Bakeries near Ithaca

Hearthstone Oven Bakery • $
126 S Pine River St, Ithaca

Customers` Favorites

Assorted Flavors of Homemade Cookies
Spinach and Artichoke Panini
Raspberry Cream Cheese Rolls
Peanut Butter and Jelly
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Breakfast Sandwich
Biscuits and Gravy
Chicken Pot Pie
Raspberry Cream

“Great place to eat. Portions are nice size. Prices are reasonable. All homemade food. Bakery has wonderful breads, cookies, and pies. Run by Mennonites. We will definitely go back.Parking: Parking next door, and on the street. No paid parking. Handicap parking in front on the street.“

4.9 Superb83 Reviews
Country Bakery Bakery • $
7978 S Ely Hwy, Middleton - 9.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Cookies
Cinnamon Rolls

“I have passed by this place a hundred times, but always after it was regular business hours and closed! I lucked out on this particular trip, but made it right at closing time! While there were virtually only a few cookies left the owner said she had some baked cinnamon rolls in the freezer. I got a couple of cookies that were good, but the cinnamon rolls were unbelievably delicious for breakfast the next day! Maybe the best I've had since I sold my own bakery in 1976! Do stop in if you are in the area... If you don't see what you want, ask if they have any of the cinnamon rolls in the freezer! You'll thank me if you do! ?“

4.8 Superb15 Reviews
Cindy Lou's Sweet Creations Custom Cakes • $
125 E Superior St, Alma - 6.6 miles

“I called to order a stress snack basket for my daughter for finals at Alma College and the lady that answered was very knowledgeable, friendly and helpful! I paid over the phone, after we discussed what would be included in the basket and I had arranged for a friend to pick it up. It was gorgeous and had unbelievably yummy decorated Christmas cookies, bars, popcorn and candies! My daughter was surprised and so happy to get it! They did a fabulous job and I will be ordering again!!“

4.3 Superb12 Reviews
Sweet Lilly's Cakes Bakery •
4303 W Harrison Rd, Alma

“Sweet Lilly’s Cakes provided a small 2-tier cake(cherry chip with vanilla buttercream) and 300 cupcakes(chocolate, vanilla and cherry chip with vanilla buttercream) for my wedding in July 2023. Cake tasted phenomenal and the presentation was beautiful. I gave faux florals for her to work with and asked her to surprise me and it turned out better than imagined. Was always punctual with communication and answered any questions we had. I couldn’t have asked for a better small business to provide my wedding cake. Would recommend to anyone for all your cake needs!“

5 Superb2 Reviews
Tim Hortons Donuts • $
7642 N Alger Rd, Alma

Customers` Favorites

Biscuit Breakfast Sandwich
Bagel Breakfast Sandwich
Boston Cream Donut
Iced Capp Supreme
Croissant

“Hands down, the best fast food in Alma. The people that work here are the absolute best and I can always count on them to cheer up my day. I’ve never once gotten a wrong order and everything else I order is always super fresh and delicious. 5 starts to Tim’s of Alma!! ♥️♥️“

3.4 Good33 Reviews
Carolyn's Cakes Bakery •
125 E Superior St, Alma
0 Na0 Reviews

Ithaca’s related cuisines