to have a celebratory dinner. And the drinks are made so delicious.We got lucky and actually had a table available Saturday night, but it was packed for the most part. 11/10 will go here again.“

4.1 Good61 Reviews
Cafe Calabash Cigar Bar American • $$
425 Western Ave, South Portland - 8.39 miles

“Every time I go to a new city I try to find a nice place to have a cigar and relax. This place is JUST the spot for that. You can have coffee or liquors depending on what you want with your cigar, and the people are lovely. Wonderful atmosphere and the perfect way to kick off a vacation.“

4.6 Superb21 Reviews