Cafe Italiano at The Sweet Shop
$ • Sandwich Shops, Ice CreamAbout Cafe Italiano at The Sweet Shop
Customers' Favorites
Italian Meatballs Sub with Pepperoni
Mushroom & Black Truffle Ravioli
Grilled Chicken Bacon Bianca Pizza
Mushroom & Black Truffle Ravioli
Veggie Delight Pizza Capricciosa
Italian Veggies Pizza Bianca
Meatballs in Marinara Sauce
Chicken Bacon Pesto Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Italian Meatball Sub
Recent Reviews
167 ratings
Share your opinion about Cafe Italiano at The Sweet Shop
This restaurant is in a location which has been a gathering spot in Buchanan since 1947. Much of the original décor has been maintained but some parts of the interior have been modernized to satisfy current foods. The owners and staff are pleasant, aim to please and work hard. It is worth a stop for the ice cream at the soda fountain, if nothing else.
Had one of the best meals ever! My husband and I each got a different sub which was AMAZING! We finished off with a slice of the berry mascarpone cake and it was the best cake I’ve ever eaten.
Great Authentic Italian cuisine, great atmosphere & staff! We tried them tonight for our Anniversary & the desserts are Amazing too! 5 stars all the way!!!!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 6PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 7PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 6PM |
Cafe Italiano at The Sweet Shop is a charming, beautifully restored spot with a wonderful old-school atmosphere that offers classic Italian sandwiches, small pizzas, gelato, and desserts. Customers praise the pizza for its delicious taste, good sauce, and generous toppings. The sandwiches, pasta, and coffee, especially the iced coffee and specialty drinks like the Toffee Espresso milkshake, are also highly enjoyed. Visitors frequently mention the gelato, ice cream, and spumoni as favorites, adding to the delightful experience. The family is very kind, and guests feel welcomed in a friendly and sociable atmosphere. The decor is adorable, and the overall environment is cozy and inviting. Recent visitors recommend trying the handmade cherry phosphate soda and highlight that the restaurant is worth the visit. Service is consistently praised, making it a great place to enjoy a delicious meal whenever in town.