Custom Cakes near Kalamazoo, MI

“This is our go to bakery for birthday cakes and Amy made our wedding cake!
I was hoping they would make both our son's Wedding cakes too, if our sons wanted. I suggested they come try samples, but now costs for each sample when used to be free so to try all options-spending a lot of money just to try. They answer the phone so that is a plus, however some of staff do not know answers and don't come to register promptly when at counter.“

“I really like this place! They answer their phone and have friendly staff. I love their cheesecake named desire ice cream cake to pick up for birthdays when run out of time to make a cake! It is really delicious! The only thing I will say is they need more experience writing on their cakes. Each time I have asked them to do that, the letters are quite messy, and not spaced out well so looks like a child did it. This cake is especially good for summer birthdays. I also really like cake batter ice cream and take home a quart sometimes. Overall, great place and tasty treats! Thank you Cold Stone! Creamery!“

“I wish I had a picture, but I wanted to try cheesecake again, and OMWord, I got a slice of the Golden Oreo from Barrett’s.YUM!!!!! It’s not the normal super smooth cheeses cheese cake this has a beautiful texture as well as taste. I’m hooked! I’m hoping to try PB or Brownie Bottom or the PBBB next week for my bday. Goodbye summer bod! ❤️“

“I had this cake made for my daughter and it was absolutely delicious! I highly recommend love at first bite, everything I’ve ever had from Deanne has been outstanding! Never disappoints!!“

“I came here on 5/17/26 and Ashley is there by herself and I wanna say she did AMAZING me and my husband came here and my husband went in to get me ice cream bc I’m pregnant and Ashely made him feel welcomed and so much more ,she did amazing!!!!“