17 Best Pizza Restaurants near Buffalo

“First time in Buffalo at this tasty mom & pop pizza. Delicious cauliflower and gluten free crust-the freshest ingredients, excellent service! The food was amazing! Five stars ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️We will definitely stop here again.“

“Delicious pizza as always, very timely and friendly service and clean store. Always plenty of parking here too! Love that they offer coupon codes on the instructions once you fill out a brief online survey. Lately it seems like they’ve been worth 25% off of any purchase of $25 or more, I believe. The “Gourmet Vegetarian” (with some customizations) is our favorite pizza here, by far!“

“Ordered delivery and the wait time was less than a half hour. So easy to use the website, simple to navigate. Used their online coupon for $6.99/ item for 2+ items.. the delivery driver was friendly, fast and came back to the door to give me the Ranch dressings. Great experience and will continue to order online when having a pizza craving.“

“I wish we had gone sooner!!Having lived in Buffalo a few years now-we never knew what we were missing out on. THE BEST PIZZA in town 100% the BEST BOWL OF CHILI in town and the ONLY place to get a Mad Mexican Burger that melts in your mouth and tastes just as good when reheated if you have leftovers. Our family would definitely recommend!!“

“Mgr Lilly absolutely made my day, our families day. My best friends mom took me many years ago she's never asked for anything and is always giving of herself. She loves a cowboy pizza but happened to mention she loves a Hawaiian pizza. She doesn't eat much nowadays. Lilly made a special size pizza for her, and she ate 2 pieces. Thank you for going over and above for us. We so appreciate.“

“LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!!! Go to Rockford stop 🌞“

“Delivery people are patient . Food always warm . Timing is great ! I didn't have the tip once.. before Christmas . I hope the patient delivery guy gave to her the night before Christmas Eve . I think he did! Thank you for great service ! Tanya “

“As usual we had fantastic food! We tried some new app’s and can not wait to try more. Fun fact, my Autistic son loved your pepperoni pizza! He eats very few kinds and the fact that he enjoyed your restaurant was great for me! We can add another place of approved places for him!! The atmosphere is beautiful and fun. Our service was top notch! Always the most important part for me. We will be back!“

“I ordered a drive-through pickup and it was ready for me when I arrived at the window.
However, when we took the pizza out of the oven, we found that the bulk of the meat toppings were all in the center of the pizza which was covered by the cheese. A more even application of the toppings would greatly enhance the dining experience.“

“Everyone is used to “chain” restaurants. It’s nice to see a local, family owned company that actually cares. Their pizza’s are always on point and their cheesy bread is amazing! Highly recommend this hidden gem of Monticello!“

“It's unfortunate that Pizza Hut decided to change their personal pan pizzas. I am not a fan of the current version. It's more hand-tossed than deep dish and doesn't taste like “Pizza Hut”. This location used to sell breadsticks and no longer sell those either. Which is also a shame. The staff is nice. The place clean. Usually you have to wait for pizza to be cooked. It's got weird hours. My teen, however, would eat here everyday if I let her.“

“Our family favorite frozen pizza“

“Top notch! I love Pizza Ranch wherever I go. Monticello is the 214th location The Legendary Pizza Ranch Guest ever visited.“

“We had a quality issue with a recent purchase, but Tyler went above and beyond to make it right. From the moment we reached out, he was professional, empathetic, and proactive. He not only resolved the issue quickly but also followed up to ensure we were completely satisfied. It’s rare to experience this level of genuine care and commitment to customer satisfaction. Tyler turned a frustrating situation into a positive one, and we're truly grateful. Exceptional service like his deserves to be recognized—thank you, Tyler!“

“We hosted our twins' 2nd Birthday in their side room recently. the staff went above and beyond for us, making sure everyone had drinks, great food, and a clean spot to sit and visit at. They made life easy for celebrating my kiddos. Everyone said their meal was fantastic and thought it was such a great deal to have the kiddos birthday there. We will definitely be doing that again!“

“Don't bother ordering EXTRA CHEESE. They'll just charge you for it.
(Update) This location went out of there way to make it right almost immediately the following day. They care about their customer service. I would recommend this location.“