7 Best Italian Restaurants near New Buffalo

“The location is great and the interior is beautiful. Bathrooms are very nice and individual stalls with sinks.
Our server was fabulous. He was honest about the food and answered all our questions. He isn't a drinker but was able to provide recommendations.
Our food was awesome. Our 2.5 and 10 yr old had options and were quite pleased.
I ordered the roasted chicken, which was truly delicious. My wife ordered the rigatoni and loved every bite.
Our kids were getting kiddy so we had to skip dessert but the server brought these cookie balls things on our way out.. Class act!

Weather permitting, eating on the patio is a must. Great views and comfy seating.

All in all, this was our favorite spot as a first timer to New Buffalo.“

“Excellent atmosphere inside and out! Excellent salads, with tender generous steak chunks and one with tender generous chicken, both with wonderful dressings! Bruschetta- amazing! Kristen and bar tender teammate were perfect! Highly recommend!“

“Such a cute spot with amazing pizza, fried pickles and cookies. Our family enjoyed an outing to Villa Nova. Coming back soon!“

“The food was delicious and the atmosphere was so unique. It was beautiful all decked out for the holidays.“

“We had take out tonight for Scartozzi’s for the first time and to say that we were satisfied is an understatement. I was very impressed with the quality, taste, and portions of our food. We tried the chicken alfredo, one with fetuccini and one with bowtie pasta and both were beyond delicious; the cripsy chicken cutlet on top was perfectly cooked and so crispy and juicy and the bread that comes with the pasta is a DREAM. The caesar salad was phenomenal- the dressing and croutons are to die for. Last, we got the cheese bread which as simple as it is, was very delicious. Aside from the food, the atmosphere was so welcoming and cozy from the moment you pull into the parking lot; since it is December the decorations were so festive and beautiful, and everyone was so pleasant and nice. We have already discussed that this place will become a new weekly tradition—please keep being so amazing! Support local small businesses❤️“

“Really good food, super nice people“

“To be honest, this review may be biased... I was born in Michigan City in 1959 and grew up eating Albano's Pizza as a treat, and a treat it still is! I have lived in Florida for 41 years now, and still go to Albano's EVERY time I visit the area! So please, pay no attention to this review! It is completely one sided... God Bless the Albano's Pizza Family!“