9 Best American Restaurants near Pittsford

“This place was sold about a year ago and the buyer ran it very poorly. Anyone that had a bad experience in the last year should give it another shot. The old owner has the place back and the food is like it used to be. Very glad this place is back.“

“passed by here today by chance. food was great. (service too) we will definitely be back!“

“We visit Brooklyn every year and Poppa’s is one of our favorite places for good food and good folks!“

“Excellent food and even better staff. just moved to the area and will be making this a regular eatery!“

“My boyfriend’s band recently played here and it was such a cute place! Very homey, friendly, and a great all around atmosphere. Would love to come back!“

“Fell in love with this place on my first visit. The prices are extremely reasonable, and the food absolutely delicious. The waitress was very kind and friendly as it was my first time in town. I didn't realize they were closing about the time I showed up. But they served me anyway. You must try their patty melt! Beyond delicious!“

“Chicken pot pie is delish“

“Very few people in for a Friday night on a holiday weekend, but service was friendly, fast, and food was great. Half burrito was just the right size. Quesadilla was big enough that we took half home. Plenty of seating indoors and out. Very casual. Nice menu/selection from sandwiches and apps to fish fry, full dinners, and Taco Tuesday!

Kid-friendliness: Tables for all size groups with plenty of room, so no issue with kids who like to wander a bit“

“Excellent food smiling service“